Percy Jackson Book Club discussion

31 views
Book Series > Rank the 12 Main Olympians based off the books

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Noah (new)

Noah B. | 88 comments 1. Hermes he tried so hard with Luke and his mom
2.Artemis nice to demigods
3. Dionysus funny and I like his kind of bond with Percy
4. Poseidon tried his best as a dad
5. Apollo helped Percy (Haven’t gotten to TOA
6. Aphrodite cursed Annabeth and Percy
7. Hades bad dude and kidnapped Persephone
8.Hera scolds Percy I’m pretty sure also jealous over everyone
9. Zeus talk about hypocrite
10. Hephaestus don’t know
11.Hestia Don’t know
12.Demeter Don’t know
What do you guys think?


inge:) (hiatus, sometimes active) | 218 comments Demeter is fine tbh
Meg is her child, and I like her, so I’ll accept Demeter


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

They're super stereotypical and badly written in the books, but rank them BASED OFF the books? Sure:
12. Zeus. Need I explain?
11. Apollo. I HATED THIS GUY SO MUCH. Hands down the most annoying character I've ever read, I dnfed the second book of ToA because I hated him so much
10. Aphrodite. This is mostly from Greek Heroes, I HATED her in that book, I also just don't like her attitude in the series(s)
9. Ares. Mars is a different story, he was decent(ish), but Ares is awful. In SoM he yelled at Clarisse for nothing and he basically just had not a very big reason to even be there in the first place
8. Athena. She was just so disengaged to all of her children and that whole scene in MoA when she gave Annabeth the coin was just super weird and messed up (I know she was confused between her Greek and Roman selves but it was super sad and weird)
7. Demeter. Putting her right in the middle because I don't even remember her doing anything except telling Percy and Nico to eat cereal
6. Poseidon. He didn't do much except show up and try to be Percy's dad in the last chapter of every book, did he?
5. Hermes. He helped Percy and Annabeth a lot in SoM but of course you can't ignore the whole Luke thing
4. Dionysus. He actually cared about the campers even if he tried really hard to project the opposite
3. Hera. Her plan in HoO actually worked, she's smarter than people credit her for, and I honestly don't get why Annabeth hates her soooo much in the first series
2. Artemis. HELD THE FREAKING SKY so a young maiden didn't have to! And seconds after being released helped fight for/with the demigods
Which leaves....
1 Hephaestus! The dude is literally just so wholesome, he's actually trying with his children, he just has really bad social skills. I just remember him generally being a really nice guy. I also think he helped Percy and Annabeth in BotL though it may not have been a big deal


lowri (gcse hiatus) (laddamswilliamsgmailcom) | 393 comments only on mark of Athena so this is probs gonna change!

12) Hera (no explanation needed)
11) Zeus. I don't need to explain this one either
10) Ares. big headed and somehow has a bigger ego that Zeus
9) Aphrodite. kinda helpful I guess...
8) Athena. she expects all her children to live up to her expectations (but she's also my godly parent so I may be biased)
7) Hermes. I think he is one of the more human like gods, he genuinely cares for his kids (like he cared for Luke in his own weird way)
6) Apollo. ego bigger than the whole ass sun, but made me laugh so hard. love the bond between him and Artemis sm.
5) Poseidon. he's pretty chill (and he's Percys dad so you can't complain)
4) Artemis. cares so much about her huntersand other demigods.
3) Dionysus. so funny! love his bond with Peter Johnson<3
2) Hephaestus. SO FREAKING WHOLESOME. HE HAS SO TRAUMA AND I JUST WANT TO GIVE HIM A HUG. HES SUCH A GOOD DAD.
1) Demeter. ICONIC. MADE ME LAUGH SO HARD WITH THE CEREAL SCENE.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

oooh fun! ill do this when i get home from school


message 6: by ray ౨ৎ, Head Camp Director/Mod (new)

