Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?
message 3351:
by
Asa
(new)
Aug 02, 2010 01:44AM

reply
|
flag


Not on the list.



It would be interesting to find out. The prose is the worst part. Good luck.

First year of college, ENG101, we read this. I was the only person in the class willing to participate in the instructor's discussion of foreshadowing and symbolism and all that stuff. On the day we were completing our study of it, he asked if anyone had any final thoughts. "Yeah," I said. "This is a terrible book! 'Am I your good girl?' 'You're my great girl.' Over and over. I was glad when [SPOILER:]." The rest of the class sort of sat there in shock, then chimed in with agreement. The poor prof just stared at me like I'd run over his puppy.....

I'm glad I'm not the only one who wasn't impressed with Hemingway. I didn't really want to trash a classic, but what can I say.

I read it for Stanford's EPGY Summer Program thing. Definitely can't read this book without a teacher"
I think anything of Faulkner's is tough to tread through. I remember being extremely frusturated getting through As I Lay Dying.


Saw the movie not long ago and it was good.

Can't read two Thomas Hardy books in a row! It's a stairway to suicide...

Don't think it should be in "1001 Books" - three books by Forster is enough (the third being A Passage to India





I read Where Angels Fear to Tread ages ago, and I remember liking it. It reminded me of Henry James, and how some of his characters, in their moral self-righteousness, end up screwing people's lives. But I haven't read either A Room with a View or Howards End, so I guess I'd have to do that to see how they compare.




...then DON'T go to Steinbeck!!!!


Need a break before continuing on to "The End of the Road"(the companion book), but I did enjoy my first experience with Barth.

Thanks for the insights, Chel. I had wondered about this one...

And what did you think of the book?

If you dont feel compelled after 136 pages I say chuck it.

I finished The Remains of the Day (great) and then tried to read Gravity's Rainbow (what?). I actually learned a little about my tastes in books from GR...as in, I won't spend my downtime reading books that read like a masturbatory ego-trip for the author. Or maybe I'm just not mature enough as a reader? I don't know. What did others think of this book?
I do appreciate a great story. That's why I revisted Ishiguro and read Never Let Me Go (excellent). Now I'm on to Cloud Atlas which is great so far.

I finished The Remains of the Day (great) and then tried to read Gravity's Rainbow (what?). I actually learned a little about my tastes ..."
Loved Never Let me go, it was fab! Can't wait to read more by this author. I also give up if I can't get into a particular book, list or otherwise. There have been a few so far and probably a few more to come. The way I see it, is I've tried!!


Thanks Cynthia - I will have to give Cat's Eye a read. I have Handmaiden at home to read. Aside from Oryx and Crake, Assassin was my second Atwood. I found Oryx and Crake odd when I read it so Assassin was a surprise.
I still feel its a bit of a shame that a lesser novel written by a single hit author can triumph a greater author's more mediocre novels. Steinbeck has two novels remaining on the list - and while they may be his two very best novels - even his more medicore novels are better than some of the one hit author's novels that appear on the list.

Cynthia wrote: "Sissy, I love Margaret Atwood to pieces, but I could not get into "Blind Assassin," for reasons I do not completely understand. I love "Cat's Eye" the most and feel strongly that it belongs on the ..."

Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison. 5 stars, I thought it was a great intense novel.


The Remains of the Day a couple of days ago and I'm still thinking about it. I LOVED that book. Looking forward to reading more Kazuo Ishiguro
Oh you'll have to read Never Let Me Go it's really brilliant - but in a different way than The Remains of the Day. I just loved it! Have you seen the movie Remains of the Day? It's actually really good as well.

I totally agree! The Remains of the Day is really different from Never Let Me Go. Great, but "slower" and really brilliant in his portrayal of the main character.

Yes, I just finished it, too. Haunting, heartwrenching, Salman Bushdie said it was "beautiful and cruel" and another famous writer mentioned its "flawless mastery of tone" ---I agree with all comments.


There is a movie of this one, I read it not too long ago but haven't seen the movie but thought it read like a movie so should convert well.

This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...