Beta Reader Group discussion

43 views
Critique Partners and Swaps > Fantasy CP - plots / character arcs / worldbuilding

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Danielle (new)

Danielle Rose | 13 comments Hi there,

I have a couple of ideas for new books and am currently drawing up plot points and character arcs. I'm looking to take popular themes in fantasy (mainly gods and Fae) and subvert some tropes in order to snag an agent.

If you also have a basic outline or first draft and want to nail your plot points / character arcs / worldbuilding, please let me know!

I've been giving authors feedback on Critique Circle for a couple of years and am very polite / professional :)


message 2: by Al (new)

Al | 4 comments Hey, Danielle!

My name’s Allison, and I also write fantasy. Your idea of subverting popular tropes seems super cool and interesting and I’d love to hear about your ideas!

I’m also in the outlining stage on my current story and would greatly appreciate a critique partner to give feedback on plot holes and character arcs.

I’ve honestly never been a traditional beta reader before, but I worked as a nonfiction copy editor for a few years and I also worked as an editor for translated fiction (I gained a lot of patience from that haha).

Just lemme know if you’d like to team up to help each other out :)


message 3: by Jessi (new)

Jessi | 34 comments Hi Danielle,

I am so curious about your subversion of popular tropes!

I recently completed my first novel and am working on the draft/outline of my second which comes with some major character twists that have been circling in my head. It would be amazing to think through with partners.

Al, it'd be wonderful to work with you too!


message 4: by Danielle (new)

Danielle Rose | 13 comments Hi Allison and Jessi,

Thanks so much for reaching out. I'd love to work with you both on your outlines, my email is 1991drb@gmail.com if you'd like to get in touch.

Speak soon!


message 5: by Al (new)

Al | 4 comments Jessi, I’d also love to work with you! Maybe the three of us could form a group chat haha
My email is owllisonlove@gmail.com if you wanna get in touch! :)


message 6: by Jasmine (new)

Jasmine | 4 comments This sounds like so much fun! What I miss when writing is someone to discuss everything with (my husband is getting tired of it haha). It would be great to follow each others journeys, read and share thoughts. Did I understand what you wanted out of this right?
If you have room for one more I'm happy to join in on this!
I will say - I am new to this, but can be a picky reader. With that I want to add that I can be very flexible, adjusting feedback to whatever kind of criticism you're after ❤️


message 7: by Danielle (new)

Danielle Rose | 13 comments It would be useful to have a small community / writer's club as we'll all be able to see each other's viewpoints on the same books. I'm happy to do 1-1 with people or take part in a group partnership.

My old critique partner showed me a function of Google Docs where others can comment and 'make suggestions' to a text but can't copy or download it. Perhaps we could make a shared folder on Drive and drop our respective story ideas / outlines in there to be commented on?

Let me know :)


message 8: by Al (new)

Al | 4 comments The shared Google drive folder is a really good idea!! Does anyone have any ideas for where to start a group chat?


message 9: by Danielle (new)

Danielle Rose | 13 comments I'm having a look now. Discord looks good but might take some getting used to. WhatsApp is always a good choice as it has end-to-end encryption and most people already use it. Google Chat would fit well with a shared Google Drive folder, but lacks encryption. Most other platforms unfortunately cost money.

Anyone else have an idea?


message 10: by Jasmine (new)

Jasmine | 4 comments I prefer discord or whatsapp! :)
The google folder sounds like a great idea, as well as a writer's club where we can help each other out!


message 11: by Nikolow (last edited Feb 25, 2024 07:11AM) (new)

Nikolow | 70 comments Hello,

I would love to be part of a small writing circle, especially because we all seem to be at the drafting stage of our books. I am writing a Fantasy, plotting book 1.

So it would be my pleasure to join you - if all of you would have me.

I have already exchanged mails with Danielle on my story (saw her post on a different thread) and provided some feedback on her two book ideas, thus Danielle can also judge if I would be a worthy contribution to the forming writing circle, or not.


Mika Nikolow.


message 12: by Al (new)

Al | 4 comments I have WhatsApp as well! Maybe we can all email our numbers to Danielle and she can set up the group chat?
Also nice to meet you, Mika! The more the merrier, in my opinion :)


message 13: by Danielle (new)

Danielle Rose | 13 comments Hi Mika!

We'd love to have you in our group; I liked your story idea and appreciated your feedback.

I'm very happy to set up a WhatsApp group if everyone emails me their phone number. I'll also create a shared Google Drive folder and add your emails so we can start dropping documents in.

Just to let you know, I'm thinking of hiring a writing coach for 2-3 sessions to help me decide which story idea to pursue and plot a rough outline. In the meantime, I'll still share my initial ideas with you guys and give feedback on yours.

See you in WhatsApp!


back to top