The Next Best Book Club discussion
Afghan Whigs 2025 Challenge
>
Supermod's Afghan Whigs Reading Challenge
Big Top Halloween (1988)
“Here Comes Jesus” – Read a book that features religionFather Gaetano's Puppet Catechism: A Novella by by Mike Mignola
“In My Town” – Read a book that takes place in your hometown/state, or is written by an author from thereWhen the Wolf Comes Home by Nat Cassidy
“Priscilla’s Wedding” – Read a book that features a female protagonistMy Husband
“Push” – Read a book that you had to push yourself to finish (and probably should have DNFd but didn’t)Grasshands by Kyle Winkler
“Scream” – Read a book that scares the beejezus out of you
“But Listen” – Read a book that you know you’ll never stop talking aboutThe Seas by Samantha Hunt
“Big Top Halloween” – Read a Halloween themed booksSister Funtime by Spencer Hamilton
“Life in a Day” – Read a book cover to cover in one day and take credit for it hereRing Shout by P. Djèlí Clark
“Sammy” – Read a book that features someone’s name in the titleJulia by Sandra Newman
“Doughball” – Read a book that prominently features foodThe Lamb by Lucy Rose
“Back o’ the Line” – Read the book that’s been sitting in your TBR the longestGod Jr. by Dennis Cooper
“Greek is Extra” – Read a book written by an author from a different nationality/culture than youA Carnival of Atrocities by Natalia García Freire
Up In It (1990)
“Retarded” – Read a book that is highly offensive and/or features very dated and inappropriate themes in today’s cultureBlood on Her Tongue by Johanna van Veen
“White Trash Party” – Read a trashy novel
“Hated” – Read a book and if you absolutely hated it, take credit for it hereWe Who Hunt Alexanders by Jason Sanford
“Southpaw” – Read a book that’s a little off kilter or left of centerThe Repeat Room by Jesse Ball
“Amphetamines and Coffee” – Read a book that features addiction
“Now We Can Begin” – Read the first book in a series and take credit for it hereAnnihilation by Jeff VanderMeer
“You My Flower” - Read a book with flowers on the coverThe Garden by Nick Newman
“Son of the South” – Read a book that is set in southern stateAbsolution by Jeff VanderMeer
“I Know Your Little Secret” – Read a book you’d consider a guilty pleasureHow to Survive a Horror Story by Mallory Arnold
“I Am the Sticks” – Get cozy with a seasonal readThis Cruise Sucks by Nico Bell
Congregation (1992) COMPLETE!!!
“Her Against Me” – Read a thrillerHow to Survive a Horror Story by Mallory Arnold
“I’m Her Slave” – Read a book written by a female author or an author who identifies as femaleBeta Vulgaris by Margie Sarsfield
“Turn on the Water” – Read a cli-fi bookMigrations by Charlotte McConaghy
“Conjure Me” – Read a book that features ghosts/spiritsRose of Jericho by Alex Grecian
“Kiss the Floor” – Read a book with romance elementsThis Cruise Sucks by Nico Bell
“Congregation” – Let yourself be influenced by the masses, read a book that’s heavily featured on Bookstagram or TikTokThe Staircase in the Woods by Chuck Wendig
“This is My Confession” – Read an autobiography or an auto-fiction titleFrom the Wreck by Jane Rawson
“Dedicate it” – Read a chunkster, a book with 400+ pagesRed Rabbit by Alex Grecian
“The Temple” – Free space, read anything you want and take credit for it hereThe Rotting Room
by Viggy Parr Hampton
“Let Me Lie to You” – Read a book with a twist you did not see comingMy Husband
“Tonight” – Read a book in one sittingAll Systems Red by Martha Wells
“Miles Iz Ded” – Read a book that features made up language or unique vernacularJulia by Sandra Newman
“Scream” – Read a book that scares the beejezus out of you
Up In It (1990)
“White Trash Party” – Read a trashy novel
“Amphetamines and Coffee” – Read a book that features addiction
Congregation (1992) COMPLETE!!!