ray ౨ৎ | 1006 comments Mod
Ranking of Gods
1. Artemis- she actually cared for the demigods and hunters, like giving Annabeth her blessing to hold up the sky.
2. Hestia- The Last Olympian, and one of the only helpful goddesses in Percy’s life.
3. Poseidon- at least he tries with Percy 🤷🏻‍♀️
4. Hermes- I wanted to cry at school when it went to him and Luke’s relationship. Also, he took the couple to Paris, so I gotta give him extra points for that.
5. Hephaestus- first of all, I spelled his name right !! That’s a huge accomplishment for me anyways. He’s helpful enough, so.
6. Dionysus- didn’t really help at CHB, but he had his moments.
7. Apollo- TOA was funny only bc of Apollo, who is disgusted my his new acne and flab, and calls humans meat sacks. He did learn his lesson, but would probably forget it after 100 years, and maybe even less.
8. Aphrodite- she sometimes cared. I mean, she did gossip a lot with Piper (ofc tho, Pipes didn’t like it).
9. Athena- she overworked her kids so hard, and even sent them to find the Mark of Athena even tho many have failed for years. And, most of her kids have emotional damage and probably listen to This is Me Trying, Mirrorball, Mastermind, and Are You Satisfied? on repeat (at least I do…)
10. Ares- he expects to much out of them. Frank, Clarisse. Yeah, reading the Stolen Chariot and Sea of Monsters prove how Ares children are doing anything to get their father’s attention.
11. Hera- 🐄 🐮 (ifykyk, sry Annabeth)
12. Zeus- naw because quests for him to go to college? You’re done. You’re done.


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

ranking<33

1. Demeter , as lowri said first - an absolute icon.
2. Hermes , in case you couldn't tell from my Hermes deep dive... he's actually an alright Olympian
3. Hestia, she's chill
4. Artemis, I love how she welcomes young girls with open arms and help demigods
5. Poseidon , he's okay... I guess??? He helps sometimes.
6.Apollo, I haven't read ToA yet, but he seems okay so far.
7. Aphrodite, she's a Percabeth shipper, so I'll give her that
8. Dionysus, he cared for his own kids, sometimes even the other demigods, still won't remember their names
9. Ares , "idk, it's the vibes, man" (a random quote I found on a Renegades tumblr post that I always quote)
10. Athena , for someone who barely interacts with her kids and gifts random people who she thought were smart babies, she expects too much from her kids.
11. Hera , need I say more?
12. Zeus , again, need I say more?


message 8: by Jessie (new)

Jessie | 69 comments Kind of off topic, but did you guys know that Hades is not considered an Olympian because he lives in the Underworld instead of Mt Olympus. (Ngl being PJ fans you probably know that but the number of ppl I know irl that don’t know that fact is crazyyyyyy).


message 9: by [deleted user] (new)

Jessie wrote: "Kind of off topic, but did you guys know that Hades is not considered an Olympian because he lives in the Underworld instead of Mt Olympus. (Ngl being PJ fans you probably know that but the number ..."

Yeah, I'm noticing everyone saying Hestia, lol, it says the main 12


inge:) (hiatus, sometimes active) | 218 comments I was going to do this yesterday, but my mom yelled at me to go shower, so I’m doing it after school today:3


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

if we ranked hades hed be at 1


message 12: by VioletCabin7&9 (new)

VioletCabin7&9 | 26 comments 1 PAN! I know he is not a real Olympian God but he deserves to be🌳
2 Artemis, she is a legend and genuinely cares for demigods🏹
3 Hermes, Tried his best with Luke and loves his children.🐍
4 Hephaestus, cares about his children in his introverted way🔥
5. Apollo, I’ve finished book 3 TOA and so far he cares about his children and is becoming less self centred🎶☀️⚕️
6 Demeter, she cares for demigods and her children🪴
7 Poseidon, made an effort with Percy🌊
8 Dionysus, definitely cares for the campers but doesn’t show it🍇
9 Athena, visits her children from time to time and watches over them🏛️
10 Hera, Was right about the seven👑
11 Aphrodite, to be honest I just didn’t know where to put her😂💚
12 Ares, terrible father and so mean. Mars is better than Ares though🐗
13 Zues, he’s the worst do I need to justify this decision⚡️


message 13: by Jessie (new)

