Thoughtful (Thoughtless, #4) Thoughtful discussion


84 views
Kellan.....

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Morgan Does Kellan just seem too whiny in this book for anyone else? I mean I know that Keira is horrible and puts him through waaaaay too much. But does anyone else feel that this book just took away from his character that was built in Thoughtless? Excuse me, but he just acts like a huge p***y. The author did do a good job, but at the same time I feel like it's too much. I wanted the male side of this, not what women want a male to sound like. Even damaged, I highly doubt this retelling.


Erika He was very whiny. I don't hate Kiera, I'm one of the few, but this book was so long because of all his internal dialogue. I think I would been fine with how long it was if it went on to include Reckless as well. I know I had an expectation of Kellan being more manly than he was portrayed in this book. I still love the story of Kellan and Kiera.


Cindy I still love this series as well. The author is coming out with a book with Anna and Griffin.


Peggy The only reason I read this book was for Kellan. And he ruined it for me. Could she have written a bigger Pu$$y? I doubt it. I finished this book thinking, WOW! What a wimp. Done. Next!


Michelle °O° Erika I was one of the few that didn't hate her either but after reading this book I can see why people did.

Yes I kind of wish in a way I never read this book. I felt dirty reading his thoughts sometimes. He was so obsessed with Kiera it borderlined on creepy.


message 7: by *P (new) - rated it 4 stars

*P In my review I wrote, "I really thought of Kellan as this cocky bad ass gonna be rock star in the first book. His bad boy nature was appealing and after reading this book he just came across as more of a love sick, pathetic puppy." It was great to see others have felt the way I did. Even though I still love Kellan I definitely was better off not knowing all his inner thoughts.


Martha Morgan wrote: "Does Kellan just seem too whiny in this book for anyone else? I mean I know that Keira is horrible and puts him through waaaaay too much. But does anyone else feel that this book just took away fro..."

I agree with you 100%. His pity party was too much for me, and it was so repetative. I still love Kellan and the Thoughtless series will always be one of my faves, but this one was way too much whining.


Angela Roosa I wish I would not have read this book. It didn't really add anything to the original books.


Martha Angela wrote: "I wish I would not have read this book. It didn't really add anything to the original books."

Me too, I hated giving it 3 stars, but like I said Kellan's whining was just too much, and it was always the same thing over and over again.


message 11: by Beth (new) - rated it 5 stars

Beth I felt like she wrote the book in her personality of a girl rather than actually from kellan, a bad boy rocker. It seemed really whiny and at some points really tediuous.


message 12: by Angelina (last edited May 09, 2015 04:29PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Angelina Ruined kellan for me he was such a bitch in this book... so mad wish i didnt read it


Crystal Very whiny. I am about 44% into the book and want to just stop. Totally ruined Kellan.


back to top