Please separate these two editions

[BRNTerri]

Goodreads has combined these two ISBNs and I'm asking for someone to separate them as they're obviously two different books. ISBNs are: 9781435158153 and 9780517214534.

[rivka, Former Moderator]

Goodreads policy is to combine illustrated editions with non-illustrated ones.

[BRNTerri]

rivka wrote: "Goodreads policy is to combine illustrated editions with non-illustrated ones."

Why is that? I want to list 9781435158153 but it tells me I already have it listed, which I don't.

[Scott]

Because the text is the same.

If you want to add a new edition to your shelves, you can click "review this edition", then you will have both.

[BRNTerri]

Scott wrote: "Because the text is the same.

If you want to add a new edition to your shelves, you can click "review this edition", then you will have both."

It doesn't say "review this edition" anywhere when I'm looking at ISBN 9781435158153.

[Scott]

Sorry, it will probably say "review leather bound", right above your activity section.

[BRNTerri]

Thanks. I clicked on "review leather bound" even though I don't want to review it yet and it allowed me to add it to whichever shelves I wanted, so I did.

[Scott]

"Review" in this case is just a general term meaning adding to your shelves, rating, or writing an actual review. Basically any activity at all.