Nothing But Reading Challenges discussion
This topic is about
All the Light We Cannot See
Previous BOMs - Authors; A - D
>
All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr (Anything Goes BOM) Start Date March 19, 2015
Mod
8. good observation, I hadn't thought about them both being auditory characters
10. lol oh I would hope not! Doesn't seem that kind of book (so far) :o
Mod
8. I like S Napier's observation above. This is a really interesting part of these characters
9. I hadn't thought of that, but it is possible. I guess it is one of the first French/German connections introduced
10. Well we don't know if they have the real one or not. I actually think this will be more of a symbol for something else. Hope perhaps? She does seem to be holding it during the 1944 scenes
11. I was surprised that we went to the future again, I wasn't expecting it. I'm not sure I like too many flips back and forth. I'm really keen to see how we get there!
12. I'm not sure. It does make an interesting setting for the story though and I'm keen to read on
Questions: Bigger Faster Brighter-Brittany8. Up to this point we've been introduced to Marie-Laure and Werner, and a big part of Doerr's story telling regards sound, Marie-Laure being blind most of her story is told through what she hears and smells, and Werner is capitvated by the radio, do you believe this has some significance?
Yes I believe this is significant. I too was particularly interested in Werner's hearing loss after the attack.
9. What do you believe is the significance in Werner learning to build the radio and his fascination with the technical information in the French science program? Do you believe this will come to play as we learn more of what is happening in 1944? Do you believe the French science program will have significance should our two protagonists meet?
Werner's fascination with building radios and his fortuitous opportunity to fix the corporal's radio change his life. So much attention is paid to the French science program that I have no doubt we will see it again.
10. We are beginning to see the start of War World II, Marie-Laure and her Father are on the run, and it seems like he may of the diamond with him. What do you believe this will mean for their family? Do you believe they will be cursed as the stories of the gem propose, is it truly magical will we see miracles with Marie-Laure and her eyesight? Or is it just a gem that can buy 5 Eiffel Towers?
At this point I think very little of the stone and it's role in the book. My feelings at this point are one of sadness that anyone should have to leave their home in this way and that anyone could ever think that it is in anyway proper to treat children and human beings like cattle as Werner was during his examination.
11. Back to 1944 we get a very short glimpse into this period, Werner is trapped and disoriented, Marie-Laurie can tell that her Uncle's house is on fire. All we see if negative things happening to these characters, what do you make of that? Do you believe Doerr is just trying to prepare the reader for the awful fate that awaits our protagonists or is something else? Do you feel more engaged with this break up of the chronology of the story?
I don't think Doerr is preparing us for anything in particular. It is a reminder once again that the characters ultimately end up in the same place even though their parallel stories seem so far apart. I don't mind the break up of chronology.
12. Marie-Laure and her father arrive in Saint-Malo, Marie wishes she was really going back home to Paris but at the same time is intrigued by the new place they are in, what do you think Saint-Malo holds, it seems to be the final resting place for Marie-Laure in this story, is that good or bad? What significance do you think this holds for the diamond now that she is close to the Ocean?
I don't really have an answer to this question. For now Saint-Malo is a safe place. The diamond is for now a back story that I'm aware of but not focused on.
Questions: Zero - Rumours1. There are two epigrams at the start of the book. How do they affect your approach to the book?
They didn't affect my approach.
2. The chapters are all very short (so far). How do you find this style? Do you think Doerr has chosen to use short chapters to generate a particular effect? Is it successful or not?
I like the short chapters, it makes it very easy to stop at the end of a chapter...or to just read one more :)
3. The first section is set in 1944, and we jump back to 1934 at a critical point. Does this sneak peek into the future draw you in, or do you prefer your storylines to be strictly chronological?
They can be hit or miss with me, but I really liked the time jump in this one.
4. What are your impressions of inter-war Paris? and rural Germany? How effective is Doerr at creating the atmosphere?
There are different than I was expecting. Paris is told in a more sensory way, probably because this is told from Marie-Laure's perspective, while Germany is told more like your usual novel. It took a bit for me to get used to the differences, but it's growing on me and I'm starting to enjoy the differences between the two.
5. Marie-Laure and Werner have very different home-lives, but each are under a form of imprisonment (blindness / rigidly constrained future). What other parallels and differences are there?
They are both have people in their lives that care about them.
6. Do you have a preference for either of the storylines? If so, why?
No, they are both very interesting.
7. The Natural History Museum and its exhibits are described in loving detail. Do you enjoy the use of language? Have you highlighted (mentally or acutally) any phrases?
It's okay. No.
8. The Sea of Flame: is this significant? Would you suggest throwing a famed (albeit cursed) diamond in the ocean, as Marie-Laure did?
I thought she was the only one to completely understand the story about the diamond. Would I throw it in the ocean, probably not, but according to the story that's what should be done. I'm looking forward to seeing what role this diamond plays in the story, if any.
Questions: Bigger Faster Brighter-Brittany9. Up to this point we've been introduced to Marie-Laure and Werner, and a big part of Doerr's story telling regards sound, Marie-Laure being blind most of her story is told through what she hears and smells, and Werner is capitvated by the radio, do you believe this has some significance?
There probably is some significance, but I haven't figured it out yet.
10. What do you believe is the significance in Werner learning to build the radio and his fascination with the technical information in the French science program? Do you believe this will come to play as we learn more of what is happening in 1944? Do you believe the French science program will have significance should our two protagonists meet?
I haven't any idea, but I'm looking forward to finding out :)
11. We are beginning to see the start of War World II, Marie-Laure and her Father are on the run, and it seems like he may of the diamond with him. What do you believe this will mean for their family? Do you believe they will be cursed as the stories of the gem propose, is it truly magical will we see miracles with Marie-Laure and her eyesight? Or is it just a gem that can buy 5 Eiffel Towers?
I don't believe the diamond is cursed, or that he father has the real one, but that it's just an ordinary stone - beautiful, but nothing magical.
12. Back to 1944 we get a very short glimpse into this period, Werner is trapped and disoriented, Marie-Laurie can tell that her Uncle's house is on fire. All we see if negative things happening to these characters, what do you make of that? Do you believe Doerr is just trying to prepare the reader for the awful fate that awaits our protagonists or is something else? Do you feel more engaged with this break up of the chronology of the story?
There may be something awful that happens, but I think they will overcome it and become stronger for it. I'm still enjoying the back and forth with the time, it's making me read quicker because I want to get back to the most current time.
13. Marie-Laure and her father arrive in Saint-Malo, Marie wishes she was really going back home to Paris but at the same time is intrigued by the new place they are in, what do you think Saint-Malo holds, it seems to be the final resting place for Marie-Laure in this story, is that good or bad? What significance do you think this holds for the diamond now that she is close to the Ocean?
I'm hoping that she doesn't die in that house, so hopefully it won't be her final resting place. I'm thinking that if Marie-Laure believes herself cursed because of the diamond, since she's so close to the sea (ocean) that she'll throw it in the sea.
Questions: Madame Manec-Museum14. Why do you think that Jutta questions what they're told, while Werner seems to accept it?
15. Marie-Laure's great-uncle is the one who broadcasts the program that Jutta & Werner heard. How do you think this will play into the story?
16. Werner's fascination with technology made the test in the class easy for him and made the instructor take notice of him. Do you think that was a good thing? What do you think the outcome of this will be for him?
