⋆.ೃ࿔࿐ྂfaith & fantasy⋆.ೃ࿔࿐ྂ discussion
✯Games✯
>
⭒Elimination Game [Feat. Shadow & Bone Grishaverse Trilogy]⭒ (Completed)
message 51:
by
Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒
(new)
Apr 04, 2024 01:34PM
Mod
reply
|
flag
Alina - 20Baghra - 10
David - 26
Genya - 22
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 40*
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 44*
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 18
Alina - 20Baghra - 8*
David - 26
Genya - 22
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 40
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 46*
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 18
Team Nikolai is growing.
Alina - 20
Baghra - 8
David - 26
Genya - 22
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 42*
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 46
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 16*
Baghra - 8
David - 26
Genya - 22
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 42*
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 46
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 16*
Alina - 20Baghra - 6*
David - 26
Genya - 24*
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 42
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 46
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 16
Alina - 20Baghra - 6
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 44*
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 46
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14*
@Bella I loved Nikolai too, but Mal...🤩😝
Alina - 20Baghra - 4*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 44
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 48*
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
Contrary to popular belief, there is nothing wrong with Mal, but Nikolai is superior. ;) I really do like Mal too, though.
Alina - 20Baghra - 2*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 46*
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 48
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
I agree to disagree:) As long as you're not out to get him 😁
Alina - 20Baghra - 0*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 46
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 48
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 16*
Sorry, Baghra, but you have to go.
@Catherine--Yeah, disagreement is fine, as long as YOU don't go after Nikolai. :)
Alina - 18*David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 48*
Marie - 18
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 48
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 16
Wait, you like Zoya? I have a faint memory of her being exceedingly annoying...did she change at the end? I forgot...
Alina - 18David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 48
Marie - 16*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 50*
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 16
About Zoya, she was annoying at first, although by the end of the trilogy she wasn't so much. Still not the best, though. But then there's KoS... I really liked her in that duology.
Alina - 18David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 50*
Marie - 16
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 50
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20*
Zoya - 16
Ohh OK. I haven't read KoS yet, but I hope to eventually:))
Alina - 18David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 50
Marie - 16
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 52*
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 14*
Alina - 20*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 50
Marie - 16
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 52
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12*
I am not a Zoya fan, even though I have read beyond S&B. And while I will not argue that Nikolai deserves his place in the winners' circle, I think Mal was more noble in his treatment of Alina. I did not appreciate how Nikolai used her.
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 50
Marie - 16
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 52
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12*
I am not a Zoya fan, even though I have read beyond S&B. And while I will not argue that Nikolai deserves his place in the winners' circle, I think Mal was more noble in his treatment of Alina. I did not appreciate how Nikolai used her.
@Catherine, people hate on Mal because they see him as oppressive. Instead of seeing him the way Bardugo presents him, they read between the lines and see something that isn't there: him holding her back from her true potential. In actuality, he sees what is happening to her, and knows it isn't good. He tries to get her to see, and instead of people appreciating him for his self-sacrificial decisions, they malign him for not letting her go without a fight.
Personally, I don't like Mal, but that's because I saw him as slightly annoying (especially in book 3), and with the show, I only saw him as "nice" and nothing more.
Alina - 20David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 50
Marie - 14*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 52
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 14*
@Catherine-- KoS is really good, but a certain character's chapters made me super angry. Still a great series, though.
@Sharon-- I do get what you're saying about Nikolai, but the thing is, there was never really love on either side. And she kind of wanted to use him to try and forget Mal, remember? He did annoy me when he kissed her that one time, though. But he's great, so I can forgive him. ;)
Alina - 20
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52*
Marie - 14
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 52
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12*
Let's just face it--no one in these books are especially moral people!😅 We can like certain parts of them, but there are bound to be huge issues in almost all of them!
Bella, what character in KoS? I personally only liked Nikolai, but I especially disliked (view spoiler).
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52*
Marie - 14
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 52
Sergie - 20
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12*
Let's just face it--no one in these books are especially moral people!😅 We can like certain parts of them, but there are bound to be huge issues in almost all of them!
Bella, what character in KoS? I personally only liked Nikolai, but I especially disliked (view spoiler).
Alina - 20David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52
Marie - 14
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54*
Sergie - 18*
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12
Exactly. None of them are very moral, unfortunately.
As for the annoying chapters of KoS, those were (view spoiler)
Alina - 22*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52
Marie - 14
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 18
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 10*
Yep. That's why I don't read Bardugo anymore. She just kept making things less and less moral with each book.
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52
Marie - 14
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 18
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 10*
Yep. That's why I don't read Bardugo anymore. She just kept making things less and less moral with each book.
Alina - 22David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52
Marie - 12*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 18
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12*
Sad but true.
The plot of KoS was really interesting, though. (The following is a spoiler for people who don't want to know ships in KoS.) And I have to admit, I love (view spoiler) It's giving Helnik some serious competition for my fave Grishaverse ship.
Alina - 24*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52
Marie - 12
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 18
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 10*
I cannot remember the Hel part of Helnik. 🤔
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 20
Mal - 52
Marie - 12
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 18
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 10*
I cannot remember the Hel part of Helnik. 🤔
Alina - 24David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22*
Mal - 52
Marie - 12*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 18
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 10
It comes from Matthias HELvar aka one of my fave SoC characters, I don't care what anyone says. :)
You are just determined to get rid of Zoya, aren't you?
