This is a really specific recommendation

[eliseisinarchenland]

Are there any books that are sort of like We Were Liars...with preppy, old money, Martha's Vineyard kind of setting? I feel like I'm craving one right now (if you can crave books :)

[Cintia]

I can give you some similar ones,
Genuine Fraud (same author)
Charm & Strange
Belzhar
There Will Be Lies
Vanishing Girls
Imaginary Girls
Damage Done
Special Topics in Calamity Physics
Dangerous Girls
Choker
Liar
Rosie Girl
Flat-Out Love
Save Yourself
When You Reach Me
Little Fires Everywhere
The Adoration of Jenna Fox
Emma in the Night
Little Monsters
One of Us Is Lying
Be True to Me
A Map for Wrecked Girls

[eliseisinarchenland]

Cintia wrote: "I can give you some similar ones,
Genuine Fraud (same author)
Charm & Strange
Belzhar
There Will Be Lies
[book:Vanishing Girls|224655..."

Wow! Thank you so much! I'll be sure to look into these