17. Marie-Laure's neighbor in Saint-Malo sees her father measuring the street and buildings, finds this suspicious and plans on reporting him to the authorities. What do you think will happen to her father because of this and how does this make you feel towards that neighbor?
18. What thoughts do you have about the story now that we're a third into it? Any speculations about what will happen?
message 58:
by
Karen ⊰✿, Fiction Aficionado
(last edited Mar 22, 2015 12:00AM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Mod
14. I think he doesn't necessarily accept it, as much as understands the consequences. He is more likely to tow the line to keep them both safe
15. This really surprised me! Nice connection that has been created, although I'm not sure where it will head yet
16. I guess he will be some kind of star pupil. His storyline is becoming more fascinating
17. This is not good. It is unfortunate that at these times paranoia sets in and I guess this is why in 1944 Marie-Laure is alone. Makes me sad
18. I am really enjoying it. Despite the subject matter it doesn't feel heavy or too descriptive. The style really appeals to me and I really enjoy historical fiction generally anyway
14. Why do you think that Jutta questions what they're told, while Werner seems to accept it?I think Werner's main concern is to protect Jutta, so I think he pretends to swallow more than he really does. I think he is good at hiding what he actually believes.
15. Marie-Laure's great-uncle is the one who broadcasts the program that Jutta & Werner heard. How do you think this will play into the story?
I was surprised to discover the connection, but it's such a great "coincidence" and I can't wait to see how that develops later.
16. Werner's fascination with technology made the test in the class easy for him and made the instructor take notice of him. Do you think that was a good thing? What do you think the outcome of this will be for him?
Well, it depends on what is meant by "a good thing." It will certainly take him on a different path in life than just being an unremarkable student. We might see some bullying later?
17. Marie-Laure's neighbor in Saint-Malo sees her father measuring the street and buildings, finds this suspicious and plans on reporting him to the authorities. What do you think will happen to her father because of this and how does this make you feel towards that neighbor?
I think her father will be arrested and that's why he has gone out the evening before the bombing and hasn't returned. I kind of hate the neighbor - he seems an opportunistic jerk.
18. What thoughts do you have about the story now that we're a third into it? Any speculations about what will happen?
I am really enjoying the story. It's well-written, has a bit of suspense going, and I am looking forward to finding out what happens. I speculate that Werner will save Marie-Laure somehow because I don't think her father or Uncle Etienne will be able to return for her.
Questions: Bigger Faster Brighter-Brittany8. Up to this point we've been introduced to Marie-Laure and Werner, and a big part of Doerr's story telling regards sound, Marie-Laure being blind most of her story is told through what she hears and smells, and Werner is capitvated by the radio, do you believe this has some significance?
Yes, I think this is significant others have explained why very well.
9. What do you believe is the significance in Werner learning to build the radio and his fascination with the technical information in the French science program? Do you believe this will come to play as we learn more of what is happening in 1944? Do you believe the French science program will have significance should our two protagonists meet?
I think it will all come into play later on in the story and I expect it will be in the final few chapters. Definitely on the last question.
10. We are beginning to see the start of War World II, Marie-Laure and her Father are on the run, and it seems like he may of the diamond with him. What do you believe this will mean for their family? Do you believe they will be cursed as the stories of the gem propose, is it truly magical will we see miracles with Marie-Laure and her eyesight? Or is it just a gem that can buy 5 Eiffel Towers?
The start of WWII will change their family dynamics, you can already see that in the way Maire-Laure’s father is starting to keep things from her. I don’t think we will see miracles happen, it is not that kind of story. It is just a very expensive diamond.
11. Back to 1944 we get a very short glimpse into this period, Werner is trapped and disoriented, Marie-Laurie can tell that her Uncle's house is on fire. All we see if negative things happening to these characters, what do you make of that? Do you believe Doerr is just trying to prepare the reader for the awful fate that awaits our protagonists or is something else? Do you feel more engaged with this break up of the chronology of the story?
There are negative things after the bombing of course, what I noticed more were the positive things, Werner being rescued and Marie-Laure getting out from her hiding place under the bed and finding shelter in the basement. I liked the break-up, since the start of the book I’ve been wondering what happened to Marie-Laure and Werner.
12. Marie-Laure and her father arrive in Saint-Malo, Marie wishes she was really going back home to Paris but at the same time is intrigued by the new place they are in, what do you think Saint-Malo holds, it seems to be the final resting place for Marie-Laure in this story, is that good or bad? What significance do you think this holds for the diamond now that she is close to the Ocean?
Questions: Madame Manec-Museum14. Why do you think that Jutta questions what they're told, while Werner seems to accept it?
I don’t think Werner accepts what he’s being told, he is going along trying to make a better future for himself and for Jutta and he’s trying to protect her while doing that.
15. Marie-Laure's great-uncle is the one who broadcasts the program that Jutta & Werner heard. How do you think this will play into the story?
I think it will be the way Werner is going to meet and relate to Marie-Laure.
16. Werner's fascination with technology made the test in the class easy for him and made the instructor take notice of him. Do you think that was a good thing? What do you think the outcome of this will be for him?
I think it will be a blessing in disguise. At first it will draw him into bad things and into the war. But he will come out positive.
17. Marie-Laure's neighbor in Saint-Malo sees her father measuring the street and buildings, finds this suspicious and plans on reporting him to the authorities. What do you think will happen to her father because of this and how does this make you feel towards that neighbor?
I don’t know what will happen to him but it won’t be good. In the 1944 sections he doesn’t seem to be in the picture.
18. What thoughts do you have about the story now that we're a third into it? Any speculations about what will happen?
I don’t like to speculate about what will happen, but I love the story so far. It is different from most of the books I’ve read staged at the time of WWII.
Mod
The two serve very different purposes, I think. The first, about the destruction of Saint-Malo, sets up the tension that helps drive the story (how do they get to Saint-Malo? will they escape? how?). As well, it makes me hugely sad about the destruction of war.
The second, about the power of radio, is more intriguing, making me puzzle out how it fits with the story.
2. The chapters are all very short (so far). How do you find this style? Do you think Doerr has chosen to use short chapters to generate a particular effect? Is it successful or not?
I wondered if the shortness of the chapters has a parallel with how Marie-Laure gets small impressions of the world, and has to build them up into complete picture. And also the flickers of a tuning radio, the brief moments of clear transmission through static. I'm enjoying the short chapters
3. The first section is set in 1944, and we jump back to 1934 at a critical point. Does this sneak peek into the future draw you in, or do you prefer your storylines to be strictly chronological?
I don't mind time-jumps, and am enjoying getting to know the characters and how they got to that point.
4. Marie-Laure and Werner have very different home-lives, but each are under a form of imprisonment (blindness / rigidly constrained future). What other parallels and differences are there?
I am interested in their different outlets: into fantasy and fiction for Maire whilst Werner is focussed on escape through technology. It's really important, I think, that they have the key figures in their lives to support and challenge them.
5. Do you have a preference for either of the storylines? If so, why?
They are both (differently) compelling
6. The Natural History Museum and its exhibits are described in loving detail. Do you enjoy the use of language? Have you highlighted (mentally or acutally) any phrases?
I haven't highlighted anything (sacrilege!) but love the turns of phrase and, in particular, the descriptions of how Marie-Laure perceives the world, with colours and sound and smells. It's really effective.
