Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?
message 301:
by
Kellie
(new)
Apr 20, 2008 07:11AM

reply
|
flag

I'm glad I read this book, but I had trouble with some of the metaphors and found the writing somewhat pretentious. I liked the story and the structure of the novel and many of the personal insights quite well though. Definitely a woman's book with a theme of feminism running throughout. Worthwhile read but could have been more enjoyable with fewer French phrases and obscure references.


I might have enjoyed Tipping the Velvet just a smidge more (maybe just because I read it first), but I thought Fingersmith was tons better than Affinity.

As I posted in another group, I thought it was quite a let down. It relies far too much on shock value and far too little on actually saying something useful. I understand that it is a counter-culture classic and am usually all for that, but here it just fell flat. I much preferred Hell's Angels over this one.

Would you have enjoyed Fight Club so much more if you hadn't seen the film? In my experience, all of Palahniuk's novels offer up the same basic critique of modern living, in variously different packaging. While Haunted may not be up your alley, I would think that the biting satire of Choke or Survivor would appeal to the same bit of you that enjoyed Fight Club.

I think it has less to do with the novels themselves (movie or not) than, perhaps, the order in which I read them. For me, Fight Club was a book that dealt a lot not only with modern life, but very MALE perceptions of modern life. The book just happened to come to me at a good time.
Yes, once we've read some Palahniuk, we start to recognize the commonalities, but we could say that for almost any popular author.
As for shock value, I think I agree, but absurdity is part of the package with authors of his ilk. The distinction I would make here is that in Palahniuk's better stuff, the critique is there, often made apparent by the absurdity and grotesquerie. In Fear and Loathing , I felt that many sections offered very little of anything to chew on...besides mescaline.
Then again, maybe I just disliked it because I read a lot of it on a 4 hour flight and I was already pissed off and annoyed. Ha!

Shorter review here: http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34...
Full review here:
http://readingrantsandraves.blogspot....

I did think the first section was too full of archaic words and the ending was a little anticlimactic for me. It almost happened too quickly.




I feel like the grumpy old man, but I've been on a string of books that haven't really done all that much for me.
My primary cause for annoyance with this one is the structure. I already ranted and raved in another thread, so I won't bother again, but I found it to be amateurish (can I say that if I'm not a writer?) in it's construction, but interesting enough to try to ignore it (with limited success).







This is one of the most frustrating books I've ever read...


I...think I liked it? Reading this book is like looking at a surrealist painting, interesting yet incomprehensible. Everyone in the story is either despicable or pathetic or both. Pretty absorbing, and a very quick read. Left me feeling disturbed and disorientated - since that was likely the point, I would say it is indeed a good book.


I'm reading Jose Saramago's Blindness right now, which isn't on the list. I'm definitely thinking it should be though, this book is fantastic! There are two other of Saramago's on the list that I think I will have to move to soon.



It was dense, but good. Stephenson plods thoroughly through WWII and present day with hackers and soldiers alike.
More serious than some of his others, but still fun. I love his humor.
I recommend it, but just go into it knowing you're going to be reading it for awhile. It's 1130 pages long!

I wouldn't recommend it. This is one of my least favorites--if not THE least favorite--from the list so far.

Well-written, but I am not really a fan of war novels.

Of all the omissions from the list, Blindness seems to be, for me, the most egregious, especially since others of Saramago's works have been included. I've read a number of his books, and Blindness seems to me in a class by itself. Without denigrating his other books, I found my reaction to Blindess to be similar to my reaction to if on a winter's night a traveler; the authors' other books are wonderful, but those two are respectively otherworldly.
Sadly, the follow-up, Seeing, while good, is just good and not transcendent.

I need suggestions! After that, I'm ready for a real page turner, something "un-put-downable!" Any and all suggestions will be appreciated. Feel free to PM me if you don't want to post it here. Thanks! :)


I like Hawthorne, and I liked this book. It is great historical fiction, especially if you consider it as a follow-up on the status of women in the New England society since "The Scarlet Letter", set a century before "Blithedale".

Sayers has two books on "the 1001 list". I'm reading "The Nine Tailors" now, but it has lots of detail so it may not be the best choice. You could try the other one though -- "Murder Must Advertise", I think it's called. I enjoyed that one.


Thanks! I do love mysteries, although I have never read James or Sayers. I think I gravitate toward more detective/thriller fluff like James Patterson and John Sandford. :)
The best book I have read recently is The Poisonwood Bible. I LOVED it. I also really enjoyed Dracula, which I finished a couple of weeks ago...I think. Dracula had TONS of detail, so that doesn't necessarily bother me, if I am interested in the plot. Actually, The Poisonwood Bible was pretty detailed too.
So I love all different genres, and would appreciate suggestions!

Kara? A post I read this morning here at goodreads reminded me what page-turners they are!

This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...