The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
TASK HELP: Spring Challenge 2022
>
5.7 - The Flying Monkeys
date
newest »

Bea wrote: "I'm assuming natural animals like birds and butterflies would work as well as fantasy creatures."
of course
of course


Robin (Saturndoo) wrote: "Seeking approval for this one please. The wing, tail feathers and feet are there but the rest of the bird isn't.
"
I'm sorry, this won't work - the task calls for "a living creature with wings," not just a wing.

I'm sorry, this won't work - the task calls for "a living creature with wings," not just a wing.


Thank you!
Rebecca NJ wrote: "Although the birds are tiny, I am assuming this is enough to show a "living creature with wings."

Thank you!"
yes

Thank you!"
yes
Hannah wrote: "Would Beauty :
work? It has a fantasy bird-like creature sitting in the windowsill on the right."
yes, the body and the wing is visible

yes, the body and the wing is visible


Karen Michele wrote: "What do you think of this one? The bird is whole and you can see the head and the wing, but a part of the body is behind the other design on the cover. Enlarging the cover works best for seeing thi..."
I'm sorry, but even with enlarging, this does not clearly show a living creature with a wing
I'm sorry, but even with enlarging, this does not clearly show a living creature with a wing


Does this cover work?
Karen Michele wrote: "I'm going to double check my understanding of living creature since these birds are stylized:
The Plague of Doves
Does this cover work?"
that works

Does this cover work?"
that works


Julia wrote: "Does
work? The flag on the right and the tunic that the boy on the left is wearing both have the image of a horse with wings. (Since it's a picture on cloth does it stil..."
no, sorry, the picture won't work

no, sorry, the picture won't work
Julia wrote: "Would this work? It is very stylized, but I think it is a winged dragon.
Thanks!"
that works

Thanks!"
that works
Aprilleigh wrote: "Would the flamingo on this cover work?
"
sorry, no. the task calls for a living creature on the cover - that's a bookend.

sorry, no. the task calls for a living creature on the cover - that's a bookend.


sorry, no. the task calls for a living creature on the cover - that's a bookend."
Thanks for the quick response, Sandy. With the inclusion of fantasy creatures I wasn't sure how rigid the definition of living was meant to be and appreciate the clarification.
Marie (UK) wrote: "i know the birds are small but does this cover work
"
sure - they're birds and their wings are clearly visible.

sure - they're birds and their wings are clearly visible.
KmarieD wrote: "Does an obvious wing mean it needs to be flying or spread out? Would the bird on this cover work?
"
the wing is visible.

the wing is visible.
Sandy wrote: "KmarieD wrote: "Does an obvious wing mean it needs to be flying or spread out? Would the bird on this cover work?
"
the wing is visible."
Thank you.

the wing is visible."
Thank you.


Thanks!
Jen K wrote: "Would this work as a fantasy winged animal? The wing is clear but part of the creature is off cover.

Thanks!"
I'm sorry, but it's not at all clear that this is a living creature (as opposed to a painting of a part of a creature).

Thanks!"
I'm sorry, but it's not at all clear that this is a living creature (as opposed to a painting of a part of a creature).
Books mentioned in this topic
The Role of Birds in World War Two: How Ornithology Helped to Win the War (other topics)The Role of Birds in World War Two: How Ornithology Helped to Win the War (other topics)
The Thirty Names of Night (other topics)
The Thirty Names of Night (other topics)
Bluebird (other topics)
More...
Read a book with a living creature with wings showing on the cover. For purposes of this task, angels, demons, fantasy creatures/animals will work. The wings must be obviously shown on the cover.
REQUIRED: Post the cover in your post.