Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?





I've read and reviewed it. Muriel Spark is a good writer. Had lots of fun reading it. I think it got 4 or 5 stars from me.

Just finished Memoirs of A Geisha by Arthur Rogers and I gave it 3 stars, very easy entertaining read.


Not my favourite Austen-book so far.
I had been warned that I would probably be annoyed by Fanny Price, but I was actually more annoyed by Edmund...

How does it compare to White Noise?"
almost as good. but then i think White Noise is pretty much perfect. Libra certainly has more emotional content. delillo's postmodern effects and concerns are still very much in effect, but this is where his latent humanism started seeping through, which to me at least is a good thing, and helped lead him to his masterful epic Underworld. my favorite part of Libra is the surprisingly affecting death scene for oswald - not something i would expect from the cold-blooded author of Ratner's Star & Players.


not really sure how i feel about your blog review. entertaining & enjoyable, definitely yes. a shallow assessment based entirely on an unashamedly subjective and very surface-level & visceral reaction to experiences you've never really been confronted by on any sort of deep or internal level....sadly, another yes. ah well. i guess what i often enjoy in blogs is the completely subjective point of view of the author when confronting the world's myriad issues, and your assessment clearly delivers in that regard. but personally, as someone who works with people living with terminal illnesses and also as someone who sees their fascinating & multi-faceted viewpoints reflected in challenging ways in works like The Plague, well...i'll just say that you are an engaging blog writer, there's no doubt about that. but depth in both creative writing AND critical writing is often attained by experience and a willingness to look through a lense darkly, so to speak. perhaps that will come in time. in my humble opinion, The Plague exists on many levels and confronts many things about the human experience, and your blog review seems to purposely ignore those virtues.

To be fair, you did ask everyone to go read your review on your blog. Amanda is free to post her response. I guess it's also fair for you to post your response to her response. Carry on, everyone!
I just finished A Severed Head. Iris Murdoch is an author I probably never would have gotten into if not for the list, and there is something so compelling about her writing! You can't decide whether you want everyone to live happily ever after or die horrible deaths. She just sucks you in, relentlessly.
@Brian - Sadly, I don't think the great David Sedaris has made it onto the list. Does anyone have any suggestions for making it clear to all that this discussion is only for books on the Peter Boxall list?


Sorry, definitely didn't realize that this was only about the list.

you certainly have succeeded in that regard.
forgot to mention, congratulations on reaching your 200th list book. that is actually an amazing accomplishment, i'm genuinely envious. next up for me is The Siege of Krishnapur. i'm hopeful that it will be at least as good as A Passage to India or the novels of paul scott. but i have my doubts.

I loved that book. It took awhile to get into it but once I did I couldn't put it down.



It's on my to-read list. I've seen the movie and loved it... so I'm only assuming that book is going to be 10 times better.

Highly recommended ...

I think the person the furthest along is Deanne. She has read about 75% of the 2006 list.

Just finished Camilla, probably too long with the path of true love definitely having it's ups and downs.
Reading a book off the list Rapscallion and planning where to go on my next day off.



Wow, Deanne, you're an inspiration! You give others hope that this goal is actually attainable!
Regarding being unable to find some of the books, etc.
I actually "cheated" - there are some titles that I know I have no intention of ever reading, or that I know were published in a foreign language and will be difficult to obtain in English - Meanwhile, there are books which I've read that I personally feel SHOULD have been on the list that aren't (see that thread), so I swapped a few titles out and replaced them with ones I've read and feel I deserve credit for reading.
So, the way I look at it the Book List isn't the Bible or anything, it's just a reference tool for me to use how it suits my needs.
I hoped I don't get stoned now....


I'm now onto The Corrections - a definite change of pace, but also enjoyable. My sister hated this one - a sure sign I'll enjoy it.


Took me a couple of chapters to get into it, then I couldn't put it down. A very strange tale of obsession and how it affects not just the person being obsessed on. 8/10


"The Monk" is another that has been on my tbr shelf for a long time. I'm anxious to hear how anyone who has read it reacted. Let us know, Pam.

I really thought highly of "The Feast of the Goat". I'll have to double my efforts to get a copy of "Oscar Wao". Glad to know of the connection.

Please tell us more about "Cost" when you're so inclined, Kristi.

Wodehouse makes me laugh more, but "Lucky Jim" is quite a jewel. Amis' humor is dryer, more subtle. I think the Brits "get" Amis better than the outsiders, but it is pretty easy for everyone to "get" the humor of Wodehouse. He's really "out there" with it!

Not on the "1001 Books You Should Read Before You Die List[s}, is it?

That's pretty much my take on Rabbit in the first in the series too, Becky. I still plan to read at least one more of Updike's Rabbit books to see if I get into them more. How about you?
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...
I will stick to the list in future, my apologies.