Percy Jackson Book Club discussion
Deep dives
>
ana vs sadie, battle of the narrators part 2 - a deep dive
date
newest »
newest »
another great deep dive (even though I haven't read Magnus Chase or kane chronicles yet)
Thank you!!! Ana is from Daughter of the Deep🫶🏼
WE NEED MORE FEMALE NARRATORS RICK!!!!!!
I like the daughter of the deep. It had a good storyline but personality wise I just like Sadie better.
Yeah, I'm gonna agree, even though I LOVE daughter of the deep, yeah, Sadie is a better narrator
I NEED MORE FEMALE NARRATORS! PLEASE UNCLE RICK, PLEASE!
Today's deep dive is spoiler free and we are going to talk about the girl narrators, Sadie and Ana.
We shall tackle once more the 3 topics:
a) accuracy
b) humour
c) who's more iconic
a) Accuracy
Ana is more accurate than Sadie, she tells the story straight, whereas Sadie tends to fight with her brother or make other remarks.
b) Humour
There is a right answer! Sadie, of course. Her accent (that she sadly starts to lose in books 2 and 3) gives her a distinct voice and her sarcasm makes her chapters far better than her older brother's. [Sorry, Carter]
c) Who is more iconic?
Sorry, Ana, while you are a queen for becoming a captain and fighting those evil ships and all that, you were quite bland. Sadie takes the crown once more.
Who's the best narrator?
Sadie wins the girl round! From both an objective and a subjective perspective as she makes the story more interesting. And I'm an Adele fan.
Since Carter won the objective round 1 and Sadie won the objective round 2, we shall soon meet during round 3 with a fight between the siblings and we will see who is the best narrator overall.