Help needed picking proper story title.

[K.]

I'd comment, but with your readers and artists debating about the title, without reading the story wouldn't know which way to jump. Though the last titles in your poll don't seem to grab the way your first two do if that helps.

[Micah]

the other three choices all use the word paradox. Is there really a paradox?

[Micah]

Of course I could just make up some...

On Fungal Wings
The Atheist, the Shrooms, and the Afterlife
Even Christopher Hitchens Ate Mushrooms (Someone should write this one even if you don't.)
The Mathematician's Death Cap (I really like that one!)

;)

[Jeffrey]

I don't have a google account so can't vote, but the ethereal pixie rings of mercy would be my preferred

[Christina]

I'm going to have to go with the ethereal pixies as well, although taking from Micah's ideas, I would twist his suggestion into An Athiest in the Afterlife.

[Hákon]

I like that title, An Atheist in the Afterlife.

[Robert]

It could be my way of thinking, I think I have an idea of what I would be reading with An Atheist in the Afterlife, the other titles don't mean much to me.

[[deleted user]]

"had a 1980s heavy metal ring to it"

This makes me very leery to suggest using the name of an awesome song for such a work, but the concept at least screams the name The Golden Walls Of Heaven.