Goodreads Librarians Group discussion
Book & Author Page Issues
>
(DONE) Private Iris Case 11 Delisted Unfairly
date
newest »
newest »
https://help.goodreads.com/s/article/..."Individual comics, unless they have an ISBN or ASIN (individual Kindle editions only)" are considered non-book items.
Are these Kindle editions? They do all have ASINs…
Shim wrote: "https://help.goodreads.com/s/article/..."Individual comics, unless they have an ISBN or ASIN (individual Kindle editions only)" are considered non-book items.
Are the..."
Issues 1-11 all have ISBNs - Issue 11 specifically has an ISBN of 9789719477112. But then they switched to ISSNs for seemingly no reason later on
The records I see on Goodreads do not have ISBNs, only ASINs.9789719477112 Doesn’t show up on Goodreads.
I know - I don't know where those ASINs were sourced from, however. I do have scans on Internet archive of cases 1-18, which is where my ISBNs are sourced from. Here is the internet archive link (https://archive.org/details/private-i...)
Nevermind - this got fixed. Request closed!
Yes I updated the status of the book record initially, tbd if it is correct
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8...
This ruling, however, doesn't make any sense. All of the issues in the Private Iris series follow the same format - they're roughly 30 page comics aimed at kids. It doesn't make sense that Case 11 should be singled out as "invalid", since it's the same format/structure as all of the other Private Iris cases.