Ilyon Chronicles discussion

107 views
Ilyon Related > Series Speculations

Comments Showing 301-350 of 476 (476 new)    post a comment »

message 301: by Claire (new)

Claire Banschbach I kind of agree that having a Christ figure doesn't really seem to fit to me, but that's only because I've only seen two books out of the series. So depending on where the rest of the series goes, maybe it will make more sense. But yeah, I was getting an early Christian vibe from the first few books, but the lamb sacrifice and the talk about the need for a big sacrifice opened up some interesting possibilities. I'm looking forward to seeing how it all plays out.

Timothy was the first person to come to mind when it comes to a Christ figure because he's taking the role of prophet/preacher, so..


message 302: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Beguerie (amandabeguerie) | 467 comments Keep in mind that a Christ figure would have to be perfect, and one with Elôm. I mean, that would, of course, be if Ilyon would parallel the Bible.


message 303: by Kendra (new)

Kendra Ardnek | 541 comments Agreed. I don't think that it's anyone that we've met already.


message 304: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments Claire, I had considered Timothy too. But I also agree with Amanda. And I don't think Timothy could quite fit with that. Especially his relationship with Leetra. (Admittedly mostly imagined by us, but I think There's enough there.)


message 305: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments @Anna: That's a good theory, about Kyrin being a Mary figure...


message 306: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Beguerie (amandabeguerie) | 467 comments Also, if someone we know was the Mary figure, the Christ figure would have to be born - therefore making His sacrifice much later in the series. Of course it could be Kyrin, but I'm not sure the likelihood. For any of you that read Makilien, Meniah (am I spelling that right?) was already a grown man when we met him.


message 307: by Kendra (new)

Kendra Ardnek | 541 comments True, but that doesn't mean that Jaye wouldn't attack it from a different angle in this series. We don't know the time frame for the full series.

It's an interesting theory. I don't know that I'm sold on it, though. We'll see what happens.

I'm thinking that the Sacrifice would happen in the last book, though. Just throwing that theory out there.


message 308: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments I would be shocked if Kyrin were Mary. I'd sooner suspect Lady Anne. But if we're speculating solely on characters we have already met, I'd sooner suspect Lenae and Jeremy actually. :)

Or what if it were Torin. :)

But I don't believe it's anyone we know already...at least not well...

Meniah gives me entire confidence that an Ilyon version would be done excellently. :)

There's no saying you'd have to have a Sacrifice in the series. You could have a birth in the series. However, a sacrifice is, granted, much more dramatic and also climactic and pivotal. *ponders how the Sacrifice would be key to Jace were it to occur in SP* *doesn't know what future books' themes are so can't speculate that far* :)

I was also thinking of the abortion issue mention briefly in Resistance. If there were a birth scene, that could factor in very dramatically considering the culture. Maybe a Moses-like birth scene (toned down for reputations' sake of course).

All this is just speculation though. :) I don't believe any of it will actually appear in the books, though I could be surprised. :)


message 309: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (wordfitlyspoken) | 158 comments And now I have to wonder if Jaye will read all this and be smirking and chuckling and thinking "They're so far off it's hilarious."


message 310: by Alyssa (new)

Alyssa | 410 comments Amanda wrote: "And now I have to wonder if Jaye will read all this and be smirking and chuckling and thinking "They're so far off it's hilarious.""

I was thinking the same thing. ;)


message 311: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments But hey, whether we're light years off or spot on, that's not important. What's important is that we're thinking and analyzing - and through so doing some of us are learning to be better authors and plotters, and all of us are learning to be better thinkers. :)

Plus we are spending more time around Ilyon and its characters. :)


message 312: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments Resterwen wrote: "But hey, whether we're light years off or spot on, that's not important. What's important is that we're thinking and analyzing - and through so doing some of us are learning to be better authors an..."

Agreed.


message 313: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments XDDD This is great, guys. I'm leaning towards maybe this staying as an Old Testament thing. I haven't read the Makilien series, but... and this is just a random theory... What if all of this is stuff that happens long before that series. Maybe Jesus won't feature at all in this series, and it will just be focusing on the Old Testament-ish times. Maybe Jace is a sort of Moses figure, or maybe he's supposed to be like David? XD That's probably just a wild theory, though.


message 314: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (wordfitlyspoken) | 158 comments That's a good idea, C.B. It might just stay as an Old Testament-y thing.

Hmmm.


message 315: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments Jaye made a comment on Facebook about researching pregnancy. Someone's having a baby I think. You're all going to say Anne.


message 316: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments I was thinking about posting the same comment here, Anna. :) but it could be a much later book. :) (or even a different series/story?)


message 317: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments Oooooh....


message 318: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments I agree that it wouldn't be Samara's Peril. I was thinking maybe five, but she finished the first draft months ago and I don't know that she's working on six yet.


message 319: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments Probably not in SP. She might be planning for six, or she might be editing 5...


message 320: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments I have a feeling abortion will be an issue in one of the books. So that would make sense that someone would be pregnant...


message 321: by gabi (new)

gabi | 358 comments I know that she's writing the first draft of book six. But who knows?


message 322: by Jaye (new)

Jaye Knight (jayelknight) | 389 comments Mod
I should be more careful with what I post on FB. XD

