twilight lovers! discussion

77 views
Eclipse Movie > Liked movie characters better than the book?

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Stephen (new)

Stephen (havan) | 22 comments Generally I like the characters in the book better than their movie incarnations and in the first two Twilight movies that was true as well.

However, today I saw Eclipse for the first time and liked Jasper better in the film than in the book. The books have always left him a bit two dimensional in my mind but the actor in Eclipse did a nice job of fleshing him out some.


I Also liked Bree Tanner and Riley better in their movie incarnations than in the Eclipse book. I've not read The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner: An Eclipse Novella The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner An Eclipse Novella by Stephenie Meyer yet so maybe some of their character development came from there, but still, nice job.


message 2: by kayla (new)

kayla  (cupcakeam0ur) | 125 comments i didnt like jaspers fake texas accent, it kept fading in and out, but his hair looked better than in the 2nd movie, idk wat they keep doin to tht poor boys hair but it is MESSED up!


message 3: by Kayla (new)

Kayla I liked Seth better in the movie. I also like Jacob better in the movies (but not just because he's so sexy... lol). I liked Jasped better in the movies I think, and yes, Bree. Umm... I like Alice better in the movies but that's it.


message 4: by Yolanda (new)

Yolanda | 7 comments I think the Eclipse movie was better than all the other movies. In fact Eclipse made me read the whole series( I still haven't read New Moon)


message 5: by Yolanda (new)

Yolanda | 7 comments Yum-Yum the Warrior wrote: "I liked Seth better in the movie. I also like Jacob better in the movies (but not just because he's so sexy... lol). I liked Jasped better in the movies I think, and yes, Bree. Umm... I like Alice ..."

Agree,Taylor Lautner does a good job with Jacob.


message 6: by Annie (new)

Annie | 15 comments I like most of the characters better in the books but I like Charlie a lot better in the movie. He is funnier and I think the actor did a good job playing him.


message 7: by Gracie (new)

Gracie Williams | 4 comments Eclipse is the best movie. The characters in the movies are awesome


message 8: by Yeehawwrodeo (new)

Yeehawwrodeo That is a close call... I think the movies are more in depth of what happens in the books, but i have seen all the movies and the books leave some parts out.. So I would have say movies are better.


message 9: by Maddie (new)

Maddie | 8 comments I like the book characters better. They turned Edward into a total jerk and Jacob into a Saint, when, in the books, it was the opposite.


back to top