Goodreads Librarians Group discussion
Book & Author Page Issues
>
re reasons why books that should combine won't combine
date
newest »

Another: the new publication date fields don't like there being a month without a year, or a day without both year and month. Fixing those took care of some won't-combines for me earlier.
I found an instance where someone put a web site address in the URL field and until I deleted that information, the editions wouldn't combine. Goodreads kept giving me error messages with the URL field highlighted.
Just fyi.