Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?
message 201:
by
Virginia
(new)
Feb 27, 2008 09:43AM

reply
|
flag


I also finished To the Lighthouse tonight. That was a long time coming; not my favorite Virginia Woolf novel.



I really enjoyed both of these novels. I probably wouldn't have appreciated them as much before taking a literature class, but now I am learning to appreciate post-modern and contemporary literature.



Anyways, I just finish How Doctors Think by Jerome Groopman

One good thing: it took about as long to read as an issue of US Magazine.

I finished "The Human Stain" by Roth since my last post. I enjoyed it, surprisingly so. Roth's sexual obsessions are far from a turn-on for me as a reader, but this one is a little more plot driven and delves deeper into historical race issues which is far more interesting to me.
I picked up "The Breast" at the book store this week, read one page and put it back down. Seemed a shorter and less justified version of Portnoy's Complaint's pre-occupation to me! I just could never take that one home with me, but I'm glad I read Portnoy's years ago and The Human Stain recently so that I have more of an understanding of this best selling author's style and subject matter. That is all I expect to get out of some of the books on THIS list. At least it is a LONG list with something for every reader's taste on it...

I graded 5, and wrote: Very good description of doctor's thought process. Good advice for layman on how to interact with their physicians in order to have a better quality of care. Easy to read.
My friend Michael also rated 5.
I should advice you that he is reiterative sometimes. But I can tell his descriptions are a lot like the real thing. We doctors are humans and make mistakes. This book is trying to make changes in patient-doctor comunication.
enjoy




Is anyone interested in starting a thread on this book? I started to write a brief response to your question, Smarti, and found I had a great deal more to say than I thought about the book.


It was also disturbing that this woman would have a very long affair with a 15 year old boy - but to me both of those story lines were just in the background. For me it was that fact that she was indeed illiterate. There was obviously something comforting to her to be read to, and when it was brought up that she had the women in the camps also read to her, perhaps it was her way of bring some comfort to the prisoner as well. She knew they were going to die.
All of the disturbing events that occur are what make this a beautiful story.


Is anybody out there a Cather fan? Has anyone read "The Professor's House" that is on the list?
I'm trying to decide if I like this author. Her characters are well developed, but her physical descriptions evoke only confusing images in my head!
"Song" is set in the southwest where I live (and she did at one time also), and nothing she describes in the environment is quite right or clearly visual. It's like she is writing about somewhere she only read about, not anywhere she has ever really been! Her descriptive word choices leave me cold!
I guess I'm asking, "Did I just make a bad choice from her works, or are others (such as the one on "the list") that much better? Any and all comments about her books are welcome!
I also note that she has books listed on the on the Modern Lirary's 100 Best Novels and the Radcliff's Rival 100 Best Novels list (but not the one I am reading). I was really looking forward to "discovering" her for myself. Now I'm wondering if I should even finish the one I have!

Well, admittedly, I have only read one work by Cather, O Pioneers!, and I really liked it a lot. My Antonia is my next read after I finish Invisible Man, so I'll let you know how it turns out.
I've heard a lot of people talk about how much they enjoyed My Antonia, The Professor's House, and Death Comes for the Archbishop. The reviews on Song of the Lark and Shadows on the Rock have been mixed, so I guess those are a matter of 'read and see'.
Logan:
I have been meaning to read The Hours for a long time now. Have you read Mrs. Dalloway? I was thinking of reading them together as a companion set to get the best outlook.



Thanks for you response, Ivy, and love you kitty pic!



I like just finished A Great and Terrible Beauty. OMG! It was amazing! I hate when good books are over... it makes me want to cry. Thank goodness for sequels!

The Glass Bead Game

Logan, I am also an avid reader of Hesse. I read Steppenwolf, Siddharta and Under the Wheel. Out of these, the last one is by far my favourite and one of my all-time best reading experiences. Did you also read that one? It is, maybe, Hesse's only realistic novel and I prefer it to the other esoteric novels he wrote. I never felt like reading The Glass Bead Game, exactly because of the criticism you have put forward. it seems like it would sum up everything that I do not like about Hesse: esoritericism, loftyness,..
If you try Under the Wheel, let me know how you liked it!


Don't let the review of Glass Bead Game throw you off- I love Hesse's eccentricities. The Magic Theatre in Steppenwolf is one of my favorite creations ever. What I disliked about Glass Bead was that it just seemed like a retread of everything he had done before. There was nothing new that he had to say and that was just disappointing.


I am now going back to Kazantakis' 'the last temptation', which I interrupted for reading 'the ground beneath her feet'

http://johnandsheena.co.uk/books/?pag...

I just finished The Honorary Consul by Graham Greene. I truly enjoyed this book from start to finish and it's one that I truly think deserves the title of "must read before you die."
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...