Weekly Short Stories Contest and Company! discussion
Totally Random
>
Chat (Cookies and tea allowed in this room)
message 2401:
by
Marie
(new)
Jun 15, 2015 08:32PM

reply
|
flag


Hey Pirates, here's a question from Bill. Your thoughts are appreciated, thank you :)
****
I'd like to get some feedback on how other authors review books. What criteria do you follow? What are the dos and don'ts? How do grammatical mistakes factor in? I'm about to give my first review and want to make sure i'm on the same page as everyone else.
When I first joined Goodreads, I was prompted to rate 20 books that I'd read previously, which I did. Almost all of the titles I rated are very well known, a lot of them are considered "classics." Even so, I only gave 5 stars to my absolute favorites. One book in particular is making me question my reviewing criteria: Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury. Obviously, it's a great book; it's read in most high schools for Christ's sake. But I never really got into it, and if asked for my thoughts, would say, "Meh, it was OK." I gave it 3 stars.
My last question (or series of questions) is this: If I gave a "classic" 3 stars...then where does that leave Billy-Joe Crunkenstein and his book about were-raccoons? Are those 20 book ratings of mine flawed? Too harsh? Should I rate indie books on a different scale than well-known, traditionally published titles?
Criteria may vary from author to author; so please comment if you feel you have something to add...for Billy-Joe's sake.
****
I'd like to get some feedback on how other authors review books. What criteria do you follow? What are the dos and don'ts? How do grammatical mistakes factor in? I'm about to give my first review and want to make sure i'm on the same page as everyone else.
When I first joined Goodreads, I was prompted to rate 20 books that I'd read previously, which I did. Almost all of the titles I rated are very well known, a lot of them are considered "classics." Even so, I only gave 5 stars to my absolute favorites. One book in particular is making me question my reviewing criteria: Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury. Obviously, it's a great book; it's read in most high schools for Christ's sake. But I never really got into it, and if asked for my thoughts, would say, "Meh, it was OK." I gave it 3 stars.
My last question (or series of questions) is this: If I gave a "classic" 3 stars...then where does that leave Billy-Joe Crunkenstein and his book about were-raccoons? Are those 20 book ratings of mine flawed? Too harsh? Should I rate indie books on a different scale than well-known, traditionally published titles?
Criteria may vary from author to author; so please comment if you feel you have something to add...for Billy-Joe's sake.

****
I'd like to get some feedback on how other authors review books. What criteria do you follow? What are t..."
I don't think it's possible to have a standardized way to rate books, because there are so many personal reasons why they do or don't appeal to different people.
I rate mine based on my own personal enjoyment.If the grammar is poor enough to have interfered with my reading enjoyment, I'll note it in my comments.
I don't care if a book is obscure, a classic, or a current best seller. I've given good and bad rating to all three.

1. Extra Credit (5 Stars): This is an extremely rare grade that I give to a medium that I not only liked, but thought it exceeded expectations. Whenever I watch something, I usually expect that it will be likeable. When I give something an EC grade, it really blew me away and changed me forever. The only movie to get this grade so far is The Lego Movie, because it gave me the creative fuel I needed to get out of a slump of depression.
2. Pass (4 stars): This is the most common grade I’ve given any movie, TV show, match, or book. When I watch something, I want to enjoy it, so I don’t intentionally pick out flaws or even dig very deep to find them. An example of a UFC match with a passing grade is the 2013 Fight of the Year, Gilbert Melendez vs. Diego Sanchez. It was exciting, just like a UFC match should be.
3. Mixed (3 stars): This is exactly how it sounds. I liked whatever I was watching or reading, but not enough to give it a passing grade. I liked it despite the overwhelming number of flaws in the medium, and these are things that are obvious enough to even the most brain-dead viewers. The only movie to receive this grade so far is Dead Man Down, where the lack of screen time for Bad News Barrett and the unresolved and overwhelming bullying storyline prevent it from being a favorite.
4. Fail (2 stars): I’ve watched the show or read the book all the way through and I hated it. Very rarely will I finish a book or show that I hate, but it does happen, more often with TV and movies than with books. The last time I gave a failing grade was when I was reviewing a UFC lightweight bout between Clay Guida and Gray Maynard. While Gray was swinging away, Clay was evasive and timid, which made a brutal brawl an impossibility between these two. Clay Guida almost got points taken away by referee Dan Miragliotta for being a cowardly fighter. Almost is not enough.
5. Did Not Finish (1 star): In other words, the medium was so bad that I couldn’t stand to see it all the way through without having my brain explode. Normally when I can’t finish a book, I put it down and that’s the last you’ll ever hear from me. No reviews, just a brief show of frustration in a few characters or less. An example of a book I would give a DNF grade to is “Fifty Shades Darker” by EL James. Christian Grey is an unbearable asshole who doesn’t deserve to have a girlfriend in the first place, and yet, Anastasia Steele is so love sick that she’ll shack up with anybody at this point whether they’re nice or mean.

