Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

L'anno del ferro (La dorsale, #1)
This topic is about L'anno del ferro
16 views
Book & Author Page Issues > please correct [MULTIPLE ISSUES]

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I cannot fix them myself.
--

please could someone delete this page, or merge it with the correct one?

same here: DENTRO L'ALGORITMO
incorrect / correct

same here: ASTRI AMARI
incorrect / correct

and here: SCANSATEVI DALLA LUCE
new edition / old edition

At last, CALIBANO (is a magazine!)

here is a cover missing and actually the whole record is terrible.

same for the #0 issue:
it has the cover but all else is missing.

on the publisher's page you can take all infos for both issues. Click on the picture on website to download it HD.

THANKS A LOT AND SORRY


message 2: by Trang (new)

Duong Trang | 179 comments Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I cannot fix them myself.
--

please could someone delete this page, or merge it with ..."


Hi, Giorgeliot! I fixed the issue with the Calibanos. However, I don't understand the issue with correct/incorrect pages. It seems to me that they are different editions of a book.


message 3: by lethe (new)

lethe | 16377 comments Calibano does not look like a magazine that should be in Goodreads. Only literary magazines are allowed.


message 4: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I cannot fix them myself.
--

please could someone delete this page..."


--

hello! Thank you for fixing Calibano 0 and 1 :)

for "scansatevi dalla luce" they are actually two different editions, one is new and one is older

but the others are not. they are duplicates of the same identical book :')


message 5: by Trang (new)

Duong Trang | 179 comments lethe wrote: "Calibano does not look like a magazine that should be in Goodreads. Only literary magazines are allowed."

I have tried to wrap my head around this topic with literary magazines, and on the publisher's site it is described that they are monographic magazines containing in-depth analyses of a thematic.

Though I'm not really sure if they are literary magazines.


message 6: by lethe (new)

lethe | 16377 comments Trang wrote: "Though I'm not really sure if they are literary magazines."

From the two issues linked to in the OP I'd say they are about music.

A magazine should have articles on literature or contain literature (such as poetry or short stories) to be valid for inclusion. I don't think these are.


message 7: by Trang (new)

Duong Trang | 179 comments lethe wrote: "Trang wrote: "Though I'm not really sure if they are literary magazines."

From the two issues linked to in the OP I'd say they are about music.

A magazine should have articles on literature or co..."


I see, then should I mark those as invalid?


message 8: by lethe (new)

lethe | 16377 comments Trang wrote: "I see, then should I mark those as invalid?"

Maybe the OP can explain what kind of magazines they are. If they are indeed music magazines (or something else non-literary), you can indeed mark them as invalid.


message 9: by Trang (new)

Duong Trang | 179 comments Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I cannot fix them myself.
--

please could someone de..."


Hi, they are indeed different editions. However, regarding the duplicates, they are also different editions, both published by effequ (one is the first edition and the other Kindle edition). I suppose the only thing we can do is combining them as Nic had said.


message 10: by Trang (new)

Duong Trang | 179 comments lethe wrote: "Trang wrote: "I see, then should I mark those as invalid?"

Maybe the OP can explain what kind of magazines they are. If they are indeed music magazines (or something else non-literary), you can in..."


Ok, thanks!


message 11: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments lethe wrote: "Calibano does not look like a magazine that should be in Goodreads. Only literary magazines are allowed."

it is a very much literary magazine :)


message 12: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments lethe wrote: "Trang wrote: "I see, then should I mark those as invalid?"

Maybe the OP can explain what kind of magazines they are. If they are indeed music magazines (or something else non-literary), you can in..."


hello, these are NOT music magazines. They are monographic issues about a subject with a multiple approach (essays, poems, short stories etc) and from multiple points of view (architecture, history of music, arts, political theory and so on).


message 13: by Silvia (last edited Jul 28, 2023 07:10AM) (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I cannot fix them myself.
--

plea..."


[edited after understanding]

Ok now I see - but since they are the same book it is possible to merge them, right? and let the reader choose the format?

So now the thing is: there are two editions of Scansatevi dalla luce (which exists in print also in the new edition, not only kindle), but not of the other books.


message 14: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I cannot fix them myself.
--

plea..."


also, the kindle edition exists also as printed book...


message 15: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments lethe wrote: "Trang wrote: "Though I'm not really sure if they are literary magazines."

From the two issues linked to in the OP I'd say they are about music.

A magazine should have articles on literature or co..."


they so very are :)


message 16: by Trang (new)

Duong Trang | 179 comments Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I cannot fix them my..."

Merging means combining two editions that are actually duplicates, and then updating the status of one edition to "Deleted". Combining means taking two or more editions and linking them into one work. No editions are deleted, so you have the same number of editions before and after a combination. From what I understand each edition of a work is of a unique format/language/publisher.

I added the new print edition of Scansatevi dalla luce by effequ, feel free to check it out!


message 17: by Silvia (last edited Jul 28, 2023 08:21AM) (new) - added it

Silvia (giorgeliot) | 41 comments Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going crazy because I..."

Thanks a lot, now it's exactly how I wanted it - so it's "combining" and not "merging" the word I was looking for :)


message 18: by Trang (new)

Duong Trang | 179 comments Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "Trang wrote: "Giorgeliot wrote: "hello everyone, I hope a multiple request is ok - I'm the publisher of these books and I'm going c..."

You're welcome! Send us a message if there is anything else!


back to top