The Slaughterhouse Society discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
417 views
General Cult Proceedings > The Wanted List

Comments Showing 3,851-3,900 of 54,122 (54122 new)    post a comment »

Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dream, like I said before, being a toxic person and then having negative traits like being whiny, annoying, idiotic, the list goes on, are totally different things. She DOES do stupid, annoying things and has a long way to go, but after those first 1-2 ch she doesn't do anything TOXIC. If that's your standard for toxicity then do you have any idea how many characters across multiple books we'd call toxic? It does NOT FIT. And I agreed with you that she's toxic, however as the story progresses you can SEE the improvement and if we all did what you're saying, continue viewing a character based off our INITIAL impression then character arcs would NEVER WORK. You CANNOT hold a character to a first scene where you have no context or understanding of what's going on.


message 3852: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Being whiny, yelling(at Eiser is justifiable to be honest, he's way worse than her), being bitchy and other smaller moments in itself aren't signs of toxic behaviour, but if you combine them she wasn't the best of a person (reasonable) in the earlier chapters. She doesn't just stop being toxic after chapter 2 just because she didn't do anything as bad as what she did back then+ as I said those things still happened. And the author SHOWED it to us


message 3853: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
I never denied any development, but she doesn't just stop being toxic after the first 2 chapters. Her development is slow not spontaneous and she slowly fixes herself up and matures


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Being whiny, yelling(at Eiser is justifiable to be honest, he's way worse than her), being bitchy and other smaller moments in itself aren't signs of toxic behaviour, but if you combine them she wa..."

EXACTLY, they 'aren't signs of toxic behaviour' so you CANNOT call her toxic after the first 1-2 chapters because that is INCORRECT. I never disagreed that she has many flaws but toxicity is NOT one of THEM


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "I never denied any development, but she doesn't just stop being toxic after the first 2 chapters. Her development is slow not spontaneous and she slowly fixes herself up and matures"

Like I said Dream, give me an example then


message 3856: by All Might (new)

All Might (thesymbolofpeace) | 117 comments ❝Okay, Okay! Can someone catch me up?❞


message 3857: by ✦Artemis✦ (new)

✦Artemis✦ lol me to


message 3858: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (last edited Feb 23, 2024 10:19AM) (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Plus given Fredrick's and the servent's reaction, that wasn't a one time thing—it was recurring, just another Tuesday for them. The author didn't show us her doing it on-screen but there's a high chance she did still caused damage & yell at servents or something like that at the very least when Eiser wasn't here(that is, before any major change like her managing the hotel buisness came up)


message 3859: by Jose (new)

Jose (jo_c09) Yeahh, what’s going on??


message 3860: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Change takes time, even for a character as complex as Serena.


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Plus given Fredrick's and the servent's reaction, that wasn't a one time thing—it was recurring, just another Tuesday for them. The author didn't show us her doing it on-screen but there's a high c..."

YES but if you remember, that toxicity was a reaction to EISER, who was the actual toxic person in that situation and the servants themselves said it's because he's coming back. Even Frederick had only nice things to say about her apart from those moments


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Basically there's a webtoon called Serena and Dream thinks that the fmc is a toxic character for a long period of the webtoon but really, we only see her being toxic in the first 2 chapters and we KNOW Dream, that that is a response to a certain something, and hence I've been trying to make her understand that she ISN'T toxic past the first 1-2 chapters lol


message 3863: by Wania (new)

Wania | 207 comments HEYYYY


message 3864: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Plus given Fredrick's and the servent's reaction, that wasn't a one time thing—it was recurring, just another Tuesday for them. The author didn't show us her doing it on-screen..."

But Eiser and Serena dine every Wednesday


message 3865: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Waniaaaaa


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Plus given Fredrick's and the servent's reaction, that wasn't a one time thing—it was recurring, just another Tuesday for them. The author didn't ..."

That's the interesting thing, basically when someone is in a situation that has caused them trauma, it can result in them acting unlike themselves, did you know? 👀


message 3868: by Wania (last edited Feb 23, 2024 10:32AM) (new)

Wania | 207 comments Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"


HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?"


Doing greatttt, we've got some new memberss :D
I can't say anything for your relations as they barely come online anymore 😔


message 3870: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Yes, that EXPLAINS it, but her servents and Fredrick still endure her behaviour. The only reason they probably stay is because they KNOW (and the pay) and feel bad for her; It doesn't mean they don't deserve to get better treatment by her


message 3871: by Wania (new)

Wania | 207 comments Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?"

Doing greatttt, we've got some new memberss :D
I can't say anything for your relations as the..."


Anyone barely comes online anymore :(


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Yes, that EXPLAINS it, but her servents and Fredrick still endure her behaviour. The only reason they probably stay is because they KNOW (and the pay) and feel bad for her; It doesn't mean they don..."

You KNOW that Frederick is not around for just the pay and we've already established that this is not how she acts every day. They have more understanding towards her and her situation than you do lol


message 3873: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?"

Doing greatttt, we've got some new memberss :D
I can't say anything for your relations as the..."


Yusra and Aaoxa?


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?"

Doing greatttt, we've got some new memberss :D
I can't say anyt..."


Ikrrrr, we should kebab them for being inactive :D


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?"

Doing greatttt, we've got some new memberss :D
I can't say anyt..."


