Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

Carrigmore Castle
This topic is about Carrigmore Castle
9 views
Serieses! > [DONE]Please create series of pre-existing books :)

Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Capn (last edited Feb 27, 2023 02:34PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Capn | 354 comments Hello!

I just finished reading the (excellent) vintage Carrigmore Castle series, and can confirm the correct sequence (two books were published in the same year and are listed alphabetically on Wikipedia, but they are out of sequence, as I found out the hard way!).

The correct series order is:
1. Carrigmore Castle - 1954
2. Tiffany and the Swallow Rhyme - 1956*
3. The Cuckoo at Coolnean - 1956*
4. Strangers in Carrigmore - 1958
5. The Tobermillin Oracle - 1962

*they are BOTH listed here as 1 Jan 1956. Neither of my copies (Faber and Faber, first ed.) have dates let alone years written inside. I don't believe they were released at the same time, but perhaps only in the same year, and it defaults to 1 Jan.

I can confirm that this is the correct sequence by way of a spoiler: In Tiffany and the Swallow Rhyme, their mother, Mrs. McKean, is ill and told to take bedrest, and they are sent on holiday without their parents to stay with a family friend. They are told there will be a 'surprise' for them upon their return - (view spoiler). In The Cuckoo at Coolnean, a minor plot point is when (view spoiler). I read these out of sequence and was at first confused as to why (view spoiler) wasn't mentioned in re: vacation plans/care considerations. ;) I quickly realised why, and that these two which were published in 1956 were listed out of order.

Is that sufficient information? WorldCat doesn't give dates (just '1956'), so I can't find a secondary source. I'm the only person to have reviewed them, though 2 others have read the final book as well.

Thanks very much. She has other series, none of which are listed on GR (Dawks is one, and The McNeills at Rathcapple has at least one sequel), but I haven't read them yet (hard to come by).


message 2: by Sandra (new)

Sandra | 31515 comments Done.

Yes, the database defaults to January 1 when only the year is added.

https://www.goodreads.com/series/3646...


Capn | 354 comments Thanks, Sandra. :) I hope future readers will enjoy reading these in the right order now! :D


back to top