Harry Potter discussion
Characters
>
If You Could Kill One More Character, Who and When Would it Be?
I think we all want Umbridge to die hahahHonestly, I think Lockhart got exactly what he deserved, ending up in Saint Mungo without memories and I think he's funny in a stupid way (maybe I've read too many fanfics)
I believe that though Lockhart was by no degree of imagination good, he did not deserve to die. Umbridge would be a good pick though, she is a danger to society.
Zaii wrote: "Honestly, I think Lockhart got exactly what he deserved, ending up in Saint Mungo without memories and I think he's funny in a stupid way (maybe I've read..."It was poetic justice; he wanted to remove the memories of other people, he was doomed to the same fate. Though I was disappointed they did not include that piece in the movies because it would have been a wonderful addition.
For me, most of the characters I thought deserved to die, did (Snape, Voldemort, etc.) but I will always stand by the fact I think Harry should have died. There are many reasons, but the primary two are simple: one, she made the "love protecting people" plothole worse and two, no matter how messed up he was, Voldemort still had 70ish years on Harry and could hold his own against Albus Dumbledore; even if you accept the horcruxes messed him up, that Harry was a container for one and "the container must be destroyed beyond repair" means he should not have made it out of the series. Period.
I probably answer this question a little too quickly. Umbridge is the absolute worst. I wouldn’t even think twice about it.
Meg wrote: "Zaii wrote: "Honestly, I think Lockhart got exactly what he deserved, ending up in Saint Mungo without memories and I think he's funny in a stupid way (maybe I've read..."It was poetic justice; h..."
Yeah, but it is a children's novel after all, that is supposed to leave you full of hope at the end. Sure, perhaps it would have made sense logically-wise for Frodo to have died while delivering the ring to Mordor, but narrative-wise, it wouldn't.
Umbridge. People who know of the series think that Voldemort is the evil one, but real fans know it’s her. I wouldn’t wish death upon her, but maybe a very miserable existence after the battle of Hogwarts. Like something involving giants. Or even just dirt. And no pink. 😈
I actually wouldn't kill Umbridge... 😊 I'd kill Ginny. It would've drove the story on more of a spin ((view spoiler))
Hear me out… Harry Potter! I want chaos and I want it now!!
Sophia wrote: "Hear me out… Harry Potter! I want chaos and I want it now!!"Same Sophia :))))
CC wrote: "Sophia wrote: "Hear me out… Harry Potter! I want chaos and I want it now!!"Same Sophia :))))"
What!
Umbridge- no comment, like, I think everyone agrees, and if you don't, I don't like you, like bro, who on this planet likes her???
Umbridge 100%, I want to smack my TV and burn the pages of my books whenever she pops up🤣
Delores Umbridge, Gilderoy Lockhart, Harry James Potter.
omg, dolores umbridge and lockhart
Umbridge and maybe Cho. I mean she was rude and snotty and didn’t really do anything to the storyline except for being Harry’s first crush. I hate umbridge to my GUTS.
Everyone: Umbridge, Filch, Cho, and Lucius! Me: What about Voldemort?
UMBRIDGE, not even ashamed of not being original
UMBRIDGE! As soon as I saw this on the front I knew exactly what I would put and that I would see her name a lot. She is so infuriating it's not even funny.
Hot take, but Cho. Should’ve been her instead of Cedric
Ermmm, Lucias Malfoy. He was never a good character, and Draco would have lost his father but harry potter lost his whole family soo.
Umbridge! Though Wormtail is a close second too.
Lucius Malfoy. He sucked 😤 And he was mean to Dobby!!!!! In my head, that’s illegal!! I feel like Cho should’ve died too, bc she was already so heartbroken over Cedric’s death, so she could just join him 😈
Umbridge, duh.
And Wormtail! He was sooo annoying
Ahahahaha! Dolphin would kill half the cast. 🤣
𝒯𝑜𝓇𝑜𝓃𝑜 wrote: "Everyone: Umbridge, Filch, Cho, and Lucius! Me: What about Voldemort?"
He did die
He did, yes. Perhaps Torono didn’t realize this wasn’t a question of who MOST needs to die, but who didn’t die that maybe should have?
controversial but Victor krum I don't like him
you guys won't like this but neville grandma in the 6th book it would have added so much yo the plot
I feel like Umbridge kind of deserved it, to be honest — she was just that awful. But at the same time, I think living as a disgraced, powerless bureaucrat might’ve actually been the better punishment
Victoria wrote: "Luffy Sempai: Hagrid? Really?"I like my beef casseroles without talons in it. I'm that fastidious.
One character I would kill would be Umbridge because she was a evil teacher, and she enjoyed hurting the students. I would kill her when Hermione and Harry leads her into the forest.
Another character I would kill is Gilderoy Lockhart. I would kill Lockhart because he took other people's credit for doing heroic things. He would take away the memory of those people too.
Feel free to put more than one character.