The Fandoms discussion
Harry Potter
>
Out of all the deaths in Harry Potter, whose was the saddest? One person allowed ONLY, because I want to see you people suffer when choosing
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Mint
(new)
Jul 07, 2021 10:10AM
WARNING: THE COMMENTS WILL HAVE SPOILERS
reply
|
flag
Wait- Hermione? Oh that’s right… her character died in the 8th book when she became a helpless maiden in distress by the new writers just because she didn’t have her sweet Ron. Good one.
Watch the play if you can because she's better in the play than in the script :)
Also, probably Sirius for me. Though he's not my favorite character out of all the ones that died, his death hit me the hardest. He was the first major parental and supportive figure that Harry had and I felt like Harry deserved a good parent like him in his life, but just as he was getting to know Sirius, Sirius was stripped away from him :(
I will make sure to watch the play to see it. I also see your point of view with Sirius, I felt so bad for Harry when he died. The saddest death for me, personally, was Fred. I didn’t really understand why Rowling killed him, honestly I think she just wanted to shock the audience.
Is it bad that the only one that actually made me cry was Hedwig? 😭😭😭
Actually noI kinda cried when Hedwig died to tbh
Mary wrote: "Persephone wrote: "Is it bad that the only one that actually made me cry was Hedwig? 😭😭😭"I can’t rn 😂🖐"
😂 Okay, but to be fair I was 8 or 9 when I read book 7 and I definitely related to the animals and misfit characters the most, so Hedwig's death just hit me in a bad place 🥺💗
I am devastated when Fred died. I understand that Rowling thought it would be unrealistic to have all the Weasleys survive, but she could have killed off Percy instead! No one likes Percy lmao
I know!!! Separating Fred and George was so cruel :(((((
For me it is easy to choose. I cry a lot for everyone but I "died" with my lovely Sirius
Tonks, she was my favourite character & person in the books and the movies.
Sirius!
In the movies it was dumbledore but the books it was Sirius
I have half a mind to make a couple more accounts just so I can name them all
Lupin but i think he was kinda happy to be dead
Lita wrote: "Lupin but i think he was kinda happy to be dead"While he might have been depressed, he was married to Tonks - or was he? not so sure now. (Re: Tonks - see my most devastating death, even off the page above) and had a child, so I cannot see him happy to be dead.
Ingo wrote: "Lita wrote: "Lupin but i think he was kinda happy to be dead"While he might have been depressed, he was married to Tonks - or was he? not so sure now. (Re: Tonks - see my most devastating death,..."
He was merried but i think he was so tired, and Tonks is on the second place of sadest one
Ohh..Snape's death was really sad too...
And Lupin's too...all the deaths were sad
Maura wrote: "And Lupin's too...all the deaths were sad"
I cried for all deaths beside snapes.
Despite him trying to make up for what he did, bringing up what his mother did or didn't do for him and making Harry Miserable during his school times was wrong. And I feel like snap was an un-needed character.
I cried for all deaths beside snapes.
Despite him trying to make up for what he did, bringing up what his mother did or didn't do for him and making Harry Miserable during his school times was wrong. And I feel like snap was an un-needed character.
Fred, easily, imagine having someone who (in their case) looked and acted exactly like you, and loosing them.
*me realsiing how many deaths occured in HP*
ummm i’m sorry but i gotta say Dobby’s death killed me the most but Fred was a close one
fred. hands-down. why did she have to separate the twins? the twins were my favorite characters and i get way too depressed about fred's death...
Dobby. Such a sweet, innocent annoying thing...*sob*
Tonks, my favourite person in both the books and the movies. Hoping for the next TV-series.
Tonks. But then in the play Hermione. I despise that play. I won’t count her as dead
