Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?
message 151:
by
YorkshireSue
(new)
Feb 02, 2008 10:28AM

reply
|
flag




Tim

Nos, I really don't know what to think about this collection of short-stories disguised as a novel. It certainly is clever but also very show-off and maybe shallow. Did anyone of you read this book? If yes, I'd be very much interested in what you think of it. I gave it three stars but I also could have justified two, five or ten... very odd!
Never Let Me Go was so good 3/4 of the way and then then it was like the book that could never end - a little anticlimatic



I started Lolita a few weeks ago, and I couldn't get into it. I thought it was just me. I'll probably try again some other time, but like you because of the hype I expected I would be drawn into it easily.

Maybe I wasn't in the mood, but I wasn't too impressed with either of these books
Tim


Emma - to be honest, I read the New York Trilogy over 15 years ago and loved it at the time, but I haven't read it since (and the books we like as teenagers aren't always the same as those we enjoy as adults). I remember, though, being impressed by the type of storytelling Auster was engaged in (something I think has completely left his writing of the past 10-15 years).

55 read, 946 to go :)
I liked this book a lot, seeing everything from the eyes of a child.
The book shows the schizophrenic nature of people, when it comes to judging their own actions opposed to those of others.

Hi Kelly. Which do you like best?
I just finished The Cement Garden myself (McEwan). Guuess it was his first....couldn't help but think he was obviously trying to get noticed. Still - I couldn't put it down. Wonder how the publishing date for Flowers in the Attic lines up with it.... similar themes. Or maybe it was just a 70s thing. Stunt or not, though, Mc still has my heart.
I just finished The Cement Garden myself (McEwan). Guuess it was his first....couldn't help but think he was obviously trying to get noticed. Still - I couldn't put it down. Wonder how the publishing date for Flowers in the Attic lines up with it.... similar themes. Or maybe it was just a 70s thing. Stunt or not, though, Mc still has my heart.


When I'd finished "In Cold Blood" I looked it up on Wikipedia and found that Capote and Harper Lee had been childhood friends and travelled together while Capote researched "In Cold Blood".

I'm now taking a little break for some contemporary fiction because Mansfield Park really did me in.



SOOOO depressing. This one kinda hit home, since it's about a similar peer group to the ones I went to high school with. Makes you realize that life shouldn't be wasted.


You guys are scaring me about the The Red Queen. I just bought it, but no one seems to like it at all. Why?


Hi Incom...
I remember thinking that Atonement shoudl have ended long before it did. Saturday was perfect. In general, I think McEwan's shorter books the best. He's so good at observational detail which makes the reading slower anyway. Too much of it makes the books tedious. I like those books of his where after 100 pages of "day in the life of average joe" you get that sharp left turn. Atonement was satisfying in all the ways a McEwan book is but there was just too much of it
I remember thinking that Atonement shoudl have ended long before it did. Saturday was perfect. In general, I think McEwan's shorter books the best. He's so good at observational detail which makes the reading slower anyway. Too much of it makes the books tedious. I like those books of his where after 100 pages of "day in the life of average joe" you get that sharp left turn. Atonement was satisfying in all the ways a McEwan book is but there was just too much of it

The most recent book I read from the list was Confederacy of Dunces (Toole) over Christmas and I'm kicking myself for letting it sit on my shelves all these years without reading. Easily one of the funniest books I've read in years.

Hopefully I'll like the next book better. I'm going to be starting The Sea by John Banville.

Thanks for mentioning Book Lust. Is there much overlap between the recommendations with the 1001 Must Read list?
I personally like the Modern Library's 100 Best Novel list for its selections, too many of which are not on the 1001 list!

I also finished "Our Mutual Friend". A typical Dickens story, but his are also always good reads.
I finished "The Unconsoled" recently too -- my second book by Ishiguro and a surprising postmodern turn after the beautiful and more traditional story of "The Remains of the Day". I like it, but it took me a few days to decide for sure that I did!
A fourth I checked off the list is "Sister Carrie". I don't know how I missed this one earlier in life. It is brutally honest about human flaws and motivation and an excellent historical presentation of America at the beginning of the Industrial Age. I had to push myself through at times, but I'm glad I stuck with it until the end.
I may read "The Satanic Verses" next. Any opinions on that one?

The Fall of the House of Usher (re-read)
Cold Comfort Farm
Billy Budd
The Bluest Eye
Candide
The Reader
Saturday
The Turn of the Screw
The Picture of Dorian Gray
I liked them all and will make comments on any that others are interested in learning more about! Just ask!
I find other's takes on the books they read quite helpful in choosing my TBR and Wish List selections! Thanks to all who contribute with comments and reviews!

The Yellow Wallpaper (so short I finished it while sitting at the reference desk one night). Great story, though I thought I was in for fussy Kate Chopin jr at first. Boy was I wrong.
Enduring Love by Ian McEwan. I liked it. THe middle kept me guessing the sanity of a few of the characters, but I enjoyed it.
Ooh, The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath. I'm glad I read it now rather than a few years down the line, I think it's a 'Catcher in the Rye' style book that it's possible to be too old to appreciate.
Enduring Love was excellent! McEwan's earlier (pre-Atonement) books are better in some ways... less mainstream, more cruel and unusual.
Enduring Love was excellent! McEwan's earlier (pre-Atonement) books are better in some ways... less mainstream, more cruel and unusual.



This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...