Mockingjay
discussion
Twilight or Hunger Games?
Ppl Twilight will never beat Hunger Games!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kenzie wrote: "Fiona wrote: "I loved Twilight, but real men do not sparkle."lollll, thats funny. :)"
Yea that's hilarious and true.
Hunger games. what the hell is with that vampire stuff? Real camps aren't like that. they're more like blood sucking monsters I like vamps that r like that but hunger games definitely sparkly vamps can't beat that. XD.
HUNGER GAMES BABYYYYYY!!!!! CANNT EXPRESS HOW MUCH I LOVE THE SEREIS IN WORDS !!!!!
maddie wrote: "HUNGER GAMES BABYYYYYY!!!!! CANNT EXPRESS HOW MUCH I LOVE THE SEREIS IN WORDS !!!!!"I totally agree
It only took me 3 days of nonstop reading to finish Twilight, and then I made my grandpa get me New Moon for my birthday. But when I got The Hunger Games from the library, I read it in 3 or 4 hours. And I was so mad at the library for not having the 2nd and 3rd books for the Hunger Games on the shelves. My grandpa got me the boxed set of all three for Christmas, which I had finished in less than a week. The fact that on the back of the book there is a comment from Suzanne Collins saying she read it under the table at a restaurant makes The Hunger Games that much better.Hunger Games Forever!!
I couldn´t pick. They are completely different books. And I can´t begin to imagine how a lot of people judge how they like the books only based on a love story in those particular books. Firstly-Hunger Games has much more depth to it than just Katniss´s and Peetas love story. Secondly-Twilight is a funny and touching love story with the "we-can´t-actually-be-together" touch to it (that is at last overcome by Bella becoming a vampire).
So-if I had to choose based on the story line and the depth of the book and plot and the message to the readers-I would give all my love and votes to Hunger Games. But if I had to pick a book based on the cute love story that made you giggle, at times frightened or excited, I would give my heart to Twilight.
But in the end-I appreciate Hunger Games a ton times more than Twilight, because some of the thoughts still linger with me from time to time. But if I just wanted something good to read (without getting depressed about mankind being cruel to one another), then I would choose Twilight.
Michelle wrote: "I really don't understand why people keep comparing every new YA book that comes out with Twilight. The Hunger Games is a dystopian book and there is not even a single supernatural being in it. Not..."I understand what you are saying, and I sorta agree. However, the comparison is about which is better written with better characters and so on. I can compare them because I powered my way through the first Twilight book, only because both my sisters and my girlfriend are big fans of them.
The Hunger Games is a much better written story that will get your attention from page one and keep it. It has characters that you can sometimes feel like you relate to, and doesn't have ridiculous characters, such as sparkly vampires. I mean seriously? Sparkly vampires? I can understand girls at an age group of 8-13 enjoying those vampires, since kids like sparkly stuff anyways, but not Teenagers or adults.
My girlfriend had several times tried to tease me and say she was going to put glitter on me so I would sparkle in the sun like a vampire. I replied by saying, If you turn me into a gay sparkly vampire, I will kill myself.
Long story short ...
Hunger Games
That is all
HUNGER GAMES ARE MY FAVORITE SERIES! I KNOW THIS BECAUSE I READ BOTH TWILIGHT AND HUNGER GAMES, I ACTUALLY JUST READ THEM BOTH FOR THE FIRST TIME THIS YEAR. I READ HUNGER GAMES IN FEB/MARCH AND TWILIGHT IN APR/MAY. THE ONLY THING THAT KEPT ME READING TWILIGHT SERIES WAS THE WAY STEPHANIE MEYERS USED GREAT DETAIL IN DESCRIBING THE CHARACTERS, OF COURSE I'M NOT THAT INTO VAMPIRE STUFF, BUT SERIOUSLY I LOVE THE COMMENT THAT KATE (DAUGHTER OF ZION) WROTE ABOUT HOW THE HUNGER GAMES KEEPS YOU HOOKED FROM THE VERY FIRST PAGE AND HOW IT HAS ALL OF THE ABOVE ROMANCE, VIOLENCE, POLITICS AND MORE. I LOVE YOU HUNGER GAMES, I HOPE THAT YOU WIN AND BECOME AN EVEN BIGGER FORCE TO BE RECKONED WITH!!! WOOT WOOT!!! I WILL BE THE ONE AT THE MOVIE THEATER WITH THE BLACK HUNGER GAMES T-SHIRT ON!!!! I CAN ONLY PRAY THAT THE MOVIE IS HALF AS GOOD AS THE BOOKS!!
Lauren wrote: "HUNGER GAMES ARE MY FAVORITE SERIES! I KNOW THIS BECAUSE I READ BOTH TWILIGHT AND HUNGER GAMES, I ACTUALLY JUST READ THEM BOTH FOR THE FIRST TIME THIS YEAR. I READ HUNGER GAMES IN FEB/MARCH AND TWI..."someone likes Caps Lock....