A book review is one's own personal reaction to a book, with or without explanation. Although elaboration, when done well, is helpful. That a book is held in esteem by anyone or any group does not factor in on my personal reaction to the book, although I may question my own reaction to a 'popular' book to better understand both who I am and the context of the society within which I find myself.
For example, I have rated the EXTREMELY popular and critically acclaimed books The Lord of the Flies and The Lion and the Witch and the Wardrobe only 1 star. But perhaps I am not a good example of what to do in the writing world. But, for better or for worse, this is my opinion.

Calcium carbide reacts with water to produce a type of flammable gas that can give off light when ignited. It is how miners powered the lamps on their helmets and certain types of vintage lamps are powered this way.
For you more violent types, this gas is also used to propel projectiles from certain types of cannons.
I hope this was helpful :)


This morning I received the message below from Melissa Andres. She has left the WSS and Goodreads for a time in order to deal with life's craziness. I've always been amazed by the consistency and quality of poems and stories that Melissa has submitted in her time with us. Her comments, feedback, friendly conversation and company will be missed.
From Melissa:
I just wanted to let everyone in the group know that I am, regretfully, having to drop out of GoodReads for a while. I have been unable to participate as of late because I have so many things going on. I wasn't sure how to send this to everyone in our group so if you could pass this information on for me I would greatly appreciate it. When things slow down (hopefully soon!) I will definitely be back. I sure miss the weekly contests and feel as if I have made many good friends.
Thanks so much!
Melissa :(

Awesome! It's funny you say about this because I was coming up with little ideas for a fantasy story that would hopefully make up a series over time. Thanks for the facts, Angie!
Update: Oh... I feel dumb. The current story contest is "Light in the Dark." Hey I might work on part of this story and post a chapter for this week's contest!!

This morning I received the message below from Melissa Andres. She has left the WSS and Goodreads for a time in order to deal with life's craziness. I've always been amazed by the consiste..."
Oh no! Hope things work out. I'll pray for the best!

This morning I received the message below from Melissa Andres. She has left the WSS and Goodreads for a time in order to deal with life's craziness. I've always been amazed by the consiste..."
She's an amazing storyteller and an awesome human being. If anybody has the strength to get through life's obstacles, it's her. We'll miss you, Melissa-Pie! :(


https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
And link to the poll:
https://www.goodreads.com/poll/show/1...

Thank you, Garrison!
Thank you, R!
I'm on cloud nine. And yes, it's the perfect birthday present I could have hoped for! :)

Luna, the brown seal-point kitty with icy blue eyes, was dying from feline cancer and irritable bowel syndrome. The Humane Society did everything they could to keep her alive, but ultimately, she had to be euthanized due to being in constant pain. This made me sad when Mom talked about it.
Nacho, the yellowish-orange kitty, is FIV+ and could only be adopted either as the only cat in the home or with another FIV+ cat. Nacho was successfully adopted alongside another FIV+ cat and is living in a happy and loving home.
I have pictures of both cats in my Animal Family folders on Face Book and Deviant Art if you want to see them. There’s even one where Luna and Nacho are in the same shot and have been dubbed the feline super couple LuNacho.
I also have a synopsis in my private creative writing folder of a story idea where Luna and Nacho are the main characters. In this case, they’re living in a land of magic and mysticism known as Orchardville. Luna is a wizard kitty and Nacho is the stud muffin warrior who rescues her.
Rest in peace, Luna-Tuna. Live well, Macho-Nacho.