7. The Sea of Flame: is this significant? Would you suggest throwing a famed (albeit cursed) diamond in the ocean, as Marie-Laure did?
Slightly too much shades of Titanic for me at the moment. I'm keeping a wary eye on how this aspect of the story shapes up (magical realism is a genre I have to be ready for)
8. Up to this point we've been introduced to Marie-Laure and Werner, and a big part of Doerr's story telling regards sound, Marie-Laure being blind most of her story is told through what she hears and smells, and Werner is captivated by the radio, do you believe this has some significance?
Sound is the easiest escape into the wider world for both of them. So, yes, these characteristics are deliberately chosen to forge the connections the drive the stories
9. What do you believe is the significance in Werner learning to build the radio and his fascination with the technical information in the French science program? Do you believe this will come to play as we learn more of what is happening in 1944? Do you believe the French science program will have significance should our two protagonists meet?
I don't think there's any significance there.
10. We are beginning to see the start of War World II, Marie-Laure and her Father are on the run, and it seems like he may of the diamond with him. What do you believe this will mean for their family? Do you believe they will be cursed as the stories of the gem propose, is it truly magical will we see miracles with Marie-Laure and her eyesight? Or is it just a gem that can buy 5 Eiffel Towers?
I remain wary of the idea that the diamond (carbon!) is cursed or magical or anything other than a pretty stone. I didn't pick this book up expecting magic!
11. Back to 1944 we get a very short glimpse into this period, Werner is trapped and disoriented, Marie-Laurie can tell that her Uncle's house is on fire. All we see if negative things happening to these characters, what do you make of that? Do you believe Doerr is just trying to prepare the reader for the awful fate that awaits our protagonists or is something else? Do you feel more engaged with this break up of the chronology of the story?
This flick forward actually distracted me from the flow. I didn't expect the jump, and it didn't add anything to the story, for me.
14. Why do you think that Jutta questions what they're told, while Werner seems to accept it?
I don't think Werner is accepting it, but recognises the best way for him to escape the mines is through compliance. Jutta doesn't have that potential for escape, so questioning is her best way to deal with the situation
15. Marie-Laure's great-uncle is the one who broadcasts the program that Jutta & Werner heard. How do you think this will play into the story?
Woah! it was a shock to me! But I liked this other use of sound as a way to connect with the wider world, to keep hope burning.
16. Werner's fascination with technology made the test in the class easy for him and made the instructor take notice of him. Do you think that was a good thing? What do you think the outcome of this will be for him?
It'll pave his path to Saint-Malo, I guess. Hoping that there's no bullying.
17. Marie-Laure's neighbor in Saint-Malo sees her father measuring the street and buildings, finds this suspicious and plans on reporting him to the authorities. What do you think will happen to her father because of this and how does this make you feel towards that neighbor?
It's deeply unsettling, especially as the neighbour is actively planning to collaborate. And I suspect bad things will happen to the father and Etienne :(
18. What thoughts do you have about the story now that we're a third into it? Any speculations about what will happen?
I'm enjoying it, but no speculating! That diamond had better not turn it all magical on me though!
Questions: The Wardrobe – Entropy19. Poor Frederick. I don’t like this school Werner is in. The teaching methods are brutal. I think Werner is being used by making these calculations and working on that radio. What could they want from him, what is he making?
20. I think we have an answer now as to what happened to Marie-Laure’s father. Will he survive in the work camps?
21.Back to 1944 again. I do like these flash forwards of sorts. What I keep wondering is what happened to Marie-Laure’s uncle and Madame Marec? How could they leave her in that house all alone, why couldn’t they take her with them? What do you think did they just forget her or is there a reason for her staying behind?
22. This section ends on a cliffhanger, Sergeant Major von Rumpel is entering Marie-Laure’s house. What do you think he is after and will he get it?
23. Finally Marie-Laure gets to see the ocean. It seemed to have broken her out of the state she was in after her father left. What did you think of the letter her father send? Do you think she will believe a thing he wrote in there?
24. Things at that school are getting worse too especially for Frederick. I applauded him for the way he reacted when he didn’t throw the water. What did you think? I keep hoping Werner will stand up for his friend and he does a little bit to help Frederick, but is it enough?
Questions: Madame Manec-Museum14. Why do you think that Jutta questions what they're told, while Werner seems to accept it?
I'm not sure that Werner "accepts it". Werner's future is predestined because he is an orphan and a male. He is destined for the mines. I think he feels trapped and feels there is no point in questioning things because he cannot change it. When he is invited to the school it is better for him to ignore what his gut may tell him because it benefits him. Werner would do anything to avoid the mines. I also view Jutta as being Werner's conscience. I wish Jutta had a more prominent role in the book.
15. Marie-Laure's great-uncle is the one who broadcasts the program that Jutta & Werner heard. How do you think this will play into the story?
Too coincidental that we have now seen the program twice....time will tell.
16. Werner's fascination with technology made the test in the class easy for him and made the instructor take notice of him. Do you think that was a good thing? What do you think the outcome of this will be for him?
Yes this was a good thing for Werner in the short term. Otherwise he would likely be "the weakest" and would suffer the consequences. His technological strengths offer him protection.
17. Marie-Laure's neighbor in Saint-Malo sees her father measuring the street and buildings, finds this suspicious and plans on reporting him to the authorities. What do you think will happen to her father because of this and how does this make you feel towards that neighbor?
Claude is a snake.
18. What thoughts do you have about the story now that we're a third into it? Any speculations about what will happen?
I love this book. I'm actually rereading it so I don't give away any spoilers so I won't speculate. I will add though that if you are enjoying this book, I highly recommend The Book Thief. There are definite similarities.
19. Poor Frederick. I don’t like this school Werner is in. The teaching methods are brutal. I think Werner is being used by making these calculations and working on that radio. What could they want from him, what is he making?I think the school likely represents what actually happened in Germany during this time. How do you get so many people to blindly follow one leader and commit the atrocities of that war? You teach them this is the only way from a young age. You desensitize them to the cruelty. Is Werner being used? Sure but no more than anyone else is being used. And Werner certainly reaps benefits as well.
20. I think we have an answer now as to what happened to Marie-Laure’s father. Will he survive in the work camps?
This is heartbreaking. It was predictable though.
21.Back to 1944 again. I do like these flash forwards of sorts. What I keep wondering is what happened to Marie-Laure’s uncle and Madame Marec? How could they leave her in that house all alone, why couldn’t they take her with them? What do you think did they just forget her or is there a reason for her staying behind?
What I take from this is really how capable she is on her own.
22. This section ends on a cliffhanger, Sergeant Major von Rumpel is entering Marie-Laure’s house. What do you think he is after and will he get it?
The von Rumpel storyline is by far my least favorite. He is a disgusting person. I think it is clear he is after the stone.
23. Finally Marie-Laure gets to see the ocean. It seemed to have broken her out of the state she was in after her father left. What did you think of the letter her father send? Do you think she will believe a thing he wrote in there?
No I don't think she believes the letter but t does give her hope that he is alive.
24. Things at that school are getting worse too especially for Frederick. I applauded him for the way he reacted when he didn’t throw the water. What did you think? I keep hoping Werner will stand up for his friend and he does a little bit to help Frederick, but is it enough?
