Clean YA Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Monthly Group Nominations
>
CLOSED - February 2021 BOTM Nominations
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Ann T, Adult Moderator
(new)
Dec 24, 2020 03:21PM

reply
|
flag

I've been wanting to read that! And its one that is actually at my library for once 😂

Being new-ish, I couldn't find much on if its clean or not. This is what I could find:
Content: Magic, mild violence, and some name calling. DUST does include some “dark” moments for a character (however, they’re not super dark and light/truth prevails).
Message/theme: The message and themes are positive, deep and beautiful.
Mia wrote: "Also, I'll nominate Dust :)
Being new-ish, I couldn't find much on if its clean or not. This is what I could find:
Content: Magic, mild violence, and some name calling. DUST does ..."
Yes, I know of that author and I would assume her books are clean. It looks really good!! 😃
Being new-ish, I couldn't find much on if its clean or not. This is what I could find:
Content: Magic, mild violence, and some name calling. DUST does ..."
Yes, I know of that author and I would assume her books are clean. It looks really good!! 😃

My library has this as well, I look forward to finally reading it.
We are looking for two more nominations. Clarabelle, Allyson, and I will review ratings and content for the current nominations which are:
The Delusion: We All Have Our Demons
The Night Circus
Dust
The Delusion: We All Have Our Demons
The Night Circus
Dust

My sister said this was good but I have not read it yet.

It seems kinda interesting to me and reminds be of a book trilogy so I'm hoping for the best.
Here's what a reviewer said on the content:
"I teach 8th grade and this is certainly appropriate for 8th graders. I don't remember any foul language at all, there's only one kiss and a hug, but there's plenty of violence and drug use. There's one scene where some teenagers drink a little and one parent figure is heavily addicted to drugs. All that said, I'd encourage teens to read it and hope to teach it in my class someday."
sumayyah wrote: "Allyson wrote: "Wow! That book looks really good!!"
Right?! I sense a new favorite author :P"
I don't know! Can it top Jennifer Nielsen?? 😂
Right?! I sense a new favorite author :P"
I don't know! Can it top Jennifer Nielsen?? 😂

Nominations are closed. We have more than 5 books, I have included all books in poll.
It was really hard this month as most books had something that our group wouldn't consider as clean. However, one didn't seem worse than others. So, I have provided by best interpretations of what I found.
Please see the comment in the voting poll. If the book isn't mentioned, then I considered it a CLEAN read. Please review on your own the books, ratings, and content, to decide if this book if for you.
It was really hard this month as most books had something that our group wouldn't consider as clean. However, one didn't seem worse than others. So, I have provided by best interpretations of what I found.
Please see the comment in the voting poll. If the book isn't mentioned, then I considered it a CLEAN read. Please review on your own the books, ratings, and content, to decide if this book if for you.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Glimpse (other topics)Ship Breaker (other topics)
P.S. I Like You (other topics)
The Delusion: We All Have Our Demons (other topics)
The Night Circus (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Claire Merle (other topics)Paolo Bacigalupi (other topics)