Hardboiled American Crime and Worldwide Noir Fiction discussion
This topic is about
Fadeout
Past Noir Book Discussions
>
Fadeout by Joseph Hansen
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Dan, Hardboiled
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Nov 05, 2021 10:47AM
It's fairly short, but oh so easy to put down.
reply
|
flag
Wow, Dan, you and Bradley are brothers I take it?
Let's abandon subtly and mutual respect and go straight for the sneering disdain?
It's a good book and the character is much appreciated by a lot of readers. You just didn't like it was all. Let's treat it with a modicum of respect?
This is a reading discussion, not an assassination.
Let's abandon subtly and mutual respect and go straight for the sneering disdain?
It's a good book and the character is much appreciated by a lot of readers. You just didn't like it was all. Let's treat it with a modicum of respect?
This is a reading discussion, not an assassination.
Actually, I did like it. Goodreads defines three stars as liking the book. As for the rest, I'm confident Carmen knew I was not serious.
I always consider 3 stars as it was readable but. But thinking about it, 3 stars sits in the middle.
Many people use their own rating system rather than Goodreads guidelines. I am not one of them. Therefore, in precise alignment with GR, 1 star is didn't like it, 2 stars is it was okay, 3 stars is liked it, 4 stars is really liked it, and 5 stars is it was amazing. The advantage for me in using GR guidelines is that I maintain consistency in my ratings better over all my ratings. I am in alignment with other readers using the same standards, and I avoid evaluation inflation, a problem in all evaluation systems. My average rating for a work--GR calculates this--is 3.29.
Mines is 3.52 so we aint to far apart.
Books mentioned in this topic
Fadeout (other topics)Scream Black Murder (other topics)
Scream Black Murder (other topics)
Fadeout (other topics)
Fadeout (other topics)
More...