If you mean do I love Matthias and Nikolai, then the answer is yes, they're both great characters imo. If you're asking if they're a ship, the answer is no. That wouldn't make ANY sense as they literally never even met each other. Or did they? I've read a lot of books between CK and now. But anyway, no the nik comes from Zenik, as in Nina Zenik If you leave Zoya alone for a bit that would be appreciated. :)
Bella wrote: "If you mean do I love Matthias and Nikolai, then the answer is yes, they're both great characters imo. If you're asking if they're a ship, the answer is no. That wouldn't make ANY sense as they lit..."
Oh, 😅. Good. I am not sure if they met when Nikolai came to meet Kaz or not. Or was Matthias (view spoiler)? I liked Matthias--it was Nina I didn't like.
Oh, 😅. Good. I am not sure if they met when Nikolai came to meet Kaz or not. Or was Matthias (view spoiler)? I liked Matthias--it was Nina I didn't like.
Alina - 26*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 52
Marie - 12
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 16*
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 10
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 52
Marie - 12
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 16*
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 10
Alina - 26David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 52
Marie - 10*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 16
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12*
I don't think they met, but (view spoiler) Yeah, that would be a weird ship. I wonder if anyone DOES ship them... But Matthais is one of my faves, he's such a great character. :)
Alina - 28*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 52
Marie - 10
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 14*
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 52
Marie - 10
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 14*
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12
Alina - 28David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54*
Marie - 10
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 14
Tamar - 20*
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12
@Sharon Aww makes sense! Booo 👎👎👎 Thanks for explaining:)
@Bella Interesting- makes me really interested:))
Thanks for using spoiler tags y'all! Also, are there any characters y'all like besides Mal, Nikolai, and for now Zoya? I am shocked at how much I forgot, but I barely remember any of these characters.
Alina - 28David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 52
Marie - 8*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 14
Tamar - 22
Tolya - 22*
Zoya - 12
Catherine wrote: "Alina - 28
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54*
Marie - 10
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 14
Tamar - 20*
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12
@Sharon Aww makes sense! Booo 👎👎👎 Thanks for explaining:)
@..."
I like David, Genya (after she comes around!), Nikolai, Mal, and Alina. And I think Tolya--he was the boy twin, right?.
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54*
Marie - 10
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 14
Tamar - 20*
Tolya - 20
Zoya - 12
@Sharon Aww makes sense! Booo 👎👎👎 Thanks for explaining:)
@..."
I like David, Genya (after she comes around!), Nikolai, Mal, and Alina. And I think Tolya--he was the boy twin, right?.
Alina - 30*
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 8
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 12*
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 12
I think I combined Bella's and Catherine's correctly, then I did my own turn.
David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 8
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 12*
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 12
I think I combined Bella's and Catherine's correctly, then I did my own turn.
Alina - 30David - 26
Genya - 24
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 6*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 12
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14*
I personally don't like Mal from the books because it seemed like he ignored Alina until she became "beautiful" due to exercising her Grisha powers. Only once did she become powerful and had everyone noticing her did he finally notice her. Mal from the show though....that's a different story. ;)
Alina - 30David - 26
Genya - 26*
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 4*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 12
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
Sharon and Bella, good to know:) Thanks for fixing that Sharon! Cat, that's an interesting take. I don't remember the book well enough, but that would definitely change my opinion of Mal.
Cat wrote: "I personally don't like Mal from the books because it seemed like he ignored Alina until she became "beautiful" due to exercising her Grisha powers. Only once did she become powerful and had everyo..."
I can see that, but I think Bardugo did a good job of fleshing out their complicated relationship and helping us (me, anyway) understand why Mal took so long. (view spoiler) I liked him much more than any of the other options!🙃 He could have had better morals, but so could all of them.🤭
I can see that, but I think Bardugo did a good job of fleshing out their complicated relationship and helping us (me, anyway) understand why Mal took so long. (view spoiler) I liked him much more than any of the other options!🙃 He could have had better morals, but so could all of them.🤭
Alina - 32*
David - 26
Genya - 26
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 4
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 10*
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
David - 26
Genya - 26
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 4
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 10*
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
Alina - 32David - 26
Genya - 28*
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 2*
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 54
Sergie - 10
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
Alina - 32David - 26
Genya - 28
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 2
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 56*
Sergie - 8*
Tamar - 20
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
I shipped Malina to the end, but Nikolai was my favorite character.
Also, I forgot to mention Harshaw when we were talking about characters we like who are still on the list. He was a bit strange, and I wasn't sure about him at first, but, for some reason, I kind of like him. Not enough for him to make the final three though.
Alina - 32David - 26
Genya - 28
Harshaw - 22
Mal - 54
Marie - 2
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 56
Sergie - 8
Tamar - 18*
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 16*
Alina - 32David - 26
Genya - 28
Harshaw - 24*
Mal - 54
Marie - 2
Nadia - 18
Nikolai - 56
Sergie - 8
Tamar - 18
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14*
Alina - 32David - 28*
Genya - 28
Harshaw - 24
Mal - 54
Marie - 2
Nadia - 16*
Nikolai - 56
Sergie - 8
Tamar - 18
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
Alina - 34*
David - 28
Genya - 28
Harshaw - 24
Mal - 54
Marie - 0*
Nadia - 16
Nikolai - 56
Sergie - 8
Tamar - 18
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
David - 28
Genya - 28
Harshaw - 24
Mal - 54
Nadia - 16
Nikolai - 56
Sergie - 8
Tamar - 18
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14
Alina - 34David - 30*
Genya - 28
Harshaw - 24
Mal - 54
Nadia - 14*
Nikolai - 56
Sergie - 8
Tamar - 18
Tolya - 22
Zoya - 14


