Challenge: 50 Books discussion
Friday Questions
>
Question #8: No way. No how. Not now. Not ever.
date
newest »

message 201:
by
Frances
(new)
Jun 09, 2010 10:11AM

reply
|
flag



i'm with you on that one, Frances. i have my reasons which i will not state here. just like i have no desire to read the harry potter series. no thank you. and before any one wants to call me a "book snob", it's not that at all....i just have no desire.


Anyone here who liked it?

I will also not read James Patterson's "Innocent Man". I lived in the town and know the location of the apartment...I actually began reading it until I developed the visual - could not and would not continue; but will read any of his other books.
You've really missed something if you haven't read King's The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon. No horror, just the delightful story of a young girl lost in the woods, with only her radio to listen to Red Sox games back when Tom Gordon was their closer.

i think King's short fiction is far superior to his novels. Shawshank Redemption came from a King short story, also Stand By Me. The Green Mile was so cool, being released in serial form. his novels, however, are usually way too long. he needs a good editor (that he'll listen to. LOL)

I also don't have the slightest interest in reading Harry Potter.
Each to their own though! I love chick lit books, thrillers, mysteries, travelogues, some fantasy etc - all things others have said they hate. Still, I read primarily for entertainment & relaxation. I don't wish to be depressed, to struggle through it just to say I've read X book or just spend my time trying to decipher the language.

The Art of Racing in the Rain

And the Harry Potter series.
Naomi wrote: "Peg wrote: "You've really missed something if you haven't read King's The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon. No horror, just the delightful story of a young girl lost in the woods, with only her radio to ..."
Stephen King's "On Writing" is amazing and I wish everything he wrote could be so, but everything I've tried to read of his was trash. I couldn't figure out how "The Green Mile" and "Shawshank Redemption" came from the same guy.
Thank you for your clarification - good to know.
Stephen King's "On Writing" is amazing and I wish everything he wrote could be so, but everything I've tried to read of his was trash. I couldn't figure out how "The Green Mile" and "Shawshank Redemption" came from the same guy.
Thank you for your clarification - good to know.
Leslie wrote: "Anything by Ian McEwan. I tried to read Saturday. I tried to read Atonement. I will never try again.
And the Harry Potter series."
Thank you for the confidence to not read Ian McEwan, as well. Not only do I have the most difficulty trying to read him, but hearing him being interviewed makes my skin crawl. Nothing personal, but he is not for me no matter how hard I try.
And the Harry Potter series."
Thank you for the confidence to not read Ian McEwan, as well. Not only do I have the most difficulty trying to read him, but hearing him being interviewed makes my skin crawl. Nothing personal, but he is not for me no matter how hard I try.

AMEN!!! I read the Twlight books because all my college-age friends were and I was pressured to join the bandwagon. I got through them all in about a weekend. This woman cannot write. The entire Twilight series is just a thinly veiled metaphor for Mormonism and her skill is abominable. I have literally read essays and stories with more varied sentence structure by the middle schoolers I teach and tutor.



I thought it was just me. I forced myself through Jodi Picoult's most recent and felt no differently than if I were pushed around on a crowded bus.
Thank you. Cheese is best eaten on a cracker, not squished between covers.
Thank you. Cheese is best eaten on a cracker, not squished between covers.


All due props to Anne Rice, but owned? Janice, please let me introduce you to Mr. Stoker.

Rose

But...
I have to say that any book that requires a multi-session class to enjoy it may be a little too much by half.

Rose

Rose"
I keep hearing about The Woman in White, so I'll definitely have to put it on the list.
But, back to Joyce: You've talked me into putting him back on the list (currently I'm reading Mary Renault's books about Greece and Alexander, then on to some of the works of Octavia Butler). And after all, any literature Joseph Campbell likes has got to have a lot to recommend it. I did read Dubliners and liked it well enough, so I've got a bit of a start.
Are you going to read Finnegan's Wake?

