The Nerd Herd Book Club discussion

Then She Was Gone
This topic is about Then She Was Gone
19 views
February Books > The Group Read Check in! No spoilers, Please.

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

AvidReaderAmy (ambrix) | 74 comments Mod
I am still waiting for my copy from the library. However, I bet some of you have started reading already. (I'm a little jealous. ;) )
After you've had a chance to read a bit of the book, check in and tell us what you think. No spoilers, please.


Nick Amy have you received your copy yet ?!


AvidReaderAmy (ambrix) | 74 comments Mod
Nick, I just got a message from the library today saying that it's available to be picked up tomorrow. So I will start it tomorrow. Have you started reading it??


Nick Yes I have ! ☺️. I’m almost half way through !


Jenna (bookendbeans) | 13 comments I finished it last week. I’ll hold any thoughts until majority have read it.


Laurie Peterson | 33 comments I’ve just started part three and it is becoming a real page turner.


AvidReaderAmy (ambrix) | 74 comments Mod
I started the book. 50% through it. Even though I kind of see the end coming, I think I am enjoying the different perspectives, when a character's different point of view happens. In a way, I wonder if you are supposed to kind of know what happens. And the build up for the unsuspecting people is part of it? (Trying to say things with no spoilers. lol)


Laurie Peterson | 33 comments Done. And all I can say without spoilers is Oh. My. God. It got to the point that I could Not put this down. I was carrying it around and reading as I got ready for work. Wow


Nick I got done two days ago. Same lauri same 🤣


Natalia Frydrych | 5 comments I just finished it. And I really can't relate to your positive feedback, but maybe I will talk about it more with spoilers.


Jenna (bookendbeans) | 13 comments Oooph. I’ll be honest. I found it too predictable and had it figured out in the first 5 or so chapters. I read it in 2 days just to get to the end, hoping for some big twist and literally was bored the entire time. Don’t want to yuck on other’s yum. I’m glad others seemed to enjoy it.


message 12: by Nick (new) - rated it 3 stars

Nick I liked the majority of the book. But some things were just odd how they happened. I figured out some things early on about poppy but it wasn’t what I originally thought, which I was actually happy about . I was also dissatisfied with the ending. I think it could have been written another way lol.

Also I don’t think the writer had very much confidence tbh because the ending she stated it was a hot mess. Which I still think it was 🤣.

I Gave this book 3 stars since it did have me hooked for a good while .


Ashlee | 11 comments I wanted to love this book...but I didn't I heard so many positive reviews about Lisa Jewell but this was so slow for me and quite predictable. The big reveal and plot twist fell flat for me unfortunately.


back to top