The Mortal Instruments discussion
Isabelle or Maia?
message 51:
by
Heather B
(new)
Apr 07, 2010 04:30PM
To be honest I kind of hope it's neither of them. I love them both I just don't really like either of them with Simon, I'm kind of hoping that there will be some one new.
reply
|
flag
I don't really care what she is, just someone new that I can see with him more than the other two.
I know this sounds wrong, but I want Isabelle to really like him for where it hurts her to see him with another girl so she knows what it really feels like.
Plus I want to see how our geeky boy Simon is going to handle it lol
I agree with another girl for Simon. But if I had to pick it would be Maia. Even though you don't know her that well I don't think Isabelle would be ready for any kind of relationship."Mimi wrote: "I don't think it's about who's better for who. I mean, Clary still wanted to be with Jace even though Simon was better for her, since at the time Jace was supposed to be her brother. I..."
"Mimi wrote:"I mean that Jace was supposedly her brother. I'm sure if some random person who had never read the book had to decide if it was better if she was with her brother or her best friend, then they'd pick her best friend, aka Simon."
I dont think so Even though Jace was her "brother" they loved each other and when you love someone nothing else matters. If you picked Simon it would have never worked out between Clary and him. Jace all the way !!
For now I like Isabelle better. I don't feel like I know enough about Maia yet. CoFA release so far away ;.;
Tia wrote: "I agree with another girl for Simon. But if I had to pick it would be Maia. Even though you don't know her that well I don't think Isabelle would be ready for any kind of relationship."Mimi wro..."
i agree with you!!!!!!!!!
and Maia is better for Simon but as a chracter i like Isabelle a lot better
I don't think you should base the choice on how either of them reacted to Simon. Maia only liked him from the beginning when she thought he was a mundane. And unlike Isabelle, Maia actually attacked Simon.Team Izzy. Although headstrong and a bit outspoken, she's cute and didn't try to kill Simon. He even said he used to think she was out of his league, but since he Turned they're basically equal.
Besides, I think Simon deserves someone as graceful and beautiful as Isabelle is described to be. It would also keep him close to Clary.
I just love Izzy and Simon together, it's a great dynamic, and I think their feelings for each other have definitely grown from COB! :DIzzy is amazing, and I love her, just like I love Simon, therefore in my mind, they belong together. That, and they have great literary chemistry!
Maia. Isabelle goes through Downworlders like its the cool thing to do. Maia needs love and Simon can do that.
But Maia and Simon, I think initially they''d start out fine, but slowly grow to dislike each other, or realise they can only be friends.
Tierney wrote: "I don't think you should base the choice on how either of them reacted to Simon. Maia only liked him from the beginning when she thought he was a mundane. And unlike Isabelle, Maia actually attacke..."So she liked him after ward when he was a Vamp as well
it was Isabelle who only went out originaly with him beacuase he was a mundane someone her parents wouldn't like, like Jace said.
Maia actaully liked him
yup i agree with Evelyn, Izzy should probably find someone who's better for her!
Although I like Isabelle more than I like Maia, Maia seems to fit Simon better. Isabelle should find someone else that can fit her life style better. Maia and simon both have super senses and super speed and super strength and super healing powers. Plus they both like the moon. Hence Simon is a daylighter, but he will come out at night, and that's when Maia is at her prime
um i think that they both will come out in the Day better!
I love Isabelle's character way more than Maia, but I think Maia is more Simon's kind of girl.
But Maia is more like Simon and Isabella needs someone amazing not just a guy who became a vampire she needs someone that can keep up. Simon said something about that in the CoB or the CoG.
i go with maia she liked simon from the beggining isabelle just played him like a violin maia ont he other hand liked hiom alot
Isabelle wrote: "i go with maia she liked simon from the beggining isabelle just played him like a violin maia ont he other hand liked hiom alot"yeah that's what i think too :D
I really cant deny the fact that Izzy has an edge to her but i think she's better for Simon than maia. to me Maia's personality isnt all that well readable. so i think that its izzy all the way.
maia is awesome. Isabelle is kinda like: "well, my partens don't like to see that i'm dating downworlders. who cares? I need attention."
I think she wouldn't match with Simon.
I'm pretty Sure the Izzy/Simon thing is gonna happen. I just think that Simon and Maia may be too similar to work, you know? They could be great friends, but I don't think it would go past that, at least for Simon. Isabelle's feelings are growing for him, and I like that dynamic. She may have wanted to tee off her parents initially, but I think she genuinely cares about Simon, and definitely as more than a friend by the time COFA is finished I'll bet
Cassandra Clair said that he dates both of them in the next book ?!?But i prefer Isabelle, Maia is a dog (excuse the pun)
Isabelle all the way!!!!!!!!!!!but for Simon Maia
I agree with Evelyn. Izzy is the best but for Simon it would have to be Maia.
Or maybe Simon will go crazy with the mark of Cain and end up alone wondering for eternity, just a thought.
It's possible. I have a theory about that, but I'm writing it for a fanfic, so I can't post it. :P
On second thoughts, he could always end up with me! :D
in my dreams i have Jace so anything's posible!
I think Isabelle because when you read City of Lost Souls you are told why Isabelle is the way she is and you see that she does in fact care about Simon, at least in my opinion. And there is a character that i love with Maia
I definitely prefer Isabelle. She's absolutely flawless, and one of my favorite characters. She has feelings she doesn't enjoy showing, just like me. I can strongly relate to her, other than the fact that she's described as perfect. Isabella has a sense of humor and a great heart. She cares so much about family and is just amazing. She doesn't fall in love easily, then Simon just comes into her life. I love her sass and sarcasm. Her bitchiness and badass attitude. I also adore Maia, but she sometimes is just too stubborn and misunderstanding. She constantly is clueless. I ship Maia with Jordan, and Isabelle with Simon. Hope someone agrees!
