[Subdue] Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane - 4 Stars

[Diana]

This novel kept a thrilling pace throughout, a quality I thoroughly enjoyed. It kicked off with one type of problem but concluded with something entirely unexpected, leaving me with mixed feelings about the ending. The first half seemed to promise a certain direction, and while I found satisfaction in that trajectory, the twist left me pondering.

What truly stood out for me was the captivating writing style – a delightful blend of humor, sorrow, and intriguing, even instructive moments. The main character (view spoiler)[whose real name I'm still not sure about (hide spoiler)] was someone I found quite appealing (view spoiler)[even though it may sound creepy, considering the ending (hide spoiler)]. What set this book apart for me was the author's ability to craft a sinister atmosphere without relying on mystical elements. The tension stemmed purely from the vividly depicted situations, making it a standout read.

[Peacejanz]

Great review. I have read this book 3 or 4 times, discussed it in two different book groups and it is still one of my favorites. We have argued about the ending and that is one of the things that is wonderful about this book. Lehane is a great mystery writer - if you liked this, you will like some of his other books. Thanks for the review. peace, janz

[Diana]

Peacejanz wrote: "Great review. I have read this book 3 or 4 times, discussed it in two different book groups and it is still one of my favorites. We have argued about the ending and that is one of the things that i..."

Thank you, Janz. I'll have a look at some of his other books. Maybe you could recommend one?

[Peacejanz]

Mystic River stands out in my mind - somewhat like Shutter Island in that some things are rarely explained. But he always writes good books. You really can not miss. And If you liked this book with the mystery at the end, you might enjoy "In the Lake of the Woods" by Tim O'Brien. One of my favorite mystery books. Good reading. peace, janz

[Diana]

Peacejanz wrote: "Mystic River stands out in my mind - somewhat like Shutter Island in that some things are rarely explained. But he always writes good books. You really can not miss. And If you liked this book with..."

Thanks, Janz. I'll check them out

[Susan]

Nice review. I also like this author and I'll have to see if this one is available at the library.