Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
discussion
Wrong date
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Beth
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 06, 2010 10:03PM
Why does it say this was first published in 2002? Shouldn't it be 2005?
reply
|
flag
Mine says: Fist American Edition, July 2005
Mabye that particular set of copies were printed out of the US.
yeh probaly and mine says 2005 too.
mine most deffinetley says 2005. yup! :)
Does it really matter?
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
YESYESYES to true Harry Potter fans it matters
i know. i just wanted t make myself clear :)
Hey, if it's some sort of typo, that might make it a valuable collector's item. It was first publication was 2005, and in countries outside the English speaking world, after that.
i hope not many, cause then it is a colectors item
huh??!!?? mine says 2002!!!!!!!!!!!
The editions I looked at on the Goodreads website say it was first published in 2005. Also, I have a hardback First American edition and it says it was published in July, 2005.
And if this helps on the when it was published thing, I was there, in line waiting for the thing the day it came out, in 2005. If it had come out in 2002 I couldn't have been at the store I got it because I didn't live in the area then. Apparently one edition has the wrong date on it. Most people won't notice it and will just treat it like any other book. You need to take yours, get an archival storage box, stick it in the box, put the box in a safe deposit box, and in 50 years when you've got a mint condition copy with the wrong date on it, you can send your grandkids to college on the proceeds.
Keryl wrote: "And if this helps on the when it was published thing, I was there, in line waiting for the thing the day it came out, in 2005. If it had come out in 2002 I couldn't have been at the store I got it..."Good idea Keryl! Mint condition hard back books might be valuable anyway, but one with the wrong date would definitely be worth a lot!!
Somebody get Rowling in here to correct this!
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
