The Catholic Book Club discussion

The Ear of the Heart: An Actress' Journey from Hollywood to Holy Vows
This topic is about The Ear of the Heart
30 views
Ear of the Heart - December 2023 > 4. Two vocations at the same time

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by CBC (new)

CBC Moderator 2 | 170 comments Mod
Dolores Hart had a vocation to be an actress and then discovered she also had a vocation to be a nun. Have you ever felt in the same (not necesasarily religious) situation?


message 2: by Jill (new)

Jill A. | 904 comments "Vocation" isn't the same as "career" or profession. One can have a vocation to marriage, committed celibacy and/or a particular lay or religious community--and hold many different jobs within that commitment.


Manuel Alfonseca | 2372 comments Mod
Jill wrote: ""Vocation" isn't the same as "career" or profession. One can have a vocation to marriage, committed celibacy and/or a particular lay or religious community--and hold many different jobs within that..."

Right. A career is not the same as a vocation.

To those vocations you have mentioned I'd add a few more. You can have a vocation to teach (which is not the same as being a teacher). Or a vocation to communicate.

In the case of Dolores Hart, I believe, from what I have read of this book (I've not finished yet) that she really had a vocation to be an actress, apart from any thoughts about her career (which she also had, of course). And then, when she discovered she had a religious vocation, she renounced her first vocation, because they were incompatible.

But you can have two vocations at the same time and they may not be incompatible: for instance, you may have a vocation to marriage and to teach.


message 4: by Fonch (new) - added it

Fonch | 2443 comments She made movies with Elvis Presley 😁.


Manuel Alfonseca | 2372 comments Mod
I have found this quote, that confirms what I said about Mother Hart having two vocations at the same time:

“Don’t cut it off,” he told me, “assume it. You are going to have to maintain absolutely in this Community that you are what you are—an actress.”
—That was something a Jesuit taught a Benedictine.



Manuel Alfonseca | 2372 comments Mod
Going again on the two vocations at the same time, I don't think anyone will deny that Don Bosco (the founder of the Salesians) had two vocations at the same time: a religious vocation, and a teaching vocation. Many other saints are in the same situation.


Manuel Alfonseca | 2372 comments Mod
I don't think it can be denied that Dolores Hart had two vocations at the same time. In the middle-last part of the book it's clear, when the two authors tell how she created a theater inside a cloistered monastery!


Steven R. McEvoy (srmcevoy) | 149 comments Manuel wrote: "I don't think it can be denied that Dolores Hart had two vocations at the same time. In the middle-last part of the book it's clear, when the two authors tell how she created a theater inside a clo..."

I agree.


back to top