In some ways Frederick and Jutta are the same character. Both have firm beliefs and will not deviate from those beliefs no matter the consequences. When you look at Werner's decisions and choices as wonder why he doesn't stand up for Frederick and why does he go along with all that is asked of him look at how Frederick is treated. And this is a boy that comes from a powerful family. Imagine how Werner would be treated if he did the same.
19. Poor Frederick. I don’t like this school Werner is in. The teaching methods are brutal. I think Werner is being used by making these calculations and working on that radio. What could they want from him, what is he making?I have absolutely no idea what they're having him make, but I guess some sort of unmanned bomb/weapon or maybe a communication device?
20. I think we have an answer now as to what happened to Marie-Laure’s father. Will he survive in the work camps?
I hope he survives the camps, but I don't think it's likely. I was actually terrified he was somehow the prisoner they tortured at Werner's school!
21.Back to 1944 again. I do like these flash forwards of sorts. What I keep wondering is what happened to Marie-Laure’s uncle and Madame Marec? How could they leave her in that house all alone, why couldn’t they take her with them? What do you think did they just forget her or is there a reason for her staying behind?
I thought they had been forcefully evacuated or imprisoned, as Uncle Etienne looks up at the planes as they approach Saint-Malo. I wonder if Uncle Etienne thinks Madame has Marie-Laure and vice versa, or maybe Marie-Laure ran away and hid.
22. This section ends on a cliffhanger, Sergeant Major von Rumpel is entering Marie-Laure’s house. What do you think he is after and will he get it?
He's after the diamond, for sure. Maybe Marie-Laure will give it to him?
23. Finally Marie-Laure gets to see the ocean. It seemed to have broken her out of the state she was in after her father left. What did you think of the letter her father send? Do you think she will believe a thing he wrote in there?
I think he is lying and she knows he's lying. She's not a little girl, to believe his loving lies anymore.
24. Things at that school are getting worse too especially for Frederick. I applauded him for the way he reacted when he didn’t throw the water. What did you think? I keep hoping Werner will stand up for his friend and he does a little bit to help Frederick, but is it enough?
I think this is going to open/keep open Werner's eyes and going to help keep him from giving his soul to Hitler.
Mod
19. I'm sure you are right. Awful to think that kids so young were exposed to things like this
24. I quite like the contrast. It has made me wonder... what would I do?
--------
@S Napier
20. Oh me too!
Mod
19. Poor Frederick. I don’t like this school Werner is in. The teaching methods are brutal. I think Werner is being used by making these calculations and working on that radio. What could they want from him, what is he making?
There has been a lot made of these abilities so I think so
20. I think we have an answer now as to what happened to Marie-Laure’s father. Will he survive in the work camps?
I really hope so, but I just don't know. A few years there is hard to survive
21.Back to 1944 again. I do like these flash forwards of sorts. What I keep wondering is what happened to Marie-Laure’s uncle and Madame Marec? How could they leave her in that house all alone, why couldn’t they take her with them? What do you think did they just forget her or is there a reason for her staying behind?
I agree, there must be a reason she is there. I can only assume that Etienne is taken away as we know he won't leave the house. And maybe Madame dies? She is quite old
22. This section ends on a cliffhanger, Sergeant Major von Rumpel is entering Marie-Laure’s house. What do you think he is after and will he get it?
He is after the diamond, but I don't think he will discover it or her
23. Finally Marie-Laure gets to see the ocean. It seemed to have broken her out of the state she was in after her father left. What did you think of the letter her father send? Do you think she will believe a thing he wrote in there?
I don't think she will, but I like that he is trying to have her not worry
24. Things at that school are getting worse too especially for Frederick. I applauded him for the way he reacted when he didn’t throw the water. What did you think? I keep hoping Werner will stand up for his friend and he does a little bit to help Frederick, but is it enough?
I'm not sure, I think something awful will happen to Frederick now
DQ - March 24th The Rounds-East 241-32625. Hauptmann, Vokheimer and Werner are doing some experiments with transceivers. Why do you think they are doing this? Are they going to be looking for something?
26. We learn about Madame Manec's proposal for sabotage. If she approached you would you participate? How far do you think this group will go with this idea?
27. Harold shows Marie and Madame Manec a secret kennel and gives Marie a key. Why do you think he does this? In a later chapter he disappears. Do you think this has to do with the kennel and the key?
28. Marie and Madame Manec talk about pseudonyms. Marie - The Whelk and Madame - The Blade. What would your pseudonym be?
29. We discover what happened to Frederick. What are your feelings regarding this whole situation? Do you think he will ever recover?
30. We are introduced to the two Neumanns. What are your first impressions?
Mod
DQ - March 24th The Rounds-East 241-326
25. Hauptmann, Vokheimer and Werner are doing some experiments with transceivers. Why do you think they are doing this? Are they going to be looking for something?
I guess that will be Werner's job, to track down the patriots using radios to communicate
26. We learn about Madame Manec's proposal for sabotage. If she approached you would you participate? How far do you think this group will go with this idea?
I wondered this too. It is so hard to know what you would do in the same situation. I would like to think I'd be willing to help "the cause", but I have to say my first priority would more likely be keeping my family safe
27. Harold shows Marie and Madame Manec a secret kennel and gives Marie a key. Why do you think he does this? In a later chapter he disappears. Do you think this has to do with the kennel and the key?
I'm assuming Marie will hide the gem here later, or perhaps use this as a hiding spot? It is worrying how he disappears
28. Marie and Madame Manec talk about pseudonyms. Marie - The Whelk and Madame - The Blade. What would your pseudonym be?
Oh, nice question to ponder! May need to give me some time on that one :)
29. We discover what happened to Frederick. What are your feelings regarding this whole situation? Do you think he will ever recover?
Oh gosh this is just so completely sad and tragic. It had me wondering if it would've been kinder if they had actually killed him. He must be in so much pain, and probably without much pain relief
25. Hauptmann, Vokheimer and Werner are doing some experiments with transceivers. Why do you think they are doing this? Are they going to be looking for something?I think they were checking how far/how fast they can find radios. This may be for finding enemies' communication devices or, as Karen suggested, to find those using illegal radios.
26. We learn about Madame Manec's proposal for sabotage. If she approached you would you participate? How far do you think this group will go with this idea?
I love to think I would help, but I have young children and would probably not have enough courage. If my children were grown, there is a greater chance I would help, I think. I think this group is going to go as far as they can.
27. Harold shows Marie and Madame Manec a secret kennel and gives Marie a key. Why do you think he does this? In a later chapter he disappears. Do you think this has to do with the kennel and the key?
I think he does this to help Marie-Laure. It may very well be that he is arrested because he was helping the ladies' resistance.
28. Marie and Madame Manec talk about pseudonyms. Marie - The Whelk and Madame - The Blade. What would your pseudonym be?
Hmmm... The Juggler? LOL
29. We discover what happened to Frederick. What are your feelings regarding this whole situation? Do you think he will ever recover?
I could see this coming. I am most disgusted by his mother. Ugh. No, I don't think he'll recover.
30. We are introduced to the two Neumanns. What are your first impressions?
I don't have much of an impression yet, but don't really care for either of them. Things seem desperate in the German army.
DQ - March 24th The Rounds-East 241-32625. Hauptmann, Volkheimer and Werner are doing some experiments with transceivers. Why do you think they are doing this? Are they going to be looking for something?
