The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
OLD TASK HELP THREADS
>
30.4- Cheryl TX's Task: Mysteries And Animals
date
newest »

Fran wrote: "For Part A I want to use Hot Stuff by Janet Evanovich. A dog plays a large part in the mystery.
For Part B I am thinking about Down the Rabbit Hole by Peter Abrahams.
..."
They work
For Part B I am thinking about Down the Rabbit Hole by Peter Abrahams.
..."
They work

For Part B I am thinking about Down the Rabbit Hole by Peter ..."
Thanks Dlmrose!

SuzieR wrote: "Clutching at straws a bit here ... but would The Redbreast by Jo Nesbo work for part b, the animal being a robin redbreast?"
My dictionary says n. a robin That works as an animal, and it is a detective mystery. It fits.
My dictionary says n. a robin That works as an animal, and it is a detective mystery. It fits.

My dictionary says n. a robin That works as an animal, and it is a detective mystery. It fits."
Lovely! Thanks :)
★Meghan★ wrote: "Does Hot Six work for part A?"
I think this book is a real stretch for this task, but the dog is mentioned in the description- and it can be hard to tell how big a role the dog plays without reading the book, so I'll say OK
I think this book is a real stretch for this task, but the dog is mentioned in the description- and it can be hard to tell how big a role the dog plays without reading the book, so I'll say OK
Paul wrote: "Hi,
Would "Ducks" work for part B?
Cheers
(Metshaft)"
Who is the author? Can you add a link to the book?
Would "Ducks" work for part B?
Cheers
(Metshaft)"
Who is the author? Can you add a link to the book?

Would "Ducks" work for part B?
Cheers
(Metshaft)"
Who is the author? Can you add a link to the book?"
Never Mind the Reversing Ducks by Adrian Plass


A: The Familiars - three animal familiars must discover where their magicians have been kidnapped to
B: Slow Horses - CIA/Spy mystery
I'm sure B will work, but just want to double check on A. Thanks!
Bridgit wrote: "Thinking of these two:
A: The Familiars - three animal familiars must discover where their magicians have been kidnapped to
B: Slow Horses - CIA/Spy mystery
I'm su..."
I can't find a reference that classifies The Familiars as a mystery- the authors' website says there is an "adventure", "quest" and "rescue". The task defines a mystery as having a detective protagonist (amateur or professional) who investigates and solves a crime.
A: The Familiars - three animal familiars must discover where their magicians have been kidnapped to
B: Slow Horses - CIA/Spy mystery
I'm su..."
I can't find a reference that classifies The Familiars as a mystery- the authors' website says there is an "adventure", "quest" and "rescue". The task defines a mystery as having a detective protagonist (amateur or professional) who investigates and solves a crime.

Yes, it works. It is described as a "police procedural" so that fits the professional detective, a crime- the counterfeiting, and the animal- Achoo the scent hound and the information pigeons

The Dogs of Babel by Carolyn Parkhurst
I'm not really a fan of traditional mysteries, and this is something I own and would like to re-read. From the description below, as well as what I can remember (although it's been a while since I read it!), it seems to me that Paul fits the bill as the amateur detective, Lorelei the dog as his "sidekick", and the mystery is investigating the death of his wife. But I'm sure I can find something else if you think this is a stretch! I can always pick up one of those "cat who..." mysteries, right? Like, The Cat Who Could Read Backwards?
FROM THE PUBLISHER
When his wife dies in a fall from a tree in their backyard, linguist Paul Iverson is wild with despair. In the days that follow, Paul becomes certain that Lexy's death was no accident. Strange clues have been left behind: unique, personal messages that only she could have left and that he is determined to decipher. So begins Paul's fantastic and even perilous search for the truth, as he abandons his everyday life to embark on a series of experiments designed to teach his dog Lorelei to communicate. Is this the project of a madman? Or does Lorelei really have something to tell him about the last afternoon of a woman he only thought he knew? At the same time, Paul obsessively recalls the early days of his love for Lexy and the ups and downs of life with the brilliant, sometimes unsettling woman who became his wife
Bev wrote: "Pondering my choices for this task - what about this for part A?
The Dogs of Babel by Carolyn Parkhurst
I'm not really a fan of traditional mysteries, and this is something I own..."
It works, it has been classified as a mystery and Lorelei is a big part.
The Cat Who.. works too
The Dogs of Babel by Carolyn Parkhurst
I'm not really a fan of traditional mysteries, and this is something I own..."
It works, it has been classified as a mystery and Lorelei is a big part.
The Cat Who.. works too

Deedee wrote: "Does Ape House by Sara Gruen work for Part B? I have not read it yet, but the cover says "When an explosion rocks the lab, severely injuring Isabel and 'liberating' t..."
I've read it - it's not a mystery book. John doesn't solve anything (and he's not a detective, professional or amateur). He just breaks the story which is handed to him.
I did enjoy the book, though - I used it for the THANKSGIVING task.
I've read it - it's not a mystery book. John doesn't solve anything (and he's not a detective, professional or amateur). He just breaks the story which is handed to him.
I did enjoy the book, though - I used it for the THANKSGIVING task.
Deedee wrote: "Does Ape House by Sara Gruen work for Part B? I have not read it yet, but the cover says "When an explosion rocks the lab, severely injuring Isabel and 'liberating' t..."
I can't find any reference to this book being a mystery. The crimes described seem to be resolved without the investigation- see Washington Post Review if you don't mind the spoilers. If you can find a reference, I'll consider it, but I don't think it works.
I can't find any reference to this book being a mystery. The crimes described seem to be resolved without the investigation- see Washington Post Review if you don't mind the spoilers. If you can find a reference, I'll consider it, but I don't think it works.

Thank you!

OK fine I'll use another book for Part B :0)
Ape House looks good I'll find another place for it

Deedee wrote: "Found another one for part B -- Sand Sharks by Margaret Maron. Definately a mystery, part of the Judge Deborah Knott series. And sharks are animals ... right? Thanks!"
Sharks work
Sharks work
Books mentioned in this topic
Sand Sharks (other topics)Sand Sharks (other topics)
Ape House (other topics)
Ape House (other topics)
Ape House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Margaret Maron (other topics)Margaret Maron (other topics)
Sara Gruen (other topics)
Sara Gruen (other topics)
Sara Gruen (other topics)
More...
For Part B I am thinking about Down the Rabbit Hole by Peter Abrahams.
Just wanted to get the 0.k. before I started- thanks!