by Viggy Parr Hampton
Gentlemen (1993)
“If I Were Going” – Read a book while on a road trip/vacationFather Gaetano's Puppet Catechism: A Novella by by Mike Mignola
“Gentlemen” – If you read a book that you are absolutely obsessed over, take credit hereAmerican Mythology by Giano Cromley
“Be Sweet” – Read a book that’s lighthearted and cutesyThe Autumn Springs Retirement Home Massacre by Philip Fracassi
“Debonair” – Read a book that made you feel fancyFigures Crossing the Field Towards the Group by Rebecca Gransden
“When We Two Parted” – Read a book that you never wanted to endToo Old for This by Samantha Downing
“Fountain and Fairfax” – Read a book that focuses on place and landscapeAcceptance by Jeff VanderMeer
“What Jail is Like” – Read a book that kept you captive the entire timeWhite Line Fever by K.C. Jones
“My Curse” – If you read a book that everyone else loved but you didn’t, take credit for it hereGrasshands by Kyle Winkler
“Now You Know” – Read a new-to-you genre
“I Keep Coming Back” – If you re-read a book, take credit for it hereAuthority by Jeff VanderMeer
“Brother Woodrow/Closing Prayer” – Save this spot for the last book you read this year!
Black Love (1996)
“Crime Scene Part One” – Read a true crime book or crime novel
“My Enemy” – Give ‘em another chance, read a book by an author you read previously but didn’t likeThe Burial Tide by Neil Sharpson
“Double Day” – Free space, read anything you want and take credit for it hereI Cheerfully Refuse by Leif Enger
“Blame, etc” – Finally read that book you keep meaning to read but have been putting offIncidents Around the House by Josh Malerman
“Step Into the Light” – Read a book that won an awardThe Emissary by Yōko Tawada
“Going to Town” – Go buy a book, read it immediately, and take credit for it hereThe Lamb by Lucy Rose
“Honky’s Ladder” – Read a book with a wildly inappropriate or misleading titleWe Are Always Tender With Our Dead by Eric LaRocca
“Night by Candlelight” – Read a historical fiction bookRing Shout by P. Djèlí Clark
“Bulletproof” – Read a book with a lot of actionThe Wolf Wants Answers by Joshua Mohr
“Summer’s Kiss” – Read a book set in the summertime, or a book that could be considered a beach readThe Sofa by Sam Munson
“Faded” – Read a used book (the more beat up the better)The Repeat Room by Jesse Ball
1965 (1998) COMPLETED!!!!
“Somethin’ Hot” – Read a book that’s got sizzlin’ spicy romance in itVampires at Sea by Lindsay Merbaum
“Crazy” – Read a bizarro or weird fiction bookPerson by Sam Pink
“Uptown Again” – Read a book that’s set in a big cityOne Yellow Eye by Leigh Radford
“Sweet Son of a Bitch” – If you read a book and gave it 5 stars, take credit for it hereThe Antidote by Karen Russell
“66” – Read a book that features an elderly protagonistThe Garden by Nick Newman
“Citi Soleil” – Read a book that’s translated from another languageThe Country Will Bring Us No Peace by Matthieu Simard
“John the Baptist” – Read a book that features a character with a different or unique job/careerBeta Vulgaris by Margie Sarsfield
“The Slide Song” – Slide out of that book you’ve been struggling to read, go on, DNF it and take credit for it hereFlashlight by Susan Choi
“Neglekted” – Read a book that’s been on your TBR for over a yearFather of Lies by Brian Evenson
“Omerta” – Read a book set in a made-up placeThe Cut by C.J. Dotson
“The Vampire Lanois” – Read a book that features vampires or other creatures of the nightBlood on Her Tongue by Johanna van Veen
“Now You Know” – Read a new-to-you genre
“Brother Woodrow/Closing Prayer” – Save this spot for the last book you read this year!
