Howl's Moving Book Club discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
7 views
One of Us is Lying Duology > One Of Us Is Lying

Comments Showing 51-84 of 84 (84 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
ok. finally caught up.
I don't know what to think, really. no one's suspicious to me. I've ended up thinking it was either the person in/ relating to the car crash, organising something to distract Mr. Avery, could have been Maeve, Janae? But Janae doesn't seem the type to murder someone to get some kind of revenge.
could have just been Simon, wanting to plant all of this drama, or like he didn't want to continue on with things?
I don't know. I'm not a thinker, I don't tend to actually think about what's going on in books and more what's happening then.
so yeah, terrible update over...


message 52: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments I think the car crash was planned too and wondering if maybe Simon just committed a detailed suicide???


message 53: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
It's plausible. I can see why people enjoy the book though.
sometimes I do have to head back and check who's point of view it is.
also, they didn't know each other well before the detention, and, ignoring lawyer advice, they've decided to start talking to one another in 'groups'.
(Addy, Bronwyn and Cooper, then sometimes just Bronwyn and Nate, or Addy and Cooper).
I don't get that bit.
I'm enjoying the legal perspective of this as well. Like their charges, possible defences, this is fun.
(or at least, it is to me anyway).


message 54: by maryam (new)

maryam aishah :) | 476 comments OK BUT GUYS ON THE COVER OF ONE OF US IS NEXT THERES ONLY THREE OF THEM AND YES I GET IT ONE OF THEM IS NEXT BUT IT LOOKS LIKE ADDY BRONWYN AND SOME UNIDENTIFIED MALE BUT WHO IS IT BC I SHIP BRONWYN AND NATE SOOOOOO HARD BUT I WANT COOPER TO LIVE AND BE HAPPY WITH KRIS

(I'm sorry, I sent this at 2am. I might be going crazy)


message 55: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
DON'T WORRY! WHO HAS A NORMAL SLEEP SCHEDULE ANYWAY (hint: not me).
looking at the cover now, I mean, I'm not finished with OOUIL yet and it's a first time read for me.
but I've *accidentally on purpose* read like the first few sentences of the epilogue and it could be this Evan guy? might be being completely illogical or something because I don't actually know who he is yet.

speaking of OOUIN, are we reading that straight after OOUIL or waiting for a bit so people can read their own stuff as well?


message 56: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
is it Evan? his name? or was it something else.


message 57: by maryam (new)

maryam aishah :) | 476 comments OMG I HADNT CONSIDERED THAT ZAYNAB THERES NO HOPE OF ME GETTING SLEEP NOW


message 58: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments YO I HIGHKEY GASPED WHEN COOPER KISSED KRIS I WAS LIKE EEEEEEEEEE


message 59: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments also maybe wait like a day or 2 for the next one??? I'm not busy and I really like it so far


message 60: by Kara (new)

Kara (kablesreads) | 348 comments Mod
Zaynab I literally told you not to look at the ending 🤦🏻‍♀️😂
It’s very interesting seeing all your ideas.


message 61: by [deleted user] (new)

Me and my friend likes looking at the last word in a book, coz curiosity killed the cat, and she ended up spoiling the ending. I also love seeing these theories


message 62: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
KARA! IT WAS.... *ACCIDENTAL* (insert our most liked emoji- just me that can't put emojis in through my phone?).


message 63: by Kara (new)

Kara (kablesreads) | 348 comments Mod
Do you mean this one (let’s hope it shows up....) 😏😏😏


message 64: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
yuppidy doodah. in other news. i have no idea what I'm meant to be doing right now. (insert our most used emoji here).


message 65: by [deleted user] (new)

I cant insert emojis either zaynab


message 66: by maryam (new)

maryam aishah :) | 476 comments "our most used emoji" I CANT ZAYNAB-


message 67: by [deleted user] (new)

I love how they knew tho lol thst the one i almost sent my teacher!!!


message 68: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
(insert laughing emoji here)


message 69: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments this is excruciatingly frustrating because all I want is Nate and Bronwyn and Kris and Cooper to be happy but it's nOt happening


message 70: by maryam (new)

maryam aishah :) | 476 comments No but this book
I had short hair when I was we nine. Looked awful.
BUT THIS BOOK IS MAKING ME THINK ABOUT CUTTING MY HAIR SHORT NOW BC OF ADDY


message 71: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
so- Addy wanted to be bald? but the hairdresser was like 'nope' so she did it herself?
also the tolerance of that hairdresser once she cut her hair like that.


message 72: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments also Nate needs a lawyerrrrrrr


message 73: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments such a power move though lol her character arc is *chef's kiss*


message 74: by Kara (new)

Kara (kablesreads) | 348 comments Mod
Do people mind if I finish the book tonight? 😂


message 75: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
no. if it's good, imma finish tonight as well.


message 76: by maryam (new)

maryam aishah :) | 476 comments I'm gonna go ahead and finish tonight too then. Do we know when we're starting One of Us is Next?


message 77: by Kara (new)

Kara (kablesreads) | 348 comments Mod
No idea, wait just a moment.....


message 78: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments my hold on OOUIN has 2 weeks left supposedly but it could be shorter depending on the other people in line for it


message 79: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments OKAY I feel like it's Jake but that seems too simple???


message 80: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments for some reason my review says I gave it one star but my phone is just ~malfunctioning~


message 81: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
I can't say. I'm incredibly behind on me reading schedule.


message 82: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
Agh!
excuse me, I'm very behind...
Jake's a suspect????
wha-
-me out-


message 83: by Liesel :D (new)

Liesel :D (itsliberty) | 436 comments where are you in the book lol


message 84: by Zaynab (new)

Zaynab (abitbookishhh) | 722 comments Mod
just about to start the last section. the bit where Addy says she told Jake the Bayview Four were all in the interview room together but they weren't.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.