I have started the first draft of book six, but in writing book five, I had an unexpected romance pop up that demanded to be told. So I'm actually working on a short story that takes place just after book five. As soon as I finish it, I'll get back to work on book six. :)


message 323: by Alyssa (new)

Alyssa | 410 comments OOH!! I'm intrigued!! :)


message 324: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments Let me guess, we haven't met either of the characters yet.


message 325: by Jaye (new)

Jaye Knight (jayelknight) | 389 comments Mod
Actually, you have met one. ;)


message 326: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments Well, guessing got me more information. Another guess, this person is male.


message 327: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Beguerie (amandabeguerie) | 467 comments I was going to guess the same.


message 328: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Beguerie (amandabeguerie) | 467 comments Is it Aaron?


message 329: by Claire (new)

Claire Banschbach My bet is Liam.


message 330: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments It being Liam would be nice, but for some reason it doesn't seem quite right to me. Which is a funny thing to say with almost no information. What about Talas?


message 331: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments Oooooh....


message 332: by Shantelle (new)

Shantelle | 62 comments Ooh ... all the speculations!! I haven't been on this thread for awhile ... this is great!! :D *must hurry back to Samara's Peril*


message 333: by Hannah (new)

Hannah (readingrogers) | 41 comments Maybe Timothy?
Is it just me or am I the only one who's dying to read SP? Agh, it's killing me!


message 334: by Alyssa (new)

Alyssa | 410 comments IT IS TORTURE!!


message 335: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments No not Timothy. I thought we already had another idea there. And nobody wants anything to happen to Leetra.


message 336: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments I'm surprised that no one has mentioned Daniel... :) Maybe you all just expect Daniel to get a girl anyway, so you don't think he would unexpectedly have a romance that far down the line. :)

*thinks of all the females it could possibly be if it IS a female*

I feel like speculating on the ones no one else will... Lenae? :) or Davira. ;) or Lydia! That would be quite interesting actually.

Or maybe Trask died and Lady Anne gets a new fiancé... ;) *hides from horrified fans* (I actually would be shocked if that happened.)

We actually have comparatively few unattached females we've met at this point who would be of proper age - assuming that this isn't 10 years away, which I believe is a safe assumption.

But back on the topic everyone was effectively distracted from... if there's a marriage, it gives the pregnancy theory more support. ;)


message 337: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments *shakes head* I have no clue...


message 338: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments I thought of Daniel, but didn't say anything. He seems a bit too important for that to happen unexpectedly.
I was trying to count the number of female characters with even one appearance. I actually kept thinking of more.
Kyrin, Anne, Lydia, Leetra, Meredith, Davira, Lenae, Solara, Lady Videlle, Holly, Elsie, Rebekah, Edith, Kalli. With Tallas' sister that makes fifteen. I think that's all of them who have names.


message 339: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments I'm guessing it's not Meredith or Kalli. :) and Solara is married... But we don't know if she is by that point...


message 340: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments :p it is spelled Solora, isn't it. :P


message 341: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments Kalli died. At the beginning. And you're right about it being Solora. I wasn't looking.


message 342: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments *cries because of Half-blood's reminder of Kalli and Aldor*


message 343: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments I was thinking about a Christ figure again. If Arcacia is Rome, then maybe Samara is somewhat representative of Judea and that is where the saviour comes. Near the beginning of Resistance it mentioned that their faith had preserved them, but it was growing weaker.
I could be completely wrong of course, but it's something worth considering.


message 344: by Kendra (new)

Kendra Ardnek | 541 comments Hmmm ....


message 345: by Amanda (new)

Amanda (wordfitlyspoken) | 158 comments That's an interesting theory.


message 346: by Kendra (new)

Kendra Ardnek | 541 comments EXILES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Book 4 has an official title and description. Yay! Why aren't we already speculating?

So, stuff we know for certain:

King Balam and Prince Daniel are the two characters mentioned by name. Both are great characters I look forward to hearing more about. Yay!

OUR PARTY IS GOING TO DORLAND, I.E. The crete country. So this means that we're going to meet more cretes, which means that Kaden might get to meet Talas's younger sister, and my ship might come about!

I believe this is the one book where there won't be a single prison break. (I'm like 90% sure that Jaye said it was book four)

The mock cover is red. This feels important to me.


message 347: by C.B. (new)

C.B. Cook (cbcook) | 293 comments RED MEANS BLOOD!!!! *cough* I mean... Love. Yes. Love.


message 348: by Erika (new)

Erika Mathews (erikamathews) | 199 comments I noticed the red, too. Quite a different feel from the greens and browns of the other covers....

Cretes! Sounds like fun....

Seems like this book has potential for drastic (i.e. bad) things to happen. Especially with the three story lines. But also good - especially with where all the characters are at. :)

BUT. THERE'S AN ARENA ON THE PINTEREST BOARD. :( :(

On a happier note, there's happy Trask and Anne on the board too. :) Maybe...? :)


message 349: by Brie (new)

Brie Donning (briedonning) | 199 comments Or red could mean fire. I think the colour has alotof fight to it. Dorland also comes with a small chance of finding giants.


message 350: by Alyssa (new)

Alyssa | 410 comments In an interview I did with Jaye, she said that Prince Daniel was a big part of this one! So maybe he gets exiled??


back to top