Black Love (1996)
“Crime Scene Part One” – Read a true crime book or crime novel
1965 (1998) COMPLETED!!!!
Do to the Beast (2014) COMPLETED!!!!
“Parked Outside” – Read a book in which the main character is on the run from somethingWhen the Wolf Comes Home by Nat Cassidy
“Matamoros” – Read a book set in another country
Eat the Ones You Love
“It Kills” – Read a book that features a slasher or a lot of goreStrangers by David Moody
“Algiers” – Read a book written by an author of a different nationality than youThe Haunting of Room 904 by Erika T. Wurth
“Lost in the Woods” – Read a book that takes place in or around the woodsListen to Your Sister by Neena Viel
“The Lottery” – Read a book that was gifted to youThe Glass Garden
“Can Rova” – Free space, if there are no prompts that fit the book just you read, take credit for it hereDark Matter: A Ghost Story by Michelle Paver
“Royal Cream” – Read a book that features foodThe Starving Saints by Caitlin Starling
“I Am Fire” – Read a book with a red coverThe Burial Tide by Neil Sharpson
“These Sticks” – Read Appalachian fiction or a book that takes place in the Fall The Autumn Springs Retirement Home Massacre by Philip Fracassi
In Spades (2017)
“Birdland” – Read a book with a bird on the cover or that features birdsThe Country Will Bring Us No Peace by Matthieu Simard
“Arabian Heights” – Read a book that’s considered a classic
“Demon in Profile” – Read a book that features demons or possessionThe Sofa by Sam Munson
“Toy Automatic” – Read a YA bookBones & All by Camille DeAngelis
“Oriole” – Read a book with a red coverCoffin Moon by Keith Rosson
“Copernicus” – Read a book that takes place in outer spaceAll Systems Red by Martha Wells
“The Spell” – Read a book that features witches or the occultThe Antidote by Karen Russell
“Light as a Feather” – Read a book that is less than 100 pages longPerson by Sam Pink
“I Got Lost” – Read a book that confused the heck out of youA Carnival of Atrocities by Natalia García Freire
“Into the Floor” – Read a book that’s just totally trippyI Gave You Eyes and You Looked Toward Darkness by Irene Solà
How Do You Burn (2022)
“I’ll Make You See God” – Read a book that prominently features death or griefRose of Jericho by Alex Grecian
“The Getaway” – Go hide from everyone and read a book, then take credit for it hereGliff by Ali Smith
“Catch a Colt” – Read a western, or a book that features horses/cowboysRed Rabbit by Alex Grecian
“Jyja” – Read a book with one word in the titleAcceptance by Jeff VanderMeer
“Please, Baby, Please” – Read your most anticipated book of the year and take credit for it herePlaying Wolf by Zuzana Říhová
“A Line of Shots” – Read a book that’s set in a bar/features a lot of drinkingWeepers by Peter Mendelsund
“Domino and Jimmy” – Read a book about BFFsWhite Line Fever by K.C. Jones
“Take Me There” – Read a book that features a place or thing that you’ve visited or experienced
“Concealer” – Read a book that turned out to be something different than you had expectedListen to Your Sister by Neena Viel
“In Flames” – Read a book that really pissed you offThe Cut by C.J. Dotson
In Spades (2017)
“Arabian Heights” – Read a book that’s considered a classic
How Do You Burn (2022)
“Take Me There” – Read a book that features a place or thing that you’ve visited or experienced
Book 1: My Husband
Big Top Halloween
“Priscilla’s Wedding” – Read a book that features a female protagonist
Congregation
“Let Me Lie to You” – Read a book with a twist you did not see coming
Big Top Halloween
“Priscilla’s Wedding” – Read a book that features a female protagonist
Congregation
“Let Me Lie to You” – Read a book with a twist you did not see coming
Book 2: Grasshands by Kyle Winkler
Big Top Halloween
“Push” – Read a book that you had to push yourself to finish (and probably should have DNFd but didn’t)
Gentlemen
“My Curse” – If you read a book that everyone else loved but you didn’t, take credit for it here
Big Top Halloween
