When the Evidence Points the Wrong Way

[Steve]

Have you ever read a true crime story where the “obvious” suspect wasn’t the right one—but the investigation seemed determined to make the case fit anyway?

I spent decades in New Mexico courtrooms defending people accused of serious crimes, and one case has stayed with me above all others: a quadruple homicide in a remote mountain cabin, where key evidence was misread, leads went cold, and the narrative took on a life of its own.

I’m curious—what true crime books or cases have you read where the official story unraveled in surprising ways? How did it change your view of the justice system?

My own deep dive into this question became Echoes of Torreón, told from the defense table. I’d love to hear your recommendations—and your take on when investigators get it wrong

[Fishface]

Well, the West Memphis Three is a great example of that.

[Fishface]

Raw Deal: The Untold Story of NYPD's Cannibal Cop is one

[Steve]

Very true. Has anyone written about the Memphis Three? I am thinking of those guys charged in Central Park NYNY and eventually exonerated.

[Fishface]

Steve wrote: "Very true. Has anyone written about the Memphis Three? I am thinking of those guys charged in Central Park NYNY and eventually exonerated."

Oh, yeah, if you look at the TC bookshelves under West Memphis Three there are more than a few books to choose from!

[Fishface]

Steve wrote: "Very true. Has anyone written about the Memphis Three? I am thinking of those guys charged in Central Park NYNY and eventually exonerated."

Another great example!

[Steve]

I am in the process of writing a true crime novel about a quadruple homicide. I am not that "into" TC but being a criminal defense trial lawyer since the Civil War (slight exaggeration), I have seen it all and writing it has seemed natural. I had a couple of people critique my first five chapters and one said it was well written but he didn't bond with anyone yet and after 50 pages it's too late. I have read that I should focus on how my story makes people feel. At the same time I need to be accurate to the facts. It's a tough tightrope to walk

[Steve]

So I tooted my horn. Ok, more of a clarinet or a basoon. But I tooted it and yet, not a single review. Patience is a learned virtue but soon forgotten.

[Fishface]

Steve wrote: "So I tooted my horn. Ok, more of a clarinet or a basoon. But I tooted it and yet, not a single review. Patience is a learned virtue but soon forgotten."

Most people will wait until the whole book is out so they can review the finished product!

[Steve]

Yeah I wanted to collaborate with my betters, maybe get some pointers. But that makes sense I guess.