that one group on goodreads...! discussion
Debates
>
Harry Potter or Twilight?
message 51:
by
elizabeth
(new)
Apr 14, 2010 05:45PM
lol
reply
|
flag
I hope they do, but for those who haven't read the books, his final scene wouldn't have as much effect.
That was depressing when I read about him dying. And I'm so pissed that they didn't have any House Elves in the fifth movie!
Yeah, taking out Hermione's club...I think the Director's and such are too tight on money that they couldn't afford the CG needed for it. Because 70% of the Harry Potter movies are just CG.
WHAT? J.K. ROWLING'S ONE OF THE RICHEST PEOPLE IN THE WORLD! HOW COME SHE DIDN'T PUT THEM IN THERE HERSELF?!
She did in the second movie...Now who knows.
they take out a lot from that movie :-\i cried when Dobby died. well was about to anyway
I just shrugged at all the deaths in that series.Then again in real life death is a funny concept to me.
Dobby's kind of upset me because I wasn't ready for him to die.
yeah me too, the same for Hedwig, Remus, Tonks, Fred, and Mad-Eye Moody. Everyone who i liked dies in the 7th one, i noticed. :(
All those off-screen deaths that you find out about when Harry mentions them.I need to re-read the book and spend the whole time understanding where Voldemoet(Tom Riddle Jr.) is coming from.
I like antagonist characters more then the main ones.
Harry Potter is way better than Twilight. Way, WAY better.
Harry grew, learned, lost things precious to him and yet still came out on top in the end, where as Bella had everything handed to her on a silver platter.
Because HP was a coming of age series, where as Twilight was a overly overrated romance.
Exactly! Plus, from what I have heard, the HP charries are just better.
Except Ginny is a Mary-Sue. At least she isn't a main character.
Eventhough Ginny is a mary-sue at least the person who plays her is better actress than Stewart any day.
There are worse actresses, plus with the role of Bella you aren't really given much, a completely characterless girl who ignores people who want to be friends and would rather be the boy who wants nothing to do with her.There are some girls like that, but Bella is the only one that ignores/treats badly those who are just trying to help her, if it gets in the way of Edward.
Alas dear Thestral I knew him well...in America.Sorry.
So can you see thestrals? unfourtunatly, I can.
I can't see thestrals, I don't even know someone who has died. I love Luna she's brillant, honest, and super funny at times.
Loser's Lurgy, Crumple-horned Snorkaks, and Blibbering Humdingers are some of Luna's best made-up things.
I would so read the Quibler. I could get those cool glasses with the nice lenses. Also not only will I read books from the leftcover/rightcover but read upsidedown too. Reading upside down is so Jetsons.
>_> Jetsons? Like that one show that was from Hanna-Barbera?
The quibbler is... interesting. They need to make a muggle version, I would definetly subscribe.
Thought so it is that cartoon series...I grew up loving that show along with The Flinstones...
Dovewing wrote: "The quibbler is... interesting. They need to make a muggle version, I would definetly subscribe."haha me too!
*sighs* without Luna Lovegood, Harry Potter would actually be pretty boring.
Not too boring. But certenly much less funney. Remember the quidditch match she narrated?
HARRY POTTER I HATE TWILIGHT!!!!!!!!!! PIE!!!!!!!! RANDOMNESS!!!!!!!!!
There should be a question mark there...
Tweety is flawed anyway.
Tweety is a girl right.....? Because one time I wasnt sure.
Which is creepy when you think about it.
o.o I do not think about Tweety Bird in that manner, sicko!
No, I mean in the way that even though Tweety is a boy he is still treated like a girl.Like if you had a son but dressed him up in dresses, did his hair cutely and raise him to believe he was a girl, but then one day he finds out he is a boy and...well the rest is up to your imagination.
:P I know.I have an old backpack where Tweety Bird is laying on his side in a bikini. o.o *confused*
Maybe Tweety is gender confused, that is quite common to be confused with one's gender. Maybe even though Tweety is a boy he feels as though he should be a girl.
So either Tweety is gender confused...or a hermaphrodite(both genders). O_o I'm ruining that small part of my childhood.
I know its a boy because I remember in this one cartoon he had to go to the bathroom so case solved. Why did he have to go to the bathroom in the middle of the cartoon I don't know? Gender confused, hmm? maybe the original creators were really unsure and treated him like a girl. Then years later the changed their minds and wanted him to be a boy.
