Booktok 📚 discussion

308 views
Just Booktok Stuff > Read or Watch

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Alan (last edited Nov 12, 2023 10:21PM) (new)

Alan Hamid | 15 comments The state of the art, AI, has reached a point where it could turn a book into a movie, just as easily as the written books could become audio-books these days.
If you had a choice to whether watch or read your next book, which format would you choose?


message 2: by évieane (new)

évieane (evieane) | 153 comments I would definitely still choose reading. I love imagining the characters and the places myself and this freedom of imagination is what I always love the most about reading. So for me, I would still pick to read the next book.


message 3: by bookhugger (new)

bookhugger yeah me too, i'd choose reading any day


message 4: by Summer (new)

Summer | 196 comments I can't choose between them because it really depends on the quality bc majority of the time it's reading but franchises such as the Harry Potter franchise I feel are much better as movies but overall reading is on top


message 5: by ❃A.J❃ (new)

❃A.J❃  (bibliophagist) | 16 comments I would definitely choose reading. Also, I'm kind of anti AI


message 6: by Larissa (new)

Larissa | 90 comments Read first and then decide if I wanna watch the movie. I really do believe some books would translate better as a movie/show and the other way around.


Emms-hiatus(ish) | 109 comments Read, always.

I would never intentionally support an AI written book, an AI movie, or AI audiobook.


message 8: by Alan (new)

Alan Hamid | 15 comments Emms wrote: "Read, always.

I would never intentionally support an AI written book, an AI movie, or AI audiobook."

Neither would I, I meant if there is a written book and technology would allow us to either read or create visuals based on what is written like a animated version, would you then?


message 9: by Alan (new)

Alan Hamid | 15 comments Larissa wrote: "Read first and then decide if I wanna watch the movie. I really do believe some books would translate better as a movie/show and the other way around."

I meant if there is a written book and technology would allow us to either read or create visuals based on what is written like a animated version, would you then?
It is like now anyone now write on paper in high school, everything submitted digitally. The art of calligraphy is lost forever!


message 10: by Alan (new)

Alan Hamid | 15 comments èvieane wrote: "I would definitely still choose reading. I love imagining the characters and the places myself and this freedom of imagination is what I always love the most about reading. So for me, I would still..."

Emms wrote: "Read, always.

I would never intentionally support an AI written book, an AI movie, or AI audiobook."

That's all I did growing up. My best friends were the collections of hundreds of book that I read. It was the most peaceful and fun time of my childhood. I still read, but the feel I have had, I just can't get it back. So, enjoy the great reading times, while you can. Thanks for the lovely comment.


message 11: by Alan (new)

Alan Hamid | 15 comments Summer wrote: "I can't choose between them because it really depends on the quality bc majority of the time it's reading but franchises such as the Harry Potter franchise I feel are much better as movies but over..."
That's how my nephews and nieces feel. But reading to me is just priceless most of the times.


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

Well, honestly, in my experience, the movies miss out on a lot of crucial details. They are movies after all. Especially in the Hunger Games Series.... the movies missed out on a lot of funny details and events.


message 13: by Alan (new)

Alan Hamid | 15 comments I think there will be no alternative to have a same joy as reading for a while. Main reason, in my opinion we all process the information at our own pace as we read the book, sometime we go fast over a paragraph, sometimes we just ponder upon a sentence, and sometimes we just go over and over a phrase, before going forward. This seems a little difficult when watching movies. At least, this is how I read.


message 14: by KyoAi (new)

KyoAi ♡ | 778 comments Read


message 15: by sky (new)

sky | 16 comments better to watch maze runner tho...


message 16: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Read. At least read first. Reading lets me use my imagination. Watching does all the work for me.
If it's really a good read, I usually want it to be turned into a movie or series.


message 17: by Mimi ♡ (new)

Mimi ♡ (sanghamitra01) | 200 comments read for sure


message 18: by madelyn:) (new)

madelyn:) | 98 comments Barbara wrote: "Read. At least read first. Reading lets me use my imagination. Watching does all the work for me.
If it's really a good read, I usually want it to be turned into a movie or series."


so true


message 19: by Addison (new)

Addison Michlig | 46 comments Read no question


back to top