Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

The Maps of the Wilderness: An Atlas of the Wilderness Campaign, Including all Cavalry Operations, May 2-6, 1864 (Savas Beatie Military Atlas Series)
This topic is about The Maps of the Wilderness
6 views
Issues with Quotes > Adding a quote

Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Eric Williams | 36 comments I tried adding the following quote:

Some historians believe that the Wilderness could have been as great a victory for Lee as that of Chancellorsville a year before. The difference was the absence of both Stonewall Jackson and Lee's characteristic aggressiveness. As indicated earlier, a recent historian believed Lee put his troops in motion a day too late and when he did, he issued contradictory orders to his lieutenants, Ewell and Hill . . . Gordon Rhea went a bit further in his indictment of Lee. He took issue with the commonly held belief that Lee had "trapped Grant in the Wilderness". "He was merely the fortunate beneficiary of sloppy Federal planning and reconnaissance." He went on the write that "his failure to take affirmative steps to impede Grant's progress or to accelerate his own army's response exposed the Confederates to peril." Rhea bluntly noted that "Lee made several decisions during the battle which put his army and his cause in serious jeopardy." Perhaps Lee's most serious shortcoming during the battle was his inability to coordinate the two wings of his army, and as a result they fought as independent entities.

Instead of it "going through", I got the message "1 error prohibited this quote from being saved:" but it didn't actually give a reason, just "Please try again later." This sort of thing has been happening over and over again for the last couple months: It won't actually save the quote but also won't give a reason for not saving it. Sometimes when I tried some time later to save it, the quote might (but not always) get saved.

Can someone else try to save this particular quote?


Eric Williams | 36 comments Just tried again today (February 5) and it failed yet again.


Eric Williams | 36 comments Tried it again today (February 7th) and it finally went through.


back to top