throwing it out the Window

[Angie Elle]

I don't think I hung onto it long enough to throw it out the window.

I watched the movie in hopes that it would be better than the book, but I didn't feel the leads had any chemistry at all. The movie was so emotionless.

The book and the movie were both a bust for me on this one! :(

[PepsiGirl]

Actually,I just threw it across the room in disgust. It was like a sucker punch. Completely unexpected.

[Lobna]

Maddie wrote: "did anyone else throw this book out the window when the read the ending?? or am i the only one!?!?"

me too , the movie was GREAT and i still love it but the book is boriiiiiiiiiiiiiing and i think it shoot be 15o pages book only

[Wajeeha]

So the ending was veryyyyy sad, sure. But i loved the book. it was very interesting. i finished it in a single go

[Sarouel]

Robin wrote: "Some of his books are better than others. He does go more for the female audience. People like who they like, he writes from a good point of view. What is HEA?"

HEA- happily ever after
:)

[Asia]

I don't really remember the book nor the movie, having read and seen them time ago. But I do remember thinking that the ending of the novel was way to melodramatic than what it could have been. Of course, I am not saying that it is necessary a "happily - ever - after - ending" but I thought that it could have ended differently, even if with a sad ending.

[Imke]

if you don't like sad and true endings why do you start reading Sparks' books? the are sad and i love that about it! the whole book they are struggling with their love and then they should come together at the end???? that wouldn't make any sense! they couldn't be together at first although they tried and wanted it and they couldn't be together at the end although they tried and wanted it. that makes sense to me! It's one of my favorite Sparks' books.

[Shreya]

Don't buy it, rather read it unless you are a hopeless romantic ! Just as simple as that ...

[Bhawya]

ending was a bit rotten...but i really liked the book...some of its elements were exceptional...

[Elesa]

I burned it and then put the ashes in a bottle. LOL

[Imke]

Pingle wrote: "Imke wrote: "if you don't like sad and true endings why do you start reading Sparks' books? the are sad and i love that about it! the whole book they are struggling with their love and then they sh..."

you're right everyone has their own taste so I expressed mine.

[Amber]

I like most NS books, but I did NOT like this one. It was too formulaic I think, which would have been fine but NS wasn't being subtle about it like in his others books.

[Beth S.]

I loved the book and the movie, I didn't mind the ending at all. Heartbreaking, but worth the read.

[Kathryn]

i liked it but i definitely couldn't throw it because it was not mine.

[Smriti]

The message in bottle .......style is out of this world.