I think they are practicing and trying out equipment to track people from the resistance who are broadcasting signals to each other or to allied forces.
26. We learn about Madame Manec's proposal for sabotage. If she approached you would you participate? How far do you think this group will go with this idea?
I’m not sure what I would do, I’d like to think I would participate but I’m not sure if I am willing to take that much risk. I think they, at least Madame Manec, will go far.
27. Harold shows Marie and Madame Manec a secret kennel and gives Marie a key. Why do you think he does this? In a later chapter he disappears. Do you think this has to do with the kennel and the key?
I’m not sure why he does this maybe it’s for Marie to hide when she needs it or he thinks the resistance can use it. It definitely has to do with the kennel and the key.
28. Marie and Madame Manec talk about pseudonyms. Marie - The Whelk and Madame - The Blade. What would your pseudonym be?
Hmmm….I don’t know. Like Karen I’d like to think about that one.
29. We discover what happened to Frederick. What are your feelings regarding this whole situation? Do you think he will ever recover?
I feel sad for him and I’m angry about the situation it shouldn’t have been the outcome for him. I don’t think he will recover, his brain injury seems permanent to me.
30. We are introduced to the two Neumanns. What are your first impressions?
I don’t have an impression really, I don’t think they are going to be important for the story. They were just a means of Werner getting to his destination.
March 25th DQ: One Ordinary Leaf-Delirium, pages 327-38331. Anthony Doerr has created an amazing sad, depressing, and eerie atmosphere by selecting his book to be about WWII. Are you getting caught up in the books atmosphere?
32. Now that we are towards the ending stretch of the book how are you feeling about the POV and time jumps? Has your option of it changed or evolved? Are you use to his style or confused by it? Do you enjoy it and it gives you certain information or keeps things a mystery?
33. We’ve learned more about the papers in the bread and how Marie-Laure will get the bread for her Uncle. He’s been communicating for small periods of time. His messages have been lasting longer. Do you think this is perhaps how he was caught?
34. The German, von Rumpel is on the mission of finding the stone. Do you think he will get it from Marie-Laure? Will he find out she is hiding above him?
35. Werner is in some serious weather and ethical conditions. The woman and girl he saw are now dead by his group. He is feeling sick by this, both psychologically and physically. What are your thoughts about how he might turn out after this event?
36. Marie-Laure and Werner have been separate in the story. Do you think their paths will cross?
Mod
31. I really like the atmosphere, the "feel" of the book. There has been so much written about WWII, but this still feels like a unique POV and story
32. The time jumps are confusing at times, but mainly because I've switched back to audio. I think the book works better not on audio. I do like the suspense it brings
33. Unfortunately, yes. And Werner is probably the one to catch him :(
34. Why can't he just die already?! lol. I hope he doesn't get it
35. This was hard. I think it brings it home, that even if you aren't the one holding the gun, you can still contribute to death
36. I think they have to. It would be kind of odd if they stayed separate
Mod
Thanks :D
Anthony Doerr has created an amazing sad, depressing, and eerie atmosphere by selecting his book to be about WWII. Are you getting caught up in the books atmosphere?I am. I really love how Doerr draws me in.
32. Now that we are towards the ending stretch of the book how are you feeling about the POV and time jumps? Has your option of it changed or evolved? Are you use to his style or confused by it? Do you enjoy it and it gives you certain information or keeps things a mystery?
I really like the jumps. They work well with the story, I think they fit in seamlessly.
33. We’ve learned more about the papers in the bread and how Marie-Laure will get the bread for her Uncle. He’s been communicating for small periods of time. His messages have been lasting longer. Do you think this is perhaps how he was caught?
Perhaps. Most likely. By Werner?
34. The German, von Rumpel is on the mission of finding the stone. Do you think he will get it from Marie-Laure? Will he find out she is hiding above him?
I think he will find out she's hiding above him, maybe. But he won't get the stone!
35. Werner is in some serious weather and ethical conditions. The woman and girl he saw are now dead by his group. He is feeling sick by this, both psychologically and physically. What are your thoughts about how he might turn out after this event?
I hope this horrible experience somehow changes him for the better. Maybe it will help him save Marie-Laure.
36. Marie-Laure and Werner have been separate in the story. Do you think their paths will cross?
I am no longer 100% sure!
I can write the questions!
March 25th DQ: One Ordinary Leaf-Delirium, pages 327-38331. Anthony Doerr has created an amazing sad, depressing, and eerie atmosphere by selecting his book to be about WWII. Are you getting caught up in the books atmosphere?
Definitely, I really like the style in which this book is written. I wasn’t sure if I wanted to read this book because I’ve read many books set during WWII, but I’m glad I did start. It is very different from the books I’ve read before.
32. Now that we are towards the ending stretch of the book how are you feeling about the POV and time jumps? Has your option of it changed or evolved? Are you use to his style or confused by it? Do you enjoy it and it gives you certain information or keeps things a mystery?
I still love them, they make sure the story doesn’t get boring and they keep the pace going.
33. We’ve learned more about the papers in the bread and how Marie-Laure will get the bread for her Uncle. He’s been communicating for small periods of time. His messages have been lasting longer. Do you think this is perhaps how he was caught?
Maybe, but I think his arrest may have more to do with the diamond.
34. The German, von Rumpel is on the mission of finding the stone. Do you think he will get it from Marie-Laure? Will he find out she is hiding above him?
He has to find her first and I think she has found a very good hiding place. I don’t think he will get it.
35. Werner is in some serious weather and ethical conditions. The woman and girl he saw are now dead by his group. He is feeling sick by this, both psychologically and physically. What are your thoughts about how he might turn out after this event?
I hope he is finally going to see past his fears for himself and his sister and put up a fight to do what he believes in.
36. Marie-Laure and Werner have been separate in the story. Do you think their paths will cross?
I think their paths will cross, how I don’t know, probably the Marie-Laure’s transmitter and Werner’s receiver will play a role.
Finished 3/22/15
♥♥♥♥I enjoyed this book more than I had anticipated. I typically don't reach for the historical fiction genre, but I thought I would give this one a shot based on the synopsis. My favorite part of the book as a whole was the eloquence with which the story was told. Doerr is a true artist.
Mod
Great, thanks!
DQs for March 26384-457
Water - Music #3
37. I loved the description of all Marie-Laure can hear (the paragraph before she begins broadcasting). As readers, we can only "hear" the story as well. Do you connect with Marie-Laure or feel as she might - being led through the story without being able to see it for yourself?
38. Do you think Von Rumpel would be looking so fervently for the diamond if he wasn't dying?
39. Werner makes the connection between Etienne's broadcasts when he was a child and the ones he's making now. What about this memory do you think inspired or triggered his decision to lie about having heard the broadcast? Why choose to defy his orders now?
40. Courage in the face of your fears is a common theme in this book. What did you think when Etienne finally left the house?
41. Marie-Laure has chosen to reveal her presence in the house. What do you think of her choice? How will these three stories come together?
Boy, what a place to stop! :)
message 83:
by
Karen ⊰✿, Fiction Aficionado
(last edited Mar 26, 2015 01:37AM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Mod
37. Nicely put, I think we are being led through the story and I can picture it all in my mind quite easily even though the author isn't overly descriptive which is quite clever
38. I didn't connect this earlier, but I find it funny someone in his position has belief in a tale like this. Or maybe it is more about he is hanging on to any possible hope? I find it hard to accept that anyone would want a stone to give eternal life but misery to those around you. What a piece of work he therefore must be!
