Mockingjay
discussion
Twilight or Hunger Games?
message 551:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Sep 01, 2011 03:28PM
Hunger Games. Definitely no contest whatsoever. The Hunger Games series may be a 3rd of the Twilight series but it has a way better plot. And bigger characters.
reply
|
flag
Ok, the size is more like half :)
The Hunger Games. Most definitely. It has a story that wants to keep you reading and Twilight is just romance and it drags on for way too long.
definitely THE HUNGER GAMES..but hunger games n twilight r different genres..so theres no point comparing em.:)
Hunger Games, no contest. While I never read Twilight, my sister told me everything about it and it just seems so shallow while the Hunger have substance. Love Peeta!
Sharon wrote: "Hunger Games. This story will stick with me for a long time. It was emotionally exhausting. I wouldn't change a thing about it, but the ending was sad and kind of depressing. Kat had the best possi..."Emotionally exhausting is correct! It took me awhile to shake the story off when I was done reading it
Michelle wrote: "I really don't understand why people keep comparing every new YA book that comes out with Twilight. The Hunger Games is a dystopian book and there is not even a single supernatural being in it. Not..."I agree completely.
Stupid question. Try again. Hunger games and twilight should never be used in the same sentence... its an insult to the Hunger Games.
To prove my point, here is a list of reasons to hate twilight.
http://bookstove.com/fantasy/why-i-ha...
Enjoy!
Michelle wrote: "I really don't understand why people keep comparing every new YA book that comes out with Twilight. The Hunger Games is a dystopian book and there is not even a single supernatural being in it. Not..."Like.
Emma wrote: "I'm so glad all of you are against Twilight. Anyone that think for a minute Twilight even compares to The Hunger Games in anyway should be killed."love.
Yes....Twilight is just compared cause its so popular..Its no better than all of the other vampire novels...
Ok, so There is no comparability to "The Twilight saga" And "The Hunger Games Trilogy"! "Twilight" showed very poor witting skills in effort to get the books out fast enough, and showcased a selfish weak young woman who used people to get what she wanted "eternal life" and "beauty". Were "The Hunger Games" Was well Written from the start ! had a not so courageous young woman but would do anything to protect the people she loved, even tho she failed to do so in the end, but gave the world a new chance at living free, But has to live with the ugly scars of war not only mental but physical. The only similarities are the love triangle's and the depression's. But by far "The Hunger Games" actually gave a point to the reader in which "Twilight" could never do. I am not going to lie I did like the Twilight book's but they did not give me a love for the character's like "The Hunger Games" did. So hand's down I will choose "The Hunger Games" book's over "Twilight" any day.
Hunger Games was awesome Catching Fire was Ok... Mocking Jay was Horribly slow nothing really happened
Hunger Games is waaaay better than Twilight. I liked Twilight up through Eclipse, Breaking Dawn just ruined the whole series for me. Hunger Games' romance wasn't a sick stalkery obsession like Twilight's. It was a natural build with tension and obstacles. You can say that Twilight has it, but it seemed forced.
Hunger Games and Mockingjay was excellent - she had to deal with all of her grief from the first two books, so parts of it are more internal, but the last half of the book was action-packed.
I agree with Sara (above)....Hunger Games all the way! The writing is far superior. I couldn't get past page 20 of Twilight...Sorry Twilight fans.
Don't get me wrong, I love The Hunger Games. Total 5 stars. But... I also like Twilight. Used to not like it, yes, but that's because the plot was way too typical. Now that I've gotten over that, the book seems amazing. Never will be as good as THG though.(well, you never know)And one more thing- why do people hate Twilight so much? Just wondering....
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Twilight (other topics)
The Hunger Games (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
More...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Hunger Games (other topics)Twilight (other topics)
The Hunger Games (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
More...


























