Overview for Twilight

[Joshua]

Hello fellow readers-

Creating this thread for our eighteenth overall book but our second book of round 5.


Please share your final ranking and thoughts below

[Alicia]

Least fav: Tyler
Fav: Alice
Rating: 6.9

[Savanah]

Least fave - James
Fave - Alice
Rating 7.3

[Savanah]

Average rating - 6.6

[Joshua]

Favorite: Alice - The most interesting character to me. Love the future vision and her wanting to be besties with Bella.

Least Favorite: Billy Black - Annoying. Tries to thwart romance because he has a personal vendetta against vampires but won't tell Bella why just keeps saying "hes bad! dont trust him!" like... its a teen girl who is at a rebellious age. give good reason or shut the fuck up!!!

Rating: 5. I feel like this maybe should be lower but the ending is nice and her running through the airport figuring out how to save her mom is gripping. The attack at the dance studio, the reveal that James was using the old home videos was fun. And that was like 1.5 chapters out of 24 chapters + a prologue and epilogue so all that other time its repetitive motion of high school girl omg i like a boy life..... and it wasnt great. Sometimes it was fun but like... Edward demanding to know he favorite color, band, and small details is.............. eh.

[Alex]

Favorite Character: Charlie. Bella and Edward steal most of the scenes but I found both of their characters to be rather bland and under developed. Charlie wasn't the best father but he always tried to improve his relationship with Bella and that was endearing.

Least Favorite Character: Mike. What a freaking weirdo. As Bella would say, he's like a lapdog begging for attention. If this book was written in 2024, his obessive behaviour with Bella would not be PC.

Rating: 7.3. It wasn't a literary master piece but I enjoyed the story for what it was!