“Push” – Read a book that you had to push yourself to finish (and probably should have DNFd but didn’t)
Gentlemen
“My Curse” – If you read a book that everyone else loved but you didn’t, take credit for it here
Book 3: The Country Will Bring Us No Peace by Matthieu Simard
1965
“Citi Soleil” – Read a book that’s translated from another language
In Spades
“Birdland” – Read a book with a bird on the cover or that features birds
1965
“Citi Soleil” – Read a book that’s translated from another language
In Spades
“Birdland” – Read a book with a bird on the cover or that features birds
Book 4: Father Gaetano's Puppet Catechism: A Novella by Mike Mignola
Big Top Halloween
“Here Comes Jesus” – Read a book that features religion
Gentlemen
“If I Were Going” – Read a book while on a road trip/vacation
Big Top Halloween
“Here Comes Jesus” – Read a book that features religion
Gentlemen
“If I Were Going” – Read a book while on a road trip/vacation
Book 5: Julia by Sandra Newman
Congregation
“Miles Iz Ded” – Read a book that features made up language or unique vernacular
Big Top Halloween
“Sammy” – Read a book that features someone’s name in the title
Congregation
“Miles Iz Ded” – Read a book that features made up language or unique vernacular
Big Top Halloween
“Sammy” – Read a book that features someone’s name in the title
Book 6: When the Wolf Comes Home by Nat Cassidy
Big Top Halloween
“In My Town” – Read a book that takes place in your hometown/state, or is written by an author from there
Do to the Beast
“Parked Outside” – Read a book in which the main character is on the run from something
Big Top Halloween
“In My Town” – Read a book that takes place in your hometown/state, or is written by an author from there
Do to the Beast
“Parked Outside” – Read a book in which the main character is on the run from something
Book 7: The Repeat Room by Jesse Ball
Up In It
“Southpaw” – Read a book that’s a little off kilter or left of center
Black Love
“Faded” – Read a used book (the more beat up the better)
Up In It
“Southpaw” – Read a book that’s a little off kilter or left of center
Black Love
“Faded” – Read a used book (the more beat up the better)
Book 8: Listen to Your Sister by Neena Viel
How Do You Burn
“Concealer” – Read a book that turned out to be something different than you had expected
Do The Beast
“Lost in the Woods” – Read a book that takes place in or around the woods
How Do You Burn
“Concealer” – Read a book that turned out to be something different than you had expected
Do The Beast
“Lost in the Woods” – Read a book that takes place in or around the woods
Book 9:Ring Shout by P. Djèlí Clark
Big Top Halloween
“Life in a Day” – Read a book cover to cover in one day and take credit for it here
Black Love
“Night by Candlelight” – Read a historical fiction book
Big Top Halloween
“Life in a Day” – Read a book cover to cover in one day and take credit for it here
Black Love
“Night by Candlelight” – Read a historical fiction book
Book 10: Beta Vulgaris by Margie Sarsfield
1965
“John the Baptist” – Read a book that features a character with a different or unique job/career
Congregation
“I’m Her Slave” – Read a book written by a female author or an author who identifies as female
1965
“John the Baptist” – Read a book that features a character with a different or unique job/career
Congregation
“I’m Her Slave” – Read a book written by a female author or an author who identifies as female
Book 11: The Garden by Nick Newman
Up In It
“You My Flower” - Read a book with flowers on the cover
1965
“66” – Read a book that features an elderly protagonist
Up In It
“You My Flower” - Read a book with flowers on the cover
1965
“66” – Read a book that features an elderly protagonist
Book 12: Red Rabbit by Alex Grecian
How Do You Burn
“Catch a Colt” – Read a western, or a book that features horses/cowboys
Congregation
“Dedicate it” – Read a chunkster, a book with 400+ pages
How Do You Burn