Lynsea - I really liked The Pillars of the Earth. It's a very looong book but some good action. My fr..."
Same here. I was pleasantly surprised by The Pillars of the Earth. World without End wasnt bad either.
I haven't been able to get into the Harry Potter series, I'm afraid. I do try to give every book a chance :)

Also, I must comment on Pillars of the Earth: I was totally into this book--for about 700 pages. Then it started morphing into a bad romance novel (I thought, did Danielle Steele take over the writing?). I was so relieved to finish it. No more Ken Follett for me.
Rose

No Sci-Fi? You're missing out on a lot of cool stuff! I dare you to try A Canticle for Leibowitz, by Walter M. Miller, Jr. I'll bet you'll like it.

Tried it, hated it. My husband loves sci fi and has tried to get me to read sci fi for years. It just isn't something I want to read. Too many other books out there.




Now, I know this makes me seem like a huge snob, but my stance on it is that there are far too many wonderful, beautifully-written books in the world that will go unread by me purely due to their sheer number (my bookshelves at home are a testament to this fact!). Thus, by reading many of the aforementioned books- or their "relatives"- I am wasting valuable time that could otherwise be spent devouring greats like Margaret Atwood, Salman Rushie, and John Irving. I'm being economical :)
Heather wrote: "I also will never read the Twilight series, nor any other Vampire series by anyone besides true writers like Anne Rice, Bram Stoker, etc. It seems like everyone is cashing in on this current obsess..."
While I agree with you on a fundamental level, I don't think you're being fair to the Oprah bookclub books. You seem to be forgetting that those books have included A Tale of Two Cities, Great Expectations, multiple Toni Morrison books, Middlesex (which was fantastic), The Road (Cormac McCarthy), books by Faulkner, Anna Karinena (Tolstoy), One Hundred Years of Solitude (Marquez), East of Eden (Steinbeck).
It's easy to write of "most of what Oprah recommends" because I used to feel the same way. When I look back at the complete list of recommendations... there's not a lot of crap there. There are also wonderful books, like A Fine Balance, that I may not have read if my mom hadn't picked it up BECAUSE it was an Oprah book.
What wouldn't I read? I will not finish the rest of the Twilight series. I read the first book, because I figured there might be something behind the hype.
I will also never read Black Boy by Richard Wright. I want to like it, I just can't.
While I agree with you on a fundamental level, I don't think you're being fair to the Oprah bookclub books. You seem to be forgetting that those books have included A Tale of Two Cities, Great Expectations, multiple Toni Morrison books, Middlesex (which was fantastic), The Road (Cormac McCarthy), books by Faulkner, Anna Karinena (Tolstoy), One Hundred Years of Solitude (Marquez), East of Eden (Steinbeck).
It's easy to write of "most of what Oprah recommends" because I used to feel the same way. When I look back at the complete list of recommendations... there's not a lot of crap there. There are also wonderful books, like A Fine Balance, that I may not have read if my mom hadn't picked it up BECAUSE it was an Oprah book.
What wouldn't I read? I will not finish the rest of the Twilight series. I read the first book, because I figured there might be something behind the hype.
I will also never read Black Boy by Richard Wright. I want to like it, I just can't.

Ok. I totally understand you now. We're on the same page with those. I have a hard time bringing myself around to them. But then again, I had a hard time making myself read Piccoult too, and I've liked that (in little doses).


Sugar and Spice by Lauren Conrad. I tried reading it after I had just finished reading The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest by Stieg Larsson, and I read 10 pages. And then I literally chucked it at a wall in my house with all my might. AWFUL BOOK (The first 2 were not nearly as bad).
I also have a strong vendetta against the Pretty little Liars tv show. The books = one million times better. The lying game show is quite good however
Books mentioned in this topic
Sugar and Spice (other topics)The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet’s Nest (other topics)
The Host (other topics)
Midnight’s Children (other topics)
Breaking Dawn (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Salman Rushdie (other topics)Stephen King (other topics)
Stephen King (other topics)
Stephen King (other topics)
Chuck Palahniuk (other topics)
More...