39. I love this connection. I think his decision is actually about the mother and child that were killed. He can no longer hide the fact that what he does leads to people, including innocent people, being killed. This attachment to the broadcasts further enforces his feelings
40. I really felt for him, and also was so very pleased too. It shows how much love he had for Marie-Laure
41. Gosh this scared me. I can't comment more as I couldn't stop :o
37. I loved the description of all Marie-Laure can hear (the paragraph before she begins broadcasting). As readers, we can only "hear" the story as well. Do you connect with Marie-Laure or feel as she might - being led through the story without being able to see it for yourself? I love Marie-Laure's character. I do feel a connection to her, and I always feel I am being led through stories without being able to see them except on the canvas of my imagination.
38. Do you think Von Rumpel would be looking so fervently for the diamond if he wasn't dying?
No, though I don't know what he really expects will happen if he does find it. I also agree with Karen - he is a despicable person. But sickness makes people desperate.
39. Werner makes the connection between Etienne's broadcasts when he was a child and the ones he's making now. What about this memory do you think inspired or triggered his decision to lie about having heard the broadcast? Why choose to defy his orders now?
I think he remembered the feeling of innocence and hope. He wants to feel that way again and also maybe this will atone for the girl with red hair a bit?
40. Courage in the face of your fears is a common theme in this book. What did you think when Etienne finally left the house?
I was so proud of him. Amazing! I knew he had it in him.
41. Marie-Laure has chosen to reveal her presence in the house. What do you think of her choice? How will these three stories come together?
I think she is very, very brave. I am not sure how the stories will come together but I imagine Werner gets free and goes to save her... maybe!
CATCHING UP ON MY QUESTIONS (at work...shhh don't tell!)Questions: Bigger Faster Brighter-Brittany
8. Up to this point we've been introduced to Marie-Laure and Werner, and a big part of Doerr's story telling regards sound, Marie-Laure being blind most of her story is told through what she hears and smells, and Werner is capitvated by the radio, do you believe this has some significance?
I think Doerr is just trying to show how influential our other senses (specifically sound) can be, even though we primarily rely on sight. Sound plays an integral part in both of our main characters' lives.
9. What do you believe is the significance in Werner learning to build the radio and his fascination with the technical information in the French science program? Do you believe this will come to play as we learn more of what is happening in 1944? Do you believe the French science program will have significance should our two protagonists meet?
The program already connects the two characters on an intensely deep level.
10. We are beginning to see the start of War World II, Marie-Laure and her Father are on the run, and it seems like he may of the diamond with him. What do you believe this will mean for their family? Do you believe they will be cursed as the stories of the gem propose, is it truly magical will we see miracles with Marie-Laure and her eyesight? Or is it just a gem that can buy 5 Eiffel Towers?
I think the war and its effects will coincide with the gem and its curse. The gem isn't a healing stone so no one is getting "cured." Marie-Laure is stronger without her sight. I think the gem's worth is relative. Different people place different amounts of importance on its legend.
11. Back to 1944 we get a very short glimpse into this period, Werner is trapped and disoriented, Marie-Laurie can tell that her Uncle's house is on fire. All we see if negative things happening to these characters, what do you make of that? Do you believe Doerr is just trying to prepare the reader for the awful fate that awaits our protagonists or is something else? Do you feel more engaged with this break up of the chronology of the story?
I don't think Doerr is preparing us for anything. It is WWII. War is ugly, nothing is being glorified. He is building suspense. The break up of the chronology definitely keeps me on the edge of my seat wanting more.
12. Marie-Laure and her father arrive in Saint-Malo, Marie wishes she was really going back home to Paris but at the same time is intrigued by the new place they are in, what do you think Saint-Malo holds, it seems to be the final resting place for Marie-Laure in this story, is that good or bad? What significance do you think this holds for the diamond now that she is close to the Ocean?
I think Saint Malo holds a mystery and danger that we have yet to find out about. It is on the ocean which we know is Marie's favorite place. What that means for the stone, only time will tell.
Questions: Madame Manec-Museum14. Why do you think that Jutta questions what they're told, while Werner seems to accept it?
Werner doesn't accept anything, he's just not exactly confident enough to fight the system. He's protecting Jutta...self-preservation. Jutta isn't facing the mines, Werner has much more to fear and lose.
15. Marie-Laure's great-uncle is the one who broadcasts the program that Jutta & Werner heard. How do you think this will play into the story?
I don't knot yet, but I'm positive this is a critical connection.
16. Werner's fascination with technology made the test in the class easy for him and made the instructor take notice of him. Do you think that was a good thing? What do you think the outcome of this will be for him?
I think it will ultimately save him from the mines, but might make him more desirable to the Nazi Party. Which is the lesser of the two evils, only Werner can say.
17. Marie-Laure's neighbor in Saint-Malo sees her father measuring the street and buildings, finds this suspicious and plans on reporting him to the authorities. What do you think will happen to her father because of this and how does this make you feel towards that neighbor?
Unfortunately, I think her father will be imprisoned...even though he was completely pure of heart. It makes me loathe that neighbor, but at the same time he's just acting out of fear. This reminds me of the "If you see something, say something" ads post 9/11. People will say and do things they normally wouldn't when they feel threatened.
18. What thoughts do you have about the story now that we're a third into it? Any speculations about what will happen?
I'm in LOVE with this book, but I've finished it so my lips are sealed!
DQs for March 26384-457
Water - Music #3
37. I loved the description of all Marie-Laure can hear (the paragraph before she begins broadcasting). As readers, we can only "hear" the story as well. Do you connect with Marie-Laure or feel as she might - being led through the story without being able to see it for yourself?
I agree with Karen, I like the way we are being led through the story but with the room to add something from our own imagination.
38. Do you think Von Rumpel would be looking so fervently for the diamond if he wasn't dying?
I think he would be. He only started to believe in the stories after he was diagnosed and he was already hunting the diamond before that.
39. Werner makes the connection between Etienne's broadcasts when he was a child and the ones he's making now. What about this memory do you think inspired or triggered his decision to lie about having heard the broadcast? Why choose to defy his orders now?
I think this memory hit close to home and those broadcast were such a big part of his youth and ambitions but he was also starting to question everything that he was doing. The timing was perfect just then for him to defy his orders.
40. Courage in the face of your fears is a common theme in this book. What did you think when Etienne finally left the house?
To protect Marie-Laure, to help her. He loves her so much.
41. Marie-Laure has chosen to reveal her presence in the house. What do you think of her choice? How will these three stories come together?
I think it was the only thing she could do, besides lying down and die in hiding. It is such a brave decision.
Questions: The Wardrobe – Entropy19. Poor Frederick. I don’t like this school Werner is in. The teaching methods are brutal. I think Werner is being used by making these calculations and working on that radio. What could they want from him, what is he making?
He is definitely making some kind of communication or tracking device that will help them in the field.
20. I think we have an answer now as to what happened to Marie-Laure’s father. Will he survive in the work camps?
I would like to hope so, but I don't think he will.