“Catch a Colt” – Read a western, or a book that features horses/cowboys
Congregation
“Dedicate it” – Read a chunkster, a book with 400+ pages
Book 13: The Antidote by Karen Russell
In Spades
“The Spell” – Read a book that features witches or the occult
1965
“Sweet Son of a Bitch” – If you read a book and gave it 5 stars, take credit for it here
In Spades
“The Spell” – Read a book that features witches or the occult
1965
“Sweet Son of a Bitch” – If you read a book and gave it 5 stars, take credit for it here
Book 14: The Lamb by Lucy Rose
Big Top Halloween
“Doughball” – Read a book that prominently features food
Black Love
“Going to Town” – Go buy a book, read it immediately, and take credit for it here
Big Top Halloween
“Doughball” – Read a book that prominently features food
Black Love
“Going to Town” – Go buy a book, read it immediately, and take credit for it here
Book 15: Rose of Jericho by Alex Grecian
Congregation
“Conjure Me” – Read a book that features ghosts/spirits
How Do You Burn
“I’ll Make You See God” – Read a book that prominently features death or grief
Congregation
“Conjure Me” – Read a book that features ghosts/spirits
How Do You Burn
“I’ll Make You See God” – Read a book that prominently features death or grief
Book 16: The Haunting of Room 904 by Erika T. Wurth
Do the Beast
“Algiers” – Read a book written by an author of a different nationality than you
Do the Beast
“Algiers” – Read a book written by an author of a different nationality than you
Book 17: White Line Fever by K.C. Jones
How Do You Burn
“Domino and Jimmy” – Read a book about BFFs
Gentleman
“What Jail is Like” – Read a book that kept you captive the entire time
How Do You Burn
“Domino and Jimmy” – Read a book about BFFs
Gentleman
“What Jail is Like” – Read a book that kept you captive the entire time
Book 18: Blood on Her Tongue by Johanna van Veen
Up In It
“Retarded” – Read a book that is highly offensive and/or features very dated and inappropriate themes in today’s culture
1965
“The Vampire Lanois” – Read a book that features vampires or other creatures of the night
Up In It
“Retarded” – Read a book that is highly offensive and/or features very dated and inappropriate themes in today’s culture
1965
“The Vampire Lanois” – Read a book that features vampires or other creatures of the night
Book 19:I Cheerfully Refuse by Leif Enger
Black Love
“Double Day” – Free space, read anything you want and take credit for it here
Black Love
“Double Day” – Free space, read anything you want and take credit for it here
Book 21:Annihilation by Jeff VanderMeer (audiobook) re-listen
Up In It
“Now We Can Begin” – Read the first book in a series and take credit for it here
Up In It
“Now We Can Begin” – Read the first book in a series and take credit for it here
Book 22: The Cut by C.J. Dotson
1965
“Omerta” – Read a book set in a made-up place
How Do You Burn
“In Flames” – Read a book that really pissed you off
1965
“Omerta” – Read a book set in a made-up place
How Do You Burn
“In Flames” – Read a book that really pissed you off
Book 23: Authorityby Jeff VanderMeer (Audiobook relisten)
Gentlemen
“I Keep Coming Back” – If you re-read a book, take credit for it here
Gentlemen
“I Keep Coming Back” – If you re-read a book, take credit for it here
Book 24: A Carnival of Atrocities by Natalia García Freire
Big Top Halloween
“Greek is Extra” – Read a book written by an author from a different nationality/culture than you
In Spades
“I Got Lost” – Read a book that confused the heck out of you
Big Top Halloween
“Greek is Extra” – Read a book written by an author from a different nationality/culture than you
In Spades
“I Got Lost” – Read a book that confused the heck out of you
Book 25: Acceptance by Jeff VanderMeer (audiobook relisten)
Gentlemen
“Fountain and Fairfax” – Read a book that focuses on place and landscape
How Do You Burn
“Jyja” – Read a book with one word in the title
Gentlemen
“Fountain and Fairfax” – Read a book that focuses on place and landscape
