make or break

[Feliks, Co-Moderator]

Is there any classic Hollywood studio-era star who has at least ten performances you rank your favorite in all cinema?

This question inspired by recent comments made in this group.

I myself can name several stars who have delivered fully ten roles which I rank all-time greats in the history of film.

For me, probably: Stewart, Fonda, Tracy, March, Peck.

[Betsy]

That's an interesting question and for those you listed, I can honestly say no. I can't even think of 10 for my favorite of the bunch, Henry Fonda. I shall have to think if there's anyone that qualifies for 10.

[Feliks, Co-Moderator]

Very good. I wonder if such a super-selective ranking, sees anyone make the grade.

For example, ardent fans of Olivier; or Paul Newman.

Does even the most ardent groupie admit to a full ten performances they stand behind, as ranking among their all-time favorites?

I suppose this question dissects 'subjectivity' vs 'objectivity'. For example, many of us are sympathetic to poor Gail Russell. Our heart went out to her.

But how would we rate her critically? That's what I'm trying to get at.

[Betsy]

Ah, that's a different thing when talking objective and subjective. I haven't seen enough of Gail Russell to really give an opinion. You might make the same point about Gene Tierney, and I would give her a higher rating since I've seen more of her movies.

[Feliks, Co-Moderator]

I will let responders to this question figure out which way they prefer to answer. It may have begun as a muddle in my mind.

[Jill H.]

I'm not sure I can list 10 films of any of my favorite actors. Bogart might come close or Olivier or William Powell. Maybe 10 is too much to expect even from the most avid fan.

[Spencer]

Bess Flowers.

OK, not really a star but she's been in at least 16 films that I rank at least 4 out of five stars.

[Spencer]

I counted 11 for Newman.

[Spencer]

10 for Bogie.

[Betsy]

I think I have seen more Cary Grant movies (40+) than any others, but I wouldn't rate 10 high enough to count. I should try the Bogart movies, now that you mention them.