21.Back to 1944 again. I do like these flash forwards of sorts. What I keep wondering is what happened to Marie-Laure’s uncle and Madame Marec? How could they leave her in that house all alone, why couldn’t they take her with them? What do you think did they just forget her or is there a reason for her staying behind?
They love her! Of course they didn't forget her!
22. This section ends on a cliffhanger, Sergeant Major von Rumpel is entering Marie-Laure’s house. What do you think he is after and will he get it?
The diamond! And I certainly hope not.
23. Finally Marie-Laure gets to see the ocean. It seemed to have broken her out of the state she was in after her father left. What did you think of the letter her father send? Do you think she will believe a thing he wrote in there?
That letter broke my heart. His description is beyond heartbreaking because we all know the camps were the complete horrific opposite of what he described. Marie-Laure is very realistic. I don't think she believes it, but I think she needs to.
24. Things at that school are getting worse too especially for Frederick. I applauded him for the way he reacted when he didn’t throw the water. What did you think? I keep hoping Werner will stand up for his friend and he does a little bit to help Frederick, but is it enough?
I admire Frederick so much. He is everything Werner wants to be. It made me cry when I read that section. I think Werner is protecting himself and his family as best he can. He isn't ready to speak out yet.
Mod
You're so right about Frederick. heartbreaking
DQ - March 24th The Rounds-East 241-32625. Hauptmann, Vokheimer and Werner are doing some experiments with transceivers. Why do you think they are doing this? Are they going to be looking for something?
They will be tracking down foreign/enemy receivers.
26. We learn about Madame Manec's proposal for sabotage. If she approached you would you participate? How far do you think this group will go with this idea?
I don't think I would participate. I'm a protector, not a fighter. I would be far too worried about the safety of my family. I feel like this is going to start small and snowball into something huge.
27. Harold shows Marie and Madame Manec a secret kennel and gives Marie a key. Why do you think he does this? In a later chapter he disappears. Do you think this has to do with the kennel and the key?
He recognizes the same adventurous spirit in Marie that Etienne used to have before the first war. He wants to give her a place of her own to escape. I don't think it had to do with his disappearance. The Germans most likely rounded him up for labor.
28. Marie and Madame Manec talk about pseudonyms. Marie - The Whelk and Madame - The Blade. What would your pseudonym be?
THE LION.
29. We discover what happened to Frederick. What are your feelings regarding this whole situation? Do you think he will ever recover?
This broke me. Frederick was such a brave soul. I have hope that over time, he'll look at a bird and for a brief moment he'll feel happy.
30. We are introduced to the two Neumanns. What are your first impressions?
UUUUUUGH! OBNOXIOUS!!! Werner is officially in war alongside war-time soldiers. He's not safe.
DQs FOR MARCH 27 Out-The End 458-53142. Why don't you think Werner escaped Saint-Malo with Marie-Laure? He could have easily changed clothes, discarded or burned his uniform, and fled with Marie-Laure without being recognized. Do you think it was atonement? Did he simply want to try to find Volkheimer? Why did he stay?
43. Marie-Laure gave Werner the key to her secret place on the beach. Did she want him to find the wooden house with the diamond? Did she actually leave the diamond in the house when she put it in the water? Was she testing Werner and his ability to resist temptation, or was she tempting fate and the curse?
44. We know that Werner went back to the secret beach cove and took Marie-Laure's little wooden house. However, later on he walks through a mine field and dies. IF Werner had the diamond, this means the curse would be broken, or never existed. The house was in his diffel bag. Did the diamond have to be ON you in order to keep you alive forever? Did he ever have it to begin with? And finally, WHY do you think he walked through that mine field? Was it suicide, or was he so ill it made him delusional?
45. Volkheimer's story ends with him alone, never married, sitting in front of an outdated television set. Eventually, he visits Jutta and her family to return Werner's belongings. What do you make of his story? Do you think he feels any remorse for the things he's done? Do you think he sees them as lives he's taken? Why do you think he was so nurturing to Max?
46. Finally, this beautiful book ends with Marie-Laure and her grandson. She's over 100 years old and still very active. Only one question: Do you think she kept the diamond and is the legend true?
47. Doerr concluded most of our main characters stories. Do you prefer that to an open-ending, where you can imagine the future you hope that character ends up with?
Mod
42. Why don't you think Werner escaped Saint-Malo with Marie-Laure? He could have easily changed clothes, discarded or burned his uniform, and fled with Marie-Laure without being recognized. Do you think it was atonement? Did he simply want to try to find Volkheimer? Why did he stay?
I don't think he could've kept up the pretence as his French was not good, and he was very Arian in appearance. I think he would've been a liability to Marie-Laure if he had stayed.
43. Marie-Laure gave Werner the key to her secret place on the beach. Did she want him to find the wooden house with the diamond? Did she actually leave the diamond in the house when she put it in the water? Was she testing Werner and his ability to resist temptation, or was she tempting fate and the curse?
I wondered about this myself. I'm assuming she took the diamond out of the house as she seemed to want Werner to confirm the house was in the water before they left. I'd love to hear other people's take on this
44. We know that Werner went back to the secret beach cove and took Marie-Laure's little wooden house. However, later on he walks through a mine field and dies. IF Werner had the diamond, this means the curse would be broken, or never existed. The house was in his diffel bag. Did the diamond have to be ON you in order to keep you alive forever? Did he ever have it to begin with? And finally, WHY do you think he walked through that mine field? Was it suicide, or was he so ill it made him delusional?
I didn't consider it suicide, but I may be wrong. And I don't believe in the curse anyway ;)
45. Volkheimer's story ends with him alone, never married, sitting in front of an outdated television set. Eventually, he visits Jutta and her family to return Werner's belongings. What do you make of his story? Do you think he feels any remorse for the things he's done? Do you think he sees them as lives he's taken? Why do you think he was so nurturing to Max?
I think he does and he tries to atone for it in small ways. There are many documented accounts of how people find themselves as "someone else" in times of war.
46. Finally, this beautiful book ends with Marie-Laure and her grandson. She's over 100 years old and still very active. Only one question: Do you think she kept the diamond and is the legend true?
No, I never considered she kept it and I don't think the legend is true otherwise her family should have been dead or in major trouble.
47. Doerr concluded most of our main characters stories. Do you prefer that to an open-ending, where you can imagine the future you hope that character ends up with?
It depends on the book. Generally I like questions answered and I like to see the future is in keeping with what we know of the characters. I didn't think it was necessary for this book to go so far into the future, it wouldn't have bothered me if it had finished where she and Werner parted ways.
Perhaps it went so far into the future to make you question whether or not she kept the diamond ;)
Mod
25. Hauptmann, Vokheimer and Werner are doing some experiments with transceivers. Why do you think they are doing this? Are they going to be looking for something?I think they are looking for "enemy" radio frequencies and locating them just like they did with Volkheimer at the school.
26. We learn about Madame Manec's proposal for sabotage. If she approached you would you participate? How far do you think this group will go with this idea?
I'm a wimp. I would not participate. I admit this makes me very nervous and I think she is foolish.
27. Harold shows Marie and Madame Manec a secret kennel and gives Marie a key. Why do you think he does this? In a later chapter he disappears. Do you think this has to do with the kennel and the key?
I think it so Marie has a safe place to go if necessary. I assumed he was imprisoned for his activities.