Hunger Games. Nuff said.
@ nick. this is how ur supposed to say it ........*ehemm* HUNGERRRRRRRR GAMMMEEESSSS!!!! lol
Hunger Games!!!! I loved the whole series... May have to read it again. I enjoyed twilight too to be fair but this series was original, superior writing and amazing characters.
never had read anything like it ...so much more original then any other ook out there
It's sin to say Twilight (jk) HUNGER GAMES ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I enjoyed both, but I think that when it comes to realism, The Hunger Games had it spot on. Considering they both fall into young adult/sci fi I was amazed at their stark differences.Also, I don't think that if The Hunger Games were turned into movies, they would use Robert Pattison, whom I loathe due to his poor performance as Edward. smh
Hunger Games is so much better!! Bella was just plain stupid...I hate when books have girl characters that have no common sense.
Lisa wrote: "Hunger Games is so much better!! Bella was just plain stupid...I hate when books have girl characters that have no common sense."same, they bother me so much!
I also pick The Hunger Games, I liked Twilight too but The Hunger Games is ranked up there with Harry Potter in my eyes...but I don't think people who haven't read both series should have any opinion.
This isn't even a real competition.... the two series are so entirely different that the only thing they have in common is being "YA series read equally by adults." It's like asking someone to compare Wuthering Heights and 1984... they just don't mesh. You're going to get plenty of answers based simply on people liking one genre over the other, or preferring action over romance... in other words, basic genre, plot, and story preferences.The only unbiased comparisons you can draw for comparison are going to based on writing style, character/plot development, etc. and I highly doubt anyone is going to write an essay here debating those aspects. ^_^
HUNGER GAMES!! BELLA DOES NOT HAVE A PERSONALITY, SHE DEPENDS ON EDWARD FOR EVERYTHING! KATNISS, ON THE OTHER HAND, SHOWS SHE CAN TAKE CARE OF HERSELF!! THAT'S HOW A STRONG WOMAN SHOULD BE :D
Never read twilight but Hunger games was very entertaining right up until the end. But it was still a very enjoyable story.
Hunger games rules!!!!!!
wooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!
Lol hahaha touche
Hunger Games. Always.
It's true that the characters in the hunger games are more likable. Katniss is always strong and Peeta always loves Katniss whereas the characters in twilight are self-destructive in everything that they do. I vote for the hunger games both in character development and writing style.
The one thing that both Twilight and the Hunger Games have in common is that the last book in each of the series is pretty much a trainwreck when compared to their predecessors.
Beth wrote: "The one thing that both Twilight and the Hunger Games have in common is that the last book in each of the series is pretty much a trainwreck when compared to their predecessors."LMFAO! BETH COULDN'T HAVE SAID IT BETTER MYSELF! WHY WAS THERE NO EPIC BATTLE I WAS READY FOR IT IN TWILIGHT AND KATNISS WAS JUST ANNOYING IN MOCKINGJAY AND I HATED THAT SUZANNE DIDN'T TELL US WHAT HAPPENED TO GALE!!!
I wish she had told us the name of katniss ans peetas kids!
What kind of question is this? HUNGER GAMES BY FAR!!!!
Lol...twilight?? Plz, very predictable
Hunger Games of course!!
Is this even a question? Hunger Games, definitely. Collins' characters are much more developed and believable. She isn't afraid to kill off characters. Not to mention, THG has strong themes that prevail throughout the novels while Twilight has virtually none. Twilight is crap, The Hunger Games is not.
Amanda said, "She's not afraid to kill of characters"-I agree...it made the book better and more interesting....however I miss some of her characters:(
Definitely, Hunger Games.
This is a joke right??????????? there is NO way you can ask this question!!! The Hunger games is a master piece. Kenzie Vampire are not stupid, there is a lot stories about vampires maybe you just read Twilight. Just because Vampires are not real does not mean is something stupid.
The Hunger Games. Clearly.
So they make 1 character look hot in the movies?? So what! Doesn't matter even though that's all people think.
HUNGER GAMES!!! TWILIGHT HAS NOTHING ON HUNGER GAMES! KATNISS WOULD BEAT BELLA ANYDAY....
Lol bella a whimp!!
The hunger games = the best choiceTwilight is what you want to read if you are a desperate teenage girl who gets off on teenage vampires.
Ofc, If you consider reading a teen vampire series....
Try: Vampire Academy
The plot = way better than twilight. And not as cliche.
I hate vampires... They're really gruesome
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Twilight (other topics)
The Hunger Games (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
More...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Hunger Games (other topics)Twilight (other topics)
The Hunger Games (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
More...
Specials by Scott Westerfield, I can't seem to get into it"
It gets better! I promise. I loved the whole series, although the 4th was my..."
I thought they were ok, not really wanting to read the next one.....