Book recommendation for two version of a scene

[MHTomas]

Hi all — quick question from a writer testing a scene: if a story gives the protagonist one impossible choice — betray a friend or lose everything they love — which would pull you in more as a reader: (A) a knife-in-the-dark betrayal, or (B) a slow, heart-breaking sacrifice?

I’m finishing a book in mystery fantasy and I’m stuck on which version feels more honest. If you’ve read anything recently that handled that well, I’d love recommendations — and if you want a short (2-page) peek at how I handle it, DM me and I’ll send a sample. No pressure, just curious what readers think.

[Maranda]

B the sacrifice. I believe that will make the reader love the protagonist more.

[Band]

(B) a slow, heart-breaking sacrifice, Because I see more people liking the slow heart breaking more than right there back stabbing personally.

[MHTomas]

Band wrote: "(B) a slow, heart-breaking sacrifice, Because I see more people liking the slow heart breaking more than right there back stabbing personally."
Thanks so much for your thoughts! I’m leaning that way too

[MHTomas]

Maranda wrote: "B the sacrifice. I believe that will make the reader love the protagonist more."
I really appreciate your take!