Harry Potter discussion
Personal Preferences
>
Twilight??? What do YOU think?
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Miss Ryoko
(last edited Jan 02, 2010 03:43PM)
(new)
Jan 02, 2010 03:46PM
I'm saying your comment of "ooh you got burned" was immature and I could tell a kid wrote it
reply
|
flag
Ella we already knew you were 10. It's not really important, unless it has something to do with your comment, such as, I don't really like Twilight, but I'm 10 so I'm not really into romance.
Teresa~*Bring it on 2010*~ wrote: "Who says all vampires in all books have to be exactly the same? Authors can make their vampires any way they like. I mean, you don't have to like Twilight by any means, but authors have creative au..."very nicely said, teresa! i personally wrote a story about fairies a few years ago and mine are portrayed NOTHING like a lot of these other authors out there--take that, melissa marr! hahaha, so yay for authors being creative!
i mean, vampires have to be "relatively" the same... stephenie probably couldnt get away writing something like "vampires dont drink blood! they drink GATORADE!" or whatever. but details should be entirely up to the author!
LOOOOOOOOOOL!!! I burst out laughing at "vampires don't drink blood! They drink gatorade!"hilarious! (and true!)
I want to write a story now where my vampires drink gatorade ;-)
lol when you do post it because i will read it!
Haha! Thanks for the support!! ;-)
i wanna read that too! ARCTIC BLAST!!!!
...and get energy off of it... i wonder about the effects of it on vampires. hahaha what happens to them if it gives humans energy?
Shae wrote: "Vampires are stupid."Amelia*annabeth&percy*sittin in a tree* wrote: "not if they drink gatorade..."
yes they very much are. not exactly counting buffy. its a story about vampires....kinda.
I agree with Courtney up at the top. Seriously! I mean, you're immortal right, so you go back to high school?? come on! Anyway, have you guys read Nightlight (by the Harvard Lampoon)? It's a hilarious parody. you should read it!!!
Hey! Don't be dissin' my gatorade drinkin' vampires! LOL...well, actually they're Amelia's, I just stole her idea ;-)
no they're OURS :D
Abi wrote: "I agree with Courtney up at the top. Seriously! I mean, you're immortal right, so you go back to high school?? come on! Anyway, have you guys read Nightlight (by the Harvard Lampoon)? It's a hilari..."I read it!! It was awesome!
:-[ (that was my sad attempt at a vampire face in response to you Amelia...but it looks more like a sad face, but I wanted it to be happy)
I'm watching PPP discover eBay A++ THEY ALL SAY!
Teresa~*Bring it on 2010*~ wrote: ":-[ (that was my sad attempt at a vampire face in response to you Amelia...but it looks more like a sad face, but I wanted it to be happy)"haha ack i guess i would be hard to make a face with fangs... ooo what about this? :} its sort of happy with a fang!
Teresa~*Bring it on 2010*~ wrote: "HAHA! I love that, one fang."i love it!
it reminds me kinda of a bulldog too, because sometimes their teeth stick out, haha
Harry Potter is wayyy better than twilight. Twilight is fun to read, but when you think of it, the plot isn't new. Also, the books have no moral at all..
Yea, how old did you think I was?
like, 15. same as me.. you share my sense of humour:)
He he he. I take that as a compliment Abi! Thx! Well, I GTG, me and my mom are going to go watch HP.
good for you! I love watching the movies! (Philosopher's stone is hilarious!! Ron is so cute)
I know! He has always been cute!
Tina wrote: "Harry Potter is wayyy better than twilight. Twilight is fun to read, but when you think of it, the plot isn't new. Also, the books have no moral at all.."i think those books have plenty of morals :P
but HP's are more obvious and universal
definitely! rupert grint is one of my favorite actors, and i agree with amelia. twilight has lots of morals harry potter just has TONS more and they're all better. but i must say PJO has excellent morals and a great many too! ;)
Harry potter is about breavery... Love... ect.
Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend.
Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend.
Girija :) wrote: "definitely! rupert grint is one of my favorite actors, and i agree with amelia. twilight has lots of morals harry potter just has TONS more and they're all better. but i must say PJO has excellent ..."PJ ALL THE WAY!!!! AHHHHHHH!
Ella wrote: "Harry potter is about breavery... Love... ect.Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend."
out of curiosity, have you read Twilight?
No she hasn't. And I'm finding it rather annoying
Sorry, I was quoting from MLIA.
i personally would refrain from making such one-sided comments about books you havent read...it makes one look immature and unreasonable. Just a suggestion, though :)
That's what I've been trying to tell her
Amelia*annabeth&percy*sittin in a tree* wrote: "Ella wrote: "Harry potter is about breavery... Love... ect.Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend."
out of curiosity, have you read Twilight? "
I haven't read the Twilight books, but I kind of want to...
you should! i liked them. they're not as "interesting" as HP, but i think they're good in their own special little way, haha
and though they're really obese books, they're really easy to read!
I read the books, they were just ok in my book. The movies were ok too (although Breaking Dawn Part 2 I barely watched.) The thing about Twilight was that things just kept getting crazier with every book which is how it is with HP too but it's just different. Plus I view HP as being more middle grades (3-6 but enjoyable for all) and Twilight is more Teen to me. I probably will not let my daughter read them until she reaches high school and with any luck by then they will be a memory. Now HP on the other hand she is allowed to read as often as she likes as the only thing that is questionable in HP is a bit of snogging and a few words that my husband doesn't appreciate (he hates that the characters say damn and bloody hell...we have to change the words when he is around) whereas with Twilight you have some downright violent and inappropriate behavior. Ok so they don't do anything sexual until the very last book but there is enough of Edward sleeping in Bella's room to make me say NO to the books for my kids.
Harry Potter>VoldemortVoldemort>Cedric Diggory
Cedric Diggory=Edward.
Edward=twilight. Soo…
Voldemort>Edward
Harry Potter> Edward
Harry Potter>twilight
Simple!!
well first of all Twilight is supposed to be more of a romance YA book so.... of course I prefer HP. not a big fan of romance.
I read twilight in like 2008-09 and I loved it then read all the books etc but now that I've grown up a fair bit (at least as far as taste goes) the piss me off. 1 sure ok Edward her true love, fine then. But it makes me sick that when he is legit Bella's boyfriend he doesn't let her do ANYTHING. Not even when she whines and complains.
2 the vampire sparklesparkle. I guess the concept is ok, if you read Stephanie Meyer's description of exactly why that happens, it's ok. But she's taken away like all of their three weaknesses. Garlic has no effect, nothing can pierce their MARBLE GRANITE PURE WHITE SKIN so wooden stakes are out the window and sun makes them sparkle like dewdrops on a spring morn. So basically they're invincible to mortals, and they can't be killed unless by a werewolf or other vampire. Annoying when a lot of people wanna kill Edward. I would if he was trapping me in that pseudo controlling relationship. I'd rip him up and set his a** on fire.