How Do You Burn
“Jyja” – Read a book with one word in the title
Book 27: All Systems Red by Martha Wells
Congregation
“Tonight” – Read a book in one sitting
In Spades
“Copernicus” – Read a book that takes place in outer space
Congregation
“Tonight” – Read a book in one sitting
In Spades
“Copernicus” – Read a book that takes place in outer space
Book 28: I Gave You Eyes and You Looked Toward Darkness by Irene Solà
In Spades
“Into the Floor” – Read a book that’s just totally trippy
In Spades
“Into the Floor” – Read a book that’s just totally trippy
Book 31: The Starving Saints by Caitlin Starling
Do To The Beast
“Royal Cream” – Read a book that features food
Do To The Beast
“Royal Cream” – Read a book that features food
Book 32:Weepers by Peter Mendelsund
How Do You Burn
“A Line of Shots” – Read a book that’s set in a bar/features a lot of drinking
How Do You Burn
“A Line of Shots” – Read a book that’s set in a bar/features a lot of drinking
Book 33: Strangers by David Moody
Do to the Beast
“It Kills” – Read a book that features a slasher or a lot of gore
Do to the Beast
“It Kills” – Read a book that features a slasher or a lot of gore
Book 34: Dark Matter: A Ghost Story by Michelle Paver
Do to the Beast
“Can Rova” – Free space, if there are no prompts that fit the book just you read, take credit for it here
Do to the Beast
“Can Rova” – Free space, if there are no prompts that fit the book just you read, take credit for it here
Book 35: The Rotting Room
by Viggy Parr Hampton
Congregation
“The Temple” – Free space, read anything you want and take credit for it here
by Viggy Parr Hampton
Congregation
“The Temple” – Free space, read anything you want and take credit for it here
Book 36: We Who Hunt Alexanders by Jason Sanford
Up In It
“Hated” – Read a book and if you absolutely hated it, take credit for it here
Up In It
“Hated” – Read a book and if you absolutely hated it, take credit for it here
Book 37: Father of Lies by Brian Evenson
1965
“Neglekted” – Read a book that’s been on your TBR for over a year
1965
“Neglekted” – Read a book that’s been on your TBR for over a year
Book 38: Absolution by Jeff VanderMeer (Audiobook)
Up In It
“Son of the South” – Read a book that is set in southern state
Up In It
“Son of the South” – Read a book that is set in southern state
Book 41: God Jr. by Dennis Cooper
Big Top Halloween
“Back o’ the Line” – Read the book that’s been sitting in your TBR the longest
Big Top Halloween
“Back o’ the Line” – Read the book that’s been sitting in your TBR the longest
Book 42: Person by Sam Pink
1965
“Crazy” – Read a bizarro or weird fiction book
In Spades
“Light as a Feather” – Read a book that is less than 100 pages long
1965
“Crazy” – Read a bizarro or weird fiction book
In Spades
“Light as a Feather” – Read a book that is less than 100 pages long
Book 43: Gliff by Ali Smith
How Do You Burn
“The Getaway” – Go hide from everyone and read a book, then take credit for it here
How Do You Burn
“The Getaway” – Go hide from everyone and read a book, then take credit for it here
Book 44: The Staircase in the Woods by Chuck Wendig
Congregation
“Congregation” – Let yourself be influenced by the masses, read a book that’s heavily featured on Bookstagram or TikTok
Book 45: A Short Stay in Hell by Steven L. Peck
Congregation
“Congregation” – Let yourself be influenced by the masses, read a book that’s heavily featured on Bookstagram or TikTok
Book 45: A Short Stay in Hell by Steven L. Peck
Book 46: The Sofa by Sam Munson
Black Love
“Summer’s Kiss” – Read a book set in the summertime, or a book that could be considered a beach read
In Spades
“Demon in Profile” – Read a book that features demons or possession
Black Love
“Summer’s Kiss” – Read a book set in the summertime, or a book that could be considered a beach read
In Spades
“Demon in Profile” – Read a book that features demons or possession
I'm going to continue to limit myself to two tasks per book.