28. Marie and Madame Manec talk about pseudonyms. Marie - The Whelk and Madame - The Blade. What would your pseudonym be? Just call me Doctor.
29. We discover what happened to Frederick. What are your feelings regarding this whole situation? Do you think he will ever recover?
I think it was inevitable though the degree of his injuries was truly saddening. What is disgusting is that the school did nothing to stop it or to punish for it. Once again the cruelty that was the Reich horrifies me. No I do not think he will recover.
30. We are introduced to the two Neumanns. What are your first impressions? I think they are unimportant.
March 25th DQ: One Ordinary Leaf-Delirium, pages 327-38331. Anthony Doerr has created an amazing sad, depressing, and eerie atmosphere by selecting his book to be about WWII. Are you getting caught up in the books atmosphere?
The book is well written and paints a gut-wrenching portrait of war-time though I would argue any war time. We are well versed in the notion that the Germans are the "bad guys" but do not forget you could change the setting to Vietnam, Korea, Iraq, Afghanistan and see similar events by both the "good guys" and the bad. I read or heard somewhere recently "it is the victors that write history".
32. Now that we are towards the ending stretch of the book how are you feeling about the POV and time jumps? Has your option of it changed or evolved? Are you use to his style or confused by it? Do you enjoy it and it gives you certain information or keeps things a mystery?
I like the flashbacks. Honestly if the "current times" were done in true chronology it would've felt long winded. By breaking it up he is able to provide more detail and paint a better picture.
33. We’ve learned more about the papers in the bread and how Marie-Laure will get the bread for her Uncle. He’s been communicating for small periods of time. His messages have been lasting longer. Do you think this is perhaps how he was caught?
Perhaps. How brave he was to do this. Though I'm still not convinced it was smart.
34. The German, von Rumpel is on the mission of finding the stone. Do you think he will get it from Marie-Laure? Will he find out she is hiding above him?
I think this is an interesting portrait of someone who believes in the legend. He is clearly approaching death's door from lymphoma. I wonder if the disease has spread to his brain.
35. Werner is in some serious weather and ethical conditions. The woman and girl he saw are now dead by his group. He is feeling sick by this, both psychologically and physically. What are your thoughts about how he might turn out after this event?
This is the reason soldiers suffer from PTSD. I'll answer the question with a question. How is Volkheimer going to live with himself? He is such an interesting character to me. So gentle and kind in one moment and cold and heartless in the next. Is he just "doing his job?"
36. Marie-Laure and Werner have been separate in the story. Do you think their paths will cross?
Yes and it seems it is getting closer and closer.
Now that the book DQs have all been posted I'm going to remark on the book. I loved this book. I'm very pleased to read this book, even though it was a very sad book.
The atmosphere is just amazing. I felt the cold of the winter, the fear that Marie-Laure faced with her health impairment, and Werner in his dread.
I liked how the POVs switched and time shifts happened. It made some of the puzzle pieces come together and just give me a few carrots for wanting to find out more. It was also pretty clear when those changes would happen, which I like a lot when an author does that.
I also enjoyed how the story had more little twists and lines to follow. The stone made that a mystery. The storyline of Marie-Laure, Werner, and other characters.
The ending was had happy and sad moments.
Doerr did an amazing job. Great choice for the BoM.
42. Why don't you think Werner escaped Saint-Malo with Marie-Laure? He could have easily changed clothes, discarded or burned his uniform, and fled with Marie-Laure without being recognized. Do you think it was atonement? Did he simply want to try to find Volkheimer? Why did he stay?I think he was afraid of being caught with Marie-Laure. He could have escaped, but I think he felt it was too dangerous. Also, I think he wanted to go get the house. And I do think he wanted to find Volkheimer.
43. Marie-Laure gave Werner the key to her secret place on the beach. Did she want him to find the wooden house with the diamond? Did she actually leave the diamond in the house when she put it in the water? Was she testing Werner and his ability to resist temptation, or was she tempting fate and the curse?
I don't know. It didn't seem to me that she consciously gave him the key. Or perhaps she wanted the diamond to protect him? I think she left the diamond in the house.
44. We know that Werner went back to the secret beach cove and took Marie-Laure's little wooden house. However, later on he walks through a mine field and dies. IF Werner had the diamond, this means the curse would be broken, or never existed. The house was in his diffel bag. Did the diamond have to be ON you in order to keep you alive forever? Did he ever have it to begin with? And finally, WHY do you think he walked through that mine field? Was it suicide, or was he so ill it made him delusional?
I don't think he ever had the diamond. I think he put the key in the house, but for some reason left the diamond behind. I don't think it was suicide. I think he was at the end of his endurance and I think his mind broke.
45. Volkheimer's story ends with him alone, never married, sitting in front of an outdated television set. Eventually, he visits Jutta and her family to return Werner's belongings. What do you make of his story? Do you think he feels any remorse for the things he's done? Do you think he sees them as lives he's taken? Why do you think he was so nurturing to Max?
I think he was always a gentle giant who did what he had to do. I think he hated the things he had to do. I also wondered if he was in love with Werner...
46. Finally, this beautiful book ends with Marie-Laure and her grandson. She's over 100 years old and still very active. Only one question: Do you think she kept the diamond and is the legend true?
Ooh I didn't ponder that! No, I don't think she kept the diamond. I think she released it into the ocean. And no, I don't believe the legend. :)
47. Doerr concluded most of our main characters stories. Do you prefer that to an open-ending, where you can imagine the future you hope that character ends up with?
For this story, it was a satisfying ending. Some stories we don't need/want a wrap-up but for this story, I'm glad we know what happened to everyone.
Interesting theory about Volkheimer!!!! I definitely noticed a deep affection there but being in love hadn't occurred to me. I can see your theory!
DQs for March 26384-457
Water - Music #3
37. I loved the description of all Marie-Laure can hear (the paragraph before she begins broadcasting). As readers, we can only "hear" the story as well. Do you connect with Marie-Laure or feel as she might - being led through the story without being able to see it for yourself?
Because I am not blind I can still conjure images based on descriptions. Unles you are blind you cannot experience things as Marie would.
38. Do you think Von Rumpel would be looking so fervently for the diamond if he wasn't dying?
No. He clearly has his faith set in the legend of the stone. He views this as his only chance for survival. If it weren't for the disease I fully suspect he would be hiding somewhere to protect his cowardly butt.
39. Werner makes the connection between Etienne's broadcasts when he was a child and the ones he's making now. What about this memory do you think inspired or triggered his decision to lie about having heard the broadcast? Why choose to defy his orders now?
He is haunted by the little girl that was murdered earlier in the story. I think. This fuels his desire to make things right so to speak. Also to harm something so central to his youth would be to harm his sister and what was left of himself
40. Courage in the face of your fears is a common theme in this book. What did you think when Etienne finally left the house?
What power love has. Then I was irritated that the baker would ask him to take such a risk. Stupid stupid
41. Marie-Laure has chosen to reveal her presence in the house. What do you think of her choice? How will these three stories come together?
She was running out of options. Really a brave girl
Nothing But Reading Challenges
Books mentioned in this topic
All the Light We Cannot See (other topics)Snow Like Ashes (other topics)
All the Light We Cannot See (other topics)
haha
I'm really enjoying it too. I hadn't gone seeking much about it though so I didn't have any pre conceived ideas