Editors and Writers discussion
Ink Deep Blog: Realistic expectations about your first novel
date
newest »


I wanted to comment on your blog about your post about being "under your pen," but the only options for posting seemed to be through Facebook or Yahoo. So I'm putting it here instead:
Erica,
I applaud your approach. A while back I remember reading a discussion thread in which several editors said that they felt commenting on the strengths of a work was something that they didn't think they should do, that their clients weren't paying for compliments but for corrections. And I imagine that there are authors who want to know nothing more than what needs to be fixed.
But like you, I have found that telling an author what works for me and why enhances the relationship. It is another part of the enlightenment you discuss above, and we all benefit from knowing that our carefully crafted nuances were noted and appreciated, that the humour we added brought a smile or a laugh, that the allusion on page thirty-five was not too esoteric for the intended audience.
Another great post — thank you!
Ruth

Thanks for the comments, Ruth!
http://www.inkdeepediting.com/#!Pract...