In The Bazaars Of Hyderabad
What do you sell O ye merchants ?
Richly your wares are displayed.
Turbans of crimson and silver,
Tunics of purple brocade,
Mirrors with panels of amber,
Daggers with handles of jade.
What do you weigh, O ye vendors?
Saffron and lentil and rice.
What do you grind, O ye maidens?
Sandalwood, henna, and spice.
What do you call , O ye pedlars?
Chessmen and ivory dice.
What do you make,O ye goldsmiths?
Wristlet and anklet and ring,
Bells for the feet of blue pigeons
Frail as a dragon-fly’s wing,
Girdles of gold for dancers,
Scabbards of gold for the king.
What do you cry,O ye fruitmen?
Citron, pomegranate, and plum.
What do you play ,O musicians?
Cithar, sarangi and drum.
what do you chant, O magicians?
Spells for aeons to come.
What do you weave, O ye flower-girls
With tassels of azure and red?
Crowns for the brow of a bridegroom,
Chaplets to garland his bed.
Sheets of white blossoms new-garnered
To perfume the sleep of the dead.
-Sarojini Naidu




This coming Wednesday (September 9th), I’m headed to the airport to begin my family vacation in Steamboat Springs, Colorado. I come home from vacation on the 14th of that same month. That means I’ll spend five days in a place that has been described as “beautiful” and “dog friendly” by my mother. I’ve been in lots of places that were beautiful and dog friendly from Monterey Bay, California to Long Beach, Washington to Seaside, Oregon to Victoria, BC, Canada. If Steamboat Springs promises the same thing as those places, I’m in for a relaxing and stress-free vacation, which is the only kind of vacation I’ll do these days.
For all of you internet folk, it means the same thing as every other time I go on vacation: limited internet access and an inability to create new pieces of art whether it’s writing, photography, or drawing. For Deviant Art and Face Book, this means the most activity you’ll get out of me is replying to messages and nothing more. For Good Reads, particularly the WSS Contest, it means I won’t be able to participate in that week’s competition. For Read Together, Blog Together, don’t worry about a thing, because as soon as I get back from vacation, the first thing I’m going to do is read and review “So…I Met a Vampire” by Paul McAvoy. Last and sure as hell not least, Mr. Andy Peloquin, you don’t need to worry about a thing either, because your September 8th guest blog post about music and creativity will go live at midnight that day. Blogger.com allows for delayed posting, so I’m not scrambling to put things together at the last minute.
Just like with all vacations past, present, and future, I will return to the internet and I will get settled back into my daily routine. Try not to laugh when I say “daily routine”. I may be jobless, but that doesn’t mean I sit around with my thumbs in my ass all day long. Hehe! We’ve got ears, say cheers!



In The Bazaars Of Hyd..."
What a lovely poem, Ajay - I've never read it before. I can see why you loved it as a child. I think I will read it to my girls later, I've a feeling that it will spark their imaginations. Thankyou for posting it.
My favorites as a child that were read to me by my Mum were:
Ozymandias by Percy Bysshe Shelly, The Tyger by William Blake, The Listeners by Walter de la Mare and Sea Fever by John Masefield - I can't think how many times we must have got Mum to read those over the years and I read them to mine two now.







Just like with any vacation I take, my time in a new city will mean time away from the internet. For Deviant Art, that means no new pieces of art will be uploaded during that time. For the WSS group on Good Reads, it means I’ll take a one-week sabbatical from the contests (though I still plan on competing in the “Patterns” prompt). For Face Book, it means my “heavy metal for the day” and “Ungrateful Mind Rewired” posts will be nonexistent (sorry, Jamie!).
But just like all good things, my vacation in New Orleans will eventually end and I’ll be back home to get the creative juices flowing yet again. I leave on Friday, October 30th and I return home on Wednesday, November 4th. As much as I love spending time with my online family, a break from the everyday grind is just what the doctor ordered. I opted out of the Steamboat Springs vacation back in September, though that was the right choice because sitting on my ass during long car rides would have driven me nuts. New Orleans will be a better choice for me, so I’m definitely getting on that plane.
If you’re planning on robbing my house while I’m away, there are two things you need to know. One, you’ll never find it in a million years. Two, even if you do, you’ll have a pissed off older brother and a spitfire niece to contend with. I don’t like your odds. Hehe! We’ve got ears, say cheers!
Books mentioned in this topic
Falling Worlds (other topics)Worlds with Ruby (other topics)
Worlds with Ruby (other topics)
Falling Worlds (other topics)
Your God Is Too Small (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Elias Canetti (other topics)Morris Berman (other topics)
Noam Chomsky (other topics)
Jane Jacobs (other topics)
Marshall Sahlins (other topics)
More...