Jessie | 69 comments @Steffy Yessss Nico’s dad is awesome


message 14: by ray ౨ৎ, Head Camp Director/Mod (new)

ray ౨ৎ | 1006 comments Mod
Hades is great


Autistic Beanbag  (dexdizzneethebeanbag) | 30 comments [WORST TO BEST]
1. Zeus... just...Zeus
2. Hera - she just ripped Percy and Jason out of their lives and erased their memories!
3. Ares - idk I just feel like here's where to put him
4. Aphrodite - solely based on the fact I just re-read the Titans Curse, i mean she literally told Percy she was making his life harder
5. Athena - I mean she's not a good mother and she puts high expectations on Annabeth but she's not the worst
6. Demeter - she really doesn't do much in the main books and I'm not counting Greek Gods in this list
7. Dionysus - He cares about the campers more than he lets on but...peter johnson...
8. Apollo - not the best at first but he's good by the end of ToA
9. Hermes - He actually tries.
10. Hephestus - Good(ish) father and doesn't do much bad stuff
11. Poseidon - great father in comparison
12. Artemis - Just amazing best god(ess) ever


message 16: by Annabelle (new)

Annabelle (Ani) | 67 comments 1: Artemis, she is just amazing. Need I say more?
2: Apollo, okay this might be a hot take but, I just found Apollo hilarious in Titan's Curse- he wasn't disrespectful to the demigods, and I feel like he actually cares about his children. (Mind you I haven't read ToA yet so correct me if I'm wrong)
3: Athena, sure she was absent in Annabeth's life for a long time, but so were most godly parents.
4: Aphrodite, she helped Piper when, Piper needed her. Also claimed Piper right when she knew it would help, thank you Aphrodite for siding with Piper over Drew
5: Poseidon, a good parent, but... but... Medusa
6: Hermes, he really tried with Luke. I respect him for that, he did his best, and really cared about Luke and Luke's mom.
7:Hephaestus, seemed to be a good dad from what we saw from, Leo. He cared about his kids even if he couldn't seem to do anything.
8: Demeter, I haven't seen Demeter in any of the books yet so U can't give a fair rating but I'm just gonna add her here
9:Dionysus, he was disrespectful towards the campers, but also hilarious and cared when one of his kids died, so bonus points.
10: *deep sigh* Ares, little war rat, I hope you get stuck in Tartarus
11: Hera, YOU RAT GIVE PERCY AND JASONS MEMORIES BACK! (I know she does but she just annoys me) and the way she treated Annabeth 😤
12: Zeus. (Throws up)


message 17: by Annabelle (new)

Annabelle (Ani) | 67 comments @stefania
YESS


message 18: by ray ౨ৎ, Head Camp Director/Mod (new)

ray ౨ৎ | 1006 comments Mod
@ani yeah, I thought he was great in Titan’s Curse but in ToA he called humans “meat sacks” and was well….

And he did learn his lesson but let’s be fr: he’s gonna forget it in 100 years and be rude again. That was nothing but a page of his life since he’s immortal


message 19: by Annabelle (new)

Annabelle (Ani) | 67 comments Wait have met Demeter before but only in the underworld with cereal-


char &#x1f383;‼️ (in my halloween era) | 157 comments 12) HERA need i explain
11) ZEUS again need i explain
10) ARES i just hate him so much
9) HERMES he’s a horrible dad and didn’t do anything for his kids
8) DIONYSUS he’s a jerk but he’s so hilarious like one of my fave characters but NOT my fave god
7) APOLLO he just has a huge ego and gets on my nerves, but i’m still a proud daughter of apollo 😃
6) APHRODITE i just felt like she could’ve FIXED HER ATTITUDE
5) DEMETER i had no reason to hate her but no reason to love her either
4) ARTEMIS i love her girl power fr
3) POSEIDON he was so funny and literally such a proud dad he was amazing.
2) HEPHEASTUS he was so wholesome and loved all his children equally he’s so bbg

AND FINALLY

1) HADES.
he is so bbg and literally so funny and the best dad and husband and he is so amazing and omg i’ll trade him for apollo fr


back to top