City of Ashes (The Mortal Instruments, #2) City of Ashes discussion


69 views
anyone finish it yet?!! I did

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Jennifer Forist i finished reading it last night and im kinda dissapointed somethings were still not wraped up... like jace and clary being related and what the inquister wispered to jace before she died... i still think it will come out jace and clary are not realated but i guess ill have to wait to find out :(


Kathleen Schwartz if they really are related it will ruin the whole series


message 3: by Brigid ✩ (new)

Brigid ✩ yeah that would suck...
i just finished it; i thought it was awesome!!! can't wait for the next one--still so many questions yet to be answered! GAH!


Cheryl Of course they're not related. The omnipotent author knows that so it's okay that they're lusting for each other because it'll all be fine in the end. Unfortunately, she forgot the readers don't know so Clary and Jace just come off looking like completely pathetic kids who both need a cold shower and some counselling on why incest is bad and actually making an effort to get over one another, instead of giving lip service (Clary) or acting like you don't see the problem (Jace).


message 5: by Sonia (new) - added it

Sonia well i love the book's ,but i do agree with all of you but lets hope the thrid one comes out good .


message 6: by Rees (new) - added it

Rees IF GOD WAS SO KIND, JACE AND CLARY WILL not BE RELATED!

Spoiler guys:
I read somewhere that Jace is actually the Inqusitors son, when she saw the scar on his shoulders and she sacrifices herself for him and smiles, also whispering something. AND of course aValentine won't say anything about that, he's finding the whole situation between his "children" rather amusing. What a sick bastard.

I think the plot will completely get ruined if that were the case, if Cas Clare worked up two whole books about them then that would be a waste. And since is Simon is out of the forbidden love triangle there would be no point in adding Sebastian.


Keona Chandler i had no idea what to come in the 5th book i cant wait, so i read only the things that can hold me enough not to go crazy.


Keona Chandler i think that we should just read the MI series then the ID and when the 5th book comes ut we all go nuts and race to see who can read it first and finish it first.
anyone agree????


Abiie #Rees, I think you're right ?? :)


Ranisha I have read the first # so many times. I just finished the 4th one that other day. And I am going nuts. I want the 5th book out already.


back to top