⚠️No Blue and Qeisya :)


message 3876: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (last edited Feb 23, 2024 10:37AM) (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Yes, that EXPLAINS it, but her servents and Fredrick still endure her behaviour. The only reason they probably stay is because they KNOW (and the pay) and feel bad for her; It ..."

That's literally what I said in my message, but as said in the last sentence; It doesn't mean her servants don't deserve to get better treatment. Yea on most days she's probably just bitchy and nothing more on normal days but every Wednesday (and the night before) counts


message 3877: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?"

Doing greatttt, we've got some new members..."


Ohhh I didn't know they were related :0


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Yes, that EXPLAINS it, but her servents and Fredrick still endure her behaviour. The only reason they probably stay is because they KNOW (and the ..."

Dream someone if you knew had gone through a traumatic incident and it caused them to act out because of it, would you ditch them because of that?? If it was a family member or a friend??


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1 HERE?"

Doing greatt..."


Yeahhh I could tellll :D


message 3880: by Yusra يسریٰ , With your head in your hand you/re nothing more than his wife (new)

Yusra يسریٰ   | 3688 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"

Heyyy Waniaa"

HOW IS EVERY1..."


blue nd Qeisya are relatedd to wania? how comee I didnt knoww


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Yusra يسریٰ wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Wania wrote: "HEYYYY"..."

You tell meee, how come YOU didn't knoww?


message 3882: by evie *s-ia* (new)

evie *s-ia*  | 2401 comments Dream wrote: "Keywords were; Bad person and Toxic. You can search it up yourself. But Evie yes, How long do you think Serena was toxic until development started to show?"

ok like she was " toxic" in general until until like 1-2
but she was still kind of a bad person until like 16


message 3883: by evie *s-ia* (new)

evie *s-ia*  | 2401 comments ☆ᗩᒪᒪᗰIGᕼT☆ wrote: "❝Okay, Okay! Can someone catch me up?❞"

they are talking about a webtoon dw


message 3884: by evie *s-ia* (new)

evie *s-ia*  | 2401 comments ok so hannas right
shes not really toxic after 1-2. shes still a bad person, and has remnants of toxicity, but shes not TOXIC. the only person u can argue shes toxic to is Frederick and even then, at least she told him hey we r friends with benefits not full on lovers w feelings


message 3885: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Still proves my point of her having toxic behaviour till even after chapter 2


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
✨Evie✨ wrote: "ok so hannas right
shes not really toxic after 1-2. shes still a bad person, and has remnants of toxicity, but shes not TOXIC. the only person u can argue shes toxic to is Frederick and even then, ..."


Yasssss Evieeee <33


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Still proves my point of her having toxic behaviour till even after chapter 2"

No, your point is WRONG Dreammm


message 3888: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
She's not as majorly toxic as in Chapter <2 but she still shows toxic behaviour beyond


message 3889: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Still proves my point of her having toxic behaviour till even after chapter 2"

No, your point is WRONG Dreammm"


EVEN EVIE SAID THE SAME THING


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "Still proves my point of her having toxic behaviour till even after chapter 2"

No, your point is WRONG Dreammm"

EVEN EVIE SAID THE SAME THING"


SHE DID NOT SAY THE SAME THING, BEING TOXIC AND HAVING NEGATIVE CHARACTERISTICS ARE TWO COMPLETELY DIFFERENT THINGS


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "She's not as majorly toxic as in Chapter <2 but she still shows toxic behaviour beyond"

Which you still can't give me an example of if I remember correctly-


message 3892: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
shes still a bad person, and has remnants of toxicity, but shes not TOXIC. the only person u can argue shes toxic to is Frederick


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "shes still a bad person, and has remnants of toxicity, but shes not TOXIC. the only person u can argue shes toxic to is Frederick"

Ah I missed that, okay fine but I disagree


message 3894: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "She's not as majorly toxic as in Chapter

Which you still can't give me an example of if I remember correctly-"


Because it's not one(or more)major moments like in the first 2 Chapters, as I said before, It's THERE and as Evie said, she is still a bad person and has remnants of toxicity. Just because she's not as bad as in Chapter 2 and below doesn't mean she's entirely redeemed herself and is completely un-toxic all of a sudden


message 3895: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "shes still a bad person, and has remnants of toxicity, but shes not TOXIC. the only person u can argue shes toxic to is Frederick"

Ah I missed that, okay fine but I disagree"


It's like half her message


message 3896: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Oh my god you're blind


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Dreamcatcher wrote: "Hanna (Fuchai's wife) wrote: "Dreamcatcher wrote: "She's not as majorly toxic as in Chapter

Which you still can't give me an example of if I remember correctly-"

Because it's not one(or more)maj..."


Like I said, there's a difference between being toxic and having negative characteristics, everyone has some kind of negative trait, do we call it 'the remnants of toxicity'? No, we call it what it is, a separate trait


message 3898: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
You should read Blindsight


message 3899: by Dreamcatcher (HIATUS), When you wake up next to him in the middle of the night (new)

Dreamcatcher (HIATUS) | 10348 comments Mod
Fantastic Sci fi


Hanna☾₊‧⁺˖⋆ (Free Palestine) | 5112 comments Mod
Lol, I'll check it out


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.