Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?


I think that as soon as I finish If on a winter's night a traveler by Italo Calvino, I'm going to give the list a rest for a little while, though. The books I'm picking off it are starting to annoy me. Time for something a bit more lighthearted. :)


Wasn't too impressed by it, but fortunately I've already read The Crow Road by Banks, so I know he's capable of writing amazing stuff. Plus it was his first novel, and for a first novel it wasn't too shabby

Wasn't too impressed by it, but fortunately I've already read The Crow Road by Banks, so I know he's capable of writing amazing stuff..."
really? I adored it!

Wasn't too impressed by it, but fortunately I've already read The Crow Road by Banks, so I know he's capable of writing ..."
I dunno...he just didn't do anything for me. I know some people thought the things Frank did were too graphic, but that wasn't my issue. Banks just seemed to go on for pages describing Frank's arsenal of weapons, which never interested me.
And then when I read the twist at the end, I didn't really care. I wasn't as attached to the characters as I was at the beginning. To be honest, the only reason I kept reading was to see what was in Angus' study.

I felt entirely the same way and actually picked up another random list on listsofbest.com, and some other random lighthearted books from my local bookstore. These were some depressed literary experts when they put this list together!

life. At around age 50, thoughts of our own
mortality surface and the childlike, carefree
belief of living forever and a "that isn't going to
happen to me" attitude seem to slip away. Still
Alice, by Lisa Genova, is a stark reminder that no
matter how we choose to live our lives, anything can and usually does happen. There's no way to stop
death. This inevitable fate of all life is buffered
as we begin to take pride in our wisdom gained via
living these long 50+ years. I can't even count
the number of times I have uttered "If I only
knew then what I know now." Genova's
interpretation of what life could be like to suffer
the thievery of Alzheimer's Disease is frightening.
Her character's case cruelly strikes as Early Onset
Alzheimer's, robbing her still healthy and fit
body of the enjoyment, satisfaction and pride in
her life's accomplishments. It also strips away so
many things she should be able to look forward
to in her later years. Her yesteryears are gone
and as this disease swiftly ravages her body so
are her tomorrows. Our experiences shape us
into the people we become. When we cannot draw
upon what life has taught us we tragically lose ourselves. This story is told through the victim's eyes. The devastation this horrid disease leaves both victims and their families is tragic. An important, as well as frightening read.

Betteredge the narrator of "The Moonstone" considers a chapter of Robinson Crusoe ( and a pipe of tobacco) all that he needs to set the world right & to give him guidence.

For "...Cathcher..." : Take a handful of aspirin, lie down, sleep. You will feel better in the morning. Ha Ha! Just not my favourite book!

For "...Cathcher..." : Take a handful of aspirin, lie down, sleep. You will feel better in the morning. Ha Ha! Just..."
Not mine either at all - I've given it two tried
Just finished Picture of Dorian Gray and I'm very disappointed it just dragged on and on




Giovanni's Room I liked less because of the main character.
I'm happy to have found this group because most of the books in the list are depressing and I'll be more motivated to read them if I know I have people to discuss them with.

Giovanni's Room I liked less because of the main..."
I have to say - I wasn't a fan. It was just so... wrong. I can't imagine that that is really what would happen to a group of boys stranded on an island.

I was prepared for things to go wrong because my husband had read it in high school. Also, if you notice whenever young boys get together, eventually something violent will happen. Not as bad as the book though :-) I had a feeling things were going to get bad when at the beginning of the book one of the older boys realized that he could bother/hurt the little ones and nothing would happen.

Giovanni's Room I liked less becau..." Marianne Wiggins (a very good writer--former wife of Salman Rushdie) said she read "Lord of the Flies" on a plane and said to herself, "That's not what girls would have done." To show what girls would have done, she wrote the novel "John Dollar." I found it very absorbing, but I'm not sure I bought her vision as much as I did Golding's. At any rate I recommend it, but be warned, it's not a cheerful read either!


Paula-- I loved Giovanni's Room, but not because of the likability of any of the characters. I just love Baldwin's writing.

Yes, I too liked the book for the same reason. baldwin's writing is charming.

I just finished The War of the Worlds. I enjoyed it but the first 2/3rds was very slow. I liked the connection of alien invasion with colonialism.


I have also read 'Go Tell it on the Mountain' by James Baldwin. The novel is written well and is very different from 'Giovanni's Room' in terms of characterization and subject. But I think what I liked most about this book was again Baldwin's writing, and on the whole found 'Go Tell it on the Mountain' better than 'Giovanni's Room'.
So anyway, this book is very different from Giovanni's Room, so you don't have to let that one put you off Baldwin.



It was difficult to get into, but once I did, I couldn't put it down...it's an amazing story of the conflict between native cultures and the Christian churches trying to convert them.


About a year ago I tried to get into that, but it didn't do much for me. It seemed rather dry and dragged on for quite a bit

Paula-- I loved..."
I haven't read Baldwin yet - I think that was from another part of someone else's message that I was responding to : )
A good friend of mine loves Baldwin, I just haven't decided which one to read first. Perhaps Giovanni's room, since that one seems to be relatively well-liked here.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...
I didn't like the ending either. But in its